Business Overview: CTO Realty Growth, Inc. (NYSE: CTO)

---

Executive Summary

CTO Realty Growth is a self-managed equity REIT that owns, manages, and repositions retail and mixed-use commercial real estate concentrated in faster-growing, business-friendly Sun Belt and secondary markets. As of December 31, 2025, the company's core portfolio consisted of 21 income-producing properties totaling 5.5 million square feet of gross leasable area across seven states, anchored by 17 open-air shopping centers such as Carolina Pavilion (Charlotte, NC), The Collection at Forsyth (Cumming, GA), and Ashley Park (Newnan, GA). Beyond direct property ownership, CTO runs two additional, capital-light lines of business: a fee-based Management Services platform — most notably its external management of Alpine Income Property Trust (NYSE: PINE), a net-lease REIT in which CTO also holds a 15.4% ownership stake — and a Commercial Loans & Investments book of mortgage and preferred-equity positions secured by real estate.

The business model centers on active portfolio "repositioning": acquiring value-add shopping centers below replacement cost, driving occupancy and rent growth through leasing and re-tenanting, and periodically recycling capital out of lower-growth single-tenant net-lease assets (often via Section 1031 exchanges) into higher-growth multi-tenant retail. Fiscal 2025 demonstrated this playbook in action — $144.9 million of shopping-center acquisitions funded in part by $85.1 million of dispositions (including a $78.0 million sale of a Plano, Texas center for a $19.8 million gain) — alongside record portfolio-wide leased occupancy of 95.9% and a 24% average cash rent spread on new and renewal leases.

The single most decision-relevant fact for investors is that CTO is a modestly sized, externally levered REIT (net debt of roughly 6.4x pro forma Adjusted EBITDA) trading at a high dividend yield (~7.3%) that exceeds its AFFO payout ratio comfortably (2025 AFFO of $1.97/share versus a $1.52 annualized dividend), giving the payout a reasonable cushion — but GAAP net income remains thin ($2.6 million, or $0.08/diluted share, in 2025) because of heavy depreciation and episodic gains/losses on asset recycling, meaning the stock's investment case rests almost entirely on FFO/AFFO growth and continued execution of the acquisition-and-lease-up strategy rather than on GAAP earnings.

---

1. Core Business Model & How They Work

CTO earns the bulk of its revenue as a traditional shopping-center landlord: it collects base rent, percentage rent, and expense reimbursements from national, regional, and local retail tenants under multi-year leases, then reinvests in acquisitions, redevelopment, and leasing to grow rental income per share over time. Layered on top of this core landlord business are two fee- and yield-generating adjacencies that diversify cash flow without requiring proportional balance-sheet growth.

Key Operational Drivers

1. Value-Add Shopping Center Acquisitions — CTO targets multi-tenant retail in supply-constrained, population- and job-growth markets, typically acquiring centers with below-market rents or occupancy upside, then re-leasing space at a premium (671,000 square feet leased in 2025 at a record 24% average cash rent spread).
2. External Management of Alpine Income Property Trust (PINE) — CTO manages PINE's net-lease portfolio for a fee (1.5% of total equity, stepping down to 0.75% on incremental equity), generating $4.8 million of management fee income in 2025 with minimal incremental capital, while its 15.4% PINE ownership stake (~$41.3 million) provides additional dividend income and alignment.
3. Commercial Loans & Investments — a $118.1 million book of commercial mortgage loans and preferred equity secured by real estate, typically 1–10 year terms with floating or fixed rates, generating $12.5 million of interest income in 2025 and serving as a bridge to eventual property ownership or capital recycling.
4. Capital Recycling via 1031 Exchanges — CTO periodically sells single-tenant net-lease assets (constrained by a Right of First Offer Agreement favoring PINE) and non-core land/subsurface interests, redeploying proceeds tax-efficiently into higher-growth multi-tenant retail.
5. Leverage and Distribution Discipline — the company funds growth with a mix of unsecured debt (~$618.8 million at a 4.3% weighted average rate) and equity, targeting an AFFO payout ratio that leaves room for dividend growth (2026 guidance of $2.11–$2.16 AFFO/share against a $1.52 current annualized dividend).

