6-K 1 ft6k.htm FRANCE TELECOM FORM 6-K Consolidated financial statements




UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

Washington, DC 20549


FORM 6-K


REPORT OF FOREIGN PRIVATE ISSUER

PURSUANT TO RULE 13a-16 OR 15d-16 OF

THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934


March 5, 2009

Commission File No. 1-14712


 

FRANCE TELECOM

(Translation of registrant’s name into English)

 


6, place d’Alleray, 75505 Paris Cedex 15, France

(Address of principal executive offices)

 


Indicate by check mark whether the Registrant files or will file

annual reports under cover of Form 20-F or Form 40-F

Form 20-F

Form 40- F


Indicate by check mark whether the Registrant is submitting the

Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(1):

Yes

No


Indicate by check mark whether the Registrant is submitting the

Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(7):

Yes

No


Indicate by check mark whether the Registrant, by furnishing the

information contained in this Form, is also thereby furnishing the information to the

Commission pursuant to Rule 12g3-2(b) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934

Yes

No


(If “Yes” is marked, indicate below the file number assigned to the

Registrant in connection with Rule 12g3-2(b): 82- )


 







Consolidated financial statements






Avertissement

Cette traduction anglaise des comptes consolidés rédigés en langue française a été préparée pour le confort des lecteurs anglophones. Malgré tout le soin apporté à cette traduction, certaines erreurs, omissions ou approximations peuvent y subsister. France Télécom, ses représentants et ses salariés n’en assumeront aucune responsabilité.


Disclaimer

This English language translation of the consolidated financial statements prepared in French has been prepared solely for the convenience of English speaking readers. Despite all the efforts devoted to this translation, certain errors, omissions or approximations may subsist. France Telecom, its representatives and employees decline all responsibility in this regard.




Year ended December 31, 2008








CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT

4

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET

5

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY

7

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS

9

SEGMENT INFORMATION

11

Note 1 - Description of business and basis of preparation of the consolidated financial statements

16

Note 2 - Accounting Policies

22

Note 3 - Main acquisitions, disposals of companies and changes in scope of consolidation

39

Note 4 - Revenues

43

Note 5 - Operating income and expenses

44

Note 6 - Impairment

46

Note 7 - Gains and losses on disposals of assets

50

Note 8 - Restructuring costs

51

Note 9 - Finance costs, net

52

Note 10 - Income tax

54

Note 11 - Goodwill

58

Note 12 - Other intangible assets

59

Note 13 - Property, plant and equipment

61

Note 14 - Interests in associates

63

Note 15 - Assets available for sale

65

Note 16 - Inventories

66

Note 17 - Loans and receivables

67

Note 18 - Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss

69

Note 19 - Other assets and prepaid expenses

70

Note 20 - Equity

71

Note 21 - Financial liabilities and net financial debt

75

Note 22 - Derivative instruments

83

Note 23 - Employee benefits

87

Note 24 - Provisions

94

Note 25 - Other liabilities and deferred income

97


2



Note 26 - Other information relating to share-based payment and similar compensation

98

Note 27 - Other information on exposure to market risks and financial instruments

103

Note 28 - Other information on the fair value of financial assets and liabilities

112

Note 29 - Off-balance sheet commitments and contractual obligations

114

Note 30 - Litigation

120

Note 31 - Related-party transactions

126

Note 32 - Subsequent events

129

Note 33 - Fees paid to statutory auditors

130

Note 34 - Scope of consolidation

131



3



Back to Contents



CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT

Amounts in millions of euros (except for per-share data)


   

Period ended

Period ended

  

Note

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

Revenues

 

4

53,488

52,959

External purchases

 

5

(23,652)

(23,156)

Other operating incomes

 

5

380

440

Other operating expenses

 

5

(2,258)

(2,360)

Labour expenses:

- Wages and employee benefit expenses

5

(8,559)

(8,767)

 

- Employee profit-sharing

5

(319)

(359)

 

- Share-based compensation

5

(82)

(279)

Depreciation and amortization

 

12-13

(7,776)

(8,111)

Impairment of Goodwill

 

6

(271)

(26)

Impairment of non-current assets

 

6

(9)

(107)

Gains (losses) on disposal of assets

 

7

11

769

Restructuring costs

 

8

(470)

(208)

Share of profits (losses) of associates

 

14

(211)

4

Operating income

  

10,272

10,799

Interest expenses, net

 

9

(2,766)

(2,521)

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

 

9

(63)

(4)

Discounting expense

 

9

(158)

(125)

Finance costs, net

  

(2,987)

(2,650)

Income tax

 

10

(2,793)

(1,330)

Consolidated net income

  

4,492

6,819

Net income attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A.