---

2. Business Segments

CTO organizes its business into three reportable/operating components:

• Income Properties — the core owned real estate portfolio (21 properties, 5.5M square feet, 7 states), generating $132.2 million of 2025 revenue, or roughly 88% of the total.
• Management Services — fee income from externally managing PINE and other third-party/asset-management arrangements plus subsurface interest management, generating $4.8 million of 2025 revenue.
• Commercial Loans & Investments — interest income from a portfolio of commercial mortgage loans and preferred equity investments secured by real estate, generating $12.5 million of 2025 revenue.

---

3. Product Portfolio

---

4. Competitive Landscape

CTO competes for acquisitions and tenants against a broad universe of larger, better-capitalized shopping-center REITs and private institutional buyers. In its own 10-K, the company acknowledges facing competitors with "substantially larger" scale and "considerably greater financial, technical and marketing resources," meaning CTO's edge must come from underwriting discipline, market selection, and hands-on leasing execution rather than sheer capital availability. Its small size (roughly $650–700 million equity market capitalization) relative to sector leaders limits its ability to compete for the largest institutional-quality portfolios and can result in a higher cost of capital during periods of market stress.

Key Competitors:

• Regency Centers, Kite Realty Group, and Site Centers (larger publicly traded grocery-anchored/open-air shopping center REITs)
• Urstadt Biddle-type regional retail landlords and other privately held or non-traded retail REITs
• Private equity real estate funds and institutional buyers (e.g., Blackstone-affiliated vehicles) competing for the same value-add retail acquisitions
• Local/regional developers and family-office owners in CTO's target Sun Belt submarkets

CTO differentiates less through unique tenant relationships and more through disciplined market selection (population and job growth corridors), a repositioning-focused acquisition strategy, and the capital-light fee income from managing PINE — but none of these create a durable structural barrier against larger, lower-cost-of-capital competitors.

---

5. Strategic Strengths & Risks

Competitive Strengths (The Moat)

• Record leased occupancy (95.9%) and strong releasing spreads (24% average cash rent spread in 2025) demonstrate execution skill in identifying and improving undermanaged retail assets.
• Diversified, capital-light fee income stream from managing PINE, which grows with PINE's equity base without requiring CTO balance-sheet capital.
• Disciplined capital recycling (1031 exchanges) that allows CTO to upgrade portfolio quality and growth profile over time without diluting shareholders as heavily as a pure-acquisition REIT.
• Concentration in Sun Belt/business-friendly markets with favorable demographic and job-growth tailwinds relative to slower-growing regions.

Strategic Risks & Vulnerabilities

1. Small scale relative to peers — a sub-$1 billion equity market cap limits access to the lowest-cost capital and the largest deal opportunities, and management itself flags "substantially larger" competitors.
2. Elevated leverage — net debt of ~6.4x pro forma Adjusted EBITDA is a meaningful debt load for a company of this size, and $618.8 million of borrowings at a 4.3% weighted-average rate leaves refinancing-rate sensitivity if rates rise or credit spreads widen.
3. Retail tenant/lease-rollover risk — 8.5% of gross annual rents expire in 2026 and 19.9% (the peak year) in 2028; a weakening retail environment could pressure releasing spreads and occupancy that are currently at record highs.
4. Related-party/structural constraints with PINE — the Right of First Offer Agreement limits CTO's ability to independently pursue single-tenant net-lease acquisitions, tying a portion of its growth optionality to PINE's own capital-raising capacity.
5. Thin GAAP earnings — net income of just $2.6 million ($0.08/share) in 2025 means the stock's total-return case depends almost entirely on FFO/AFFO growth and dividend sustainability rather than GAAP profitability, which can be more volatile due to gains/losses on property sales.

---

6. Financial Overview

---

7. Summary Conclusion

CTO Realty Growth is a small-cap, actively managed shopping-center REIT that has built a differentiated, capital-light hybrid model — direct property ownership layered with fee income from externally managing Alpine Income Property Trust and a supplemental commercial-lending book. Its 2025 results showed genuine operational strength: record occupancy, strong rent-growth spreads, and disciplined capital recycling that funded accretive shopping-center acquisitions. However, the company remains structurally disadvantaged versus larger, lower-cost-of-capital shopping-center REIT peers, carries meaningful leverage (~6.4x net debt/EBITDA), and generates only thin GAAP earnings, leaving FFO/AFFO growth and continued execution of its Sun Belt repositioning strategy as the primary levers for total shareholder return. The ~7.3% dividend yield appears reasonably well covered today, but investors are effectively underwriting management's ability to keep sourcing accretive acquisitions and managing lease rollover in a more competitive, higher-rate environment.