 

4,069

6,300

Minority interests

 

20

423

519

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

Earnings per share
(in euros)

 

20

 

 

   

 

 

Net income attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A.

 

 

 

- basic

  

1.56

2.42

- diluted

  

1.54

2.36

     

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements




4



Back to Contents



CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET

  (Amounts in millions of euros)


 

 

Note

At December 31, 2008

At December 31,
2007 (1)

   

 

 

ASSETS

  

 

 
 

Goodwill

11

30,811

31,389

 

Other Intangible assets

12

14,451

16,658

 

Property, plant and equipment

13

26,534

27,849

 

Interests in associates

14

172

282

 

Assets available for sale

15

203

518

 

Non-current loans and receivables

17

1,554

1,960

 

Non-current financial assets at fair value through profit or loss

18

106

54

 

Non-current hedging derivatives assets

22

624

42

 

Other non-current assets

19

32

63

 

Deferred tax assets

10

5,142

7,273

 

Total non-current assets

 

79,629

86,088

   

 

 
 

Inventories

16

976

1,068

 

Trade receivables

17

6,163

6,556

 

Current loans and other receivables

17

63

81

 

Current financial assets at fair value through profit or loss, excluding cash equivalents

18

721

534

 

Current hedging derivatives assets

22

75

12

 

Other current assets

19

2,143

2,035

 

Current tax assets

10

144

111

 

Prepaid expenses

19

581

673

 

Cash and cash equivalents

17&18

4,800

4,025

 

Total current assets

 

15,666

15,095

   

 

 

TOTAL ASSETS

 

95,295

101,183

     

(1) Complementary information regarding the effects of the implementation of IFRIC 13 on the balance sheet : see note 1.

     

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements





5



Back to Contents



CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET

  (Amounts in millions of euros)


 

 

Note

At December 31, 2008

At December 31,
2007 (1)

EQUITY AND LIABILITIES

 

 

 
 

Share capital

 

10,460

10,457

 

Additional paid-in capital

 

15,325

15,317

 

Retained earnings

 

1,958

2,532

 

Cumulative translation adjustment

 

-143

1,747

 

Equity attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A.

 

27,600

30,053

   

 

 
 

Minority interests

 

3,598

4,470

 

Total equity

20

31,198

34,523

   

 

 
 

Non-current trade payables

21

498

435

 

Non-current financial liabilities at amortized cost, excluding trade payables

21

31,782

32,532

 

Non-current financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss

21

495

154

 

Non-current hedging derivatives liabilities

21

650

955

 

Non-current employee benefits

23

559

535

 

Non-current provisions

24

1,262

1,657

 

Other non-current liabilities

25

711

870

 

Deferred tax liabilities

10

1,288

1,539

 

Total non-current liabilities

 

37,245

38,677

   

 

 
 

Current trade payables

21

9,519

9,580

 

Current financial liabilities at amortized cost, excluding trade payables

21

8,236

8,694

 

Current financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss

21

913

730

 

Current hedging derivatives liabilities

21

2

353

 

Current employee benefits

23

1,700

1,881

 

Current provisions

24

1,453

1,592

 

Other current liabilities

25

1,989

1,837

 

Current tax payables

10

277

331

 

Deferred income

25

2,763

2,985

 

Total current liabilities

 

26,852

27,983

   

 

 

TOTAL EQUITY AND LIABILITIES

 

95,295

101,183

     

(1) Complementary information regarding the effects of the implementation of IFRIC 13 on the balance sheet : see note 1.

     

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements




6



Back to Contents



CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY


(Amounts in millions of euros)


     
  

Number of shares in issues

Share capital

Additional paid-in capital

  
     

 

Note

 

 

 

     

Balance at January 1, 2007

 

2,606,673,130

10,427

15,179

     

Change in accounting policy upon application of IFRIC 13

1

   
     

 

 

 

 

 

Balance at January 1, 2007 after application of IFRIC 13

 

2,606,673,130

10,427

15,179

 

 

 

 

 

     

Unrealized foreign exchange gains (losses)

    

Gains (losses) on financial assets available for sale

    

Foreign exchange gains (losses) on cash flow hedges

    

Deferred tax on items recognized directly in equity

    
     

Total income and expense recognized directly in equity (A)

    

 

    

Net income for the year 2007 (B)

    
     

Total recognized income and expense for the year (A+B)

 

 

 

 

     

Allocation of 2006 net income

    

Capital increase (stock-options exercised)

 

7,675,781

30

138

Share-based compensation : Employee shareholding plan within the scope of the sale of shares owned by the French State

    

Share-based compensation : Free share award plan

    

Share-based compensation : stock options

    

Purchase of treasury shares

20

   

Dividends

20

   

Other transactions with minority interests

3

   

Other movements

    
     

 

 

 

 

 

Balance at December 31, 2007

 

2,614,348,911

10,457

15,317

 

 

 

 

 

     

Unrealized foreign exchange gains (losses)

    

Gains (losses) on financial assets available for sale

    

Foreign exchange gains (losses) on cash flow hedges

    

Foreign exchange gains (losses) on net investment hedges

    

Deferred tax on items recognized directly in equity

    

 

    

Total income and expense recognized directly in equity (A)

    
     

Net income for the year 2008 (B)

    
     

Total recognized income and expense for the year (A+B)

 

 

 

 

     

Allocation of 2007 net income

    

Capital increase (stock-options exercised)

20

642,325

3

8

Share-based compensation : Free share award plan

20

   

Share-based compensation : stock options

20

   

Purchase of treasury shares

20

   

Dividends

20

   

Other transactions with minority interests

3

   

Other movements

    
     

 

 

 

 

 

Balance at December 31, 2008

 

2,614,991,236

10,460

15,325

 

 

 

 

 

     
     

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements.


7



Back to Contents



Attribuable to equity holders of France Télécom S.A.

Total

Minority interests

Total Equity

Retained earnings

 

Translation adjustments

 

Income (expense) recognized directly in equity

Other
reserves

Net income

   

 

Assets available for sale

Hedging instruments

Deferred taxes

 

 

 

 

 

 

        

 

118

(98)

32

(5,223)

4,139

2,220

26,794

4,844

31,638

        

 

   

198

  

198

 

198

        

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

118

(98)

32

(5,025)

4,139

2,220

26,992

4,844

31,836

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

        

 

     

(467)

(467)

56

(411)

(38)

     

(38)

 

(38)

 

309

    

309

10

319

  

(106)

   

(106)

(2)

(108)

        

 

(38)

309

(106)

  

(467)

(302)

64

(238)

        

 

    

6,300

 

6,300

519

6,819

        

 

(38)

309

(106)

 

6,300

(467)

5,998

583

6,581

        

 

   

4,139

(4,139)

 

0

 

0

      

168

 

168

   

67

  

67

 

67

   

147

  

147

2

149

   

23

  

23

 

23

   

(214)

  

(214)

 

(214)

   

(3,117)

  

(3,117)

(670)

(3,787)

   

0

  

0

(107)

(107)

   

(5)

 

(6)

(11)

(182)

(193)

        

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

80

211

(74)

(3,985)

6,300

1,747

30,053

4,470

34,523

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

        

 

     

(1,930)

(1,930)

(192)

(2,122)

(54)

     

(54)

 

(54)

 

460

    

460

(1)

459

 

(26)

    

(26)

 

(26)

  

(145)

   

(145)

0

(145)

        

 

(54)

434

(145)

  

(1,930)

(1,695)

(193)

(1,888)

        

 

    

4,069

 

4,069

423

4,492

        

 

(54)

434

(145)

 

4,069

(1,930)

2,374

230

2,604

        

 

   

6,300

(6,300)

 

0

 

0

      

11

 

11

   

50

  

50

1

51

   

24

  

24

1

25

   

17

  

17

 

17

   

(4,949)

  

(4,949)

(661)

(5,610)

   

0

  

0

(348)

(348)

   

(20)

 

40

20

(95)

(75)

        

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

26

645

(219)

(2,563)

4,069

(143)

27,600

3,598

31,198

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

               

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements.

   


8



Back to Contents



CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS

 

(Amounts in millions of euros)


 

 

 

Year ended Decembre 31,

Year ended Decembre 31,

 

 

Note

2008

2007

 

 

 

 

 

OPERATING ACTIVITIES

 

 

 

 

Consolidated net income

 

4,492

6,819

 

 

 

 

 

Adjustments to reconcile net income/(loss) to funds generated from operations

 

 

 

 

Depreciation and amortization

12-13

7,776

8,111

 

Impairment of non-current assets

6-12-13

9

107

 

Impairment of goodwill

6-11

271

26

 

Gain on disposals of assets

7

(11)

(769)

 

Change in other provisions

 

(591)

(945)

 

Share of profits (losses) of associates

14

211

(4)

 

Income tax

10

2,793

1,330

 

Interest income and expense

 

2,472

2,627

 

Foreign exchange gains and losses, net

 

405

(740)

 

Derivatives

 

77

756

 

Share-based compensation

 

76

234

 

 

 

 

 

Change in inventories, trade receivables and trade payables

 

 

 

 

Decrease/(increase) in inventories (net)

 

38

(250)

 

Decrease/(increase) in trade accounts receivable

 

216

121

 

Increase/(decrease) in trade accounts payable

 

359

190

 

 

 

 

 

Other changes in working capital requirements

 

 

 

 

Decrease/(increase) in other receivables

 

(221)

(98)

 

Increase/(decrease) in other payables

 

(233)

331

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dividends and interest income received

 

299

315

 

Interest paid and interest rates effects on derivatives, net

 

(2,561)

(2,726)

 

Income tax paid

 

(878)

(791)

 

 

 

 

 

Net cash provided by operating activities

 

14,999

14,644

 

 

 

 

 

INVESTING ACTIVITIES

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Purchases/sales of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets

 

 

 

 

Purchases of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets

12-13

(7,140)

(7,064)

 

Increase/(decrease) in amounts due to fixed asset suppliers

 

(76)

125

 

Proceeds from sales of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets

12-13

233

113

 

 

 

 

 

Cash paid for investment securities, net of cash acquired

 

 

 

 

Purchase of treasury shares by TP S.A.

3

(200)

(185)

 

Purchase of treasury shares by Mobistar

3

(175)

-

 

FT España

3

(169)

-

 

Orange Uganda Limited

3

(40)

-

 

Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie

3

(32)

-

 

Silicomp

3

(5)

(96)

 

FT España ISP (Ya.com)

3

-

(319)

 

Telkom Kenya

3

-

(270)

 

Orange Moldova

3

-

(103)

 

Voxmobile

3

-

(80)

 

Other payments for investment securities

3

(140)

(64)

 

 

 

 

 

Proceeds from sales of investment securities, net of cash transferred

 

 

 

 

Orange Nederland

3

-

1,306

 

Tower Participations

3

-

254

 

Bluebirds

3

-

110

 

One

3

-

82

 

Other proceeds from sales of investment securities

3

56

56

 

 

 

 

 

Decrease/(increase) in marketable securities and other long-term assets

 

 

 

 

Escrow deposit

17-30

(207)

(757)

 

Other

 

(140)

11

 

 

 

 

 

Net cash used in investing activities

 

(8,035)

(6,881)

 

 

 

 

 

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements

 

 

 


 


9



Back to Contents



 

 

 

Au
31 décembre

Au
31 décembre

 

 

Note

2008

2007

 

 

 

 

 

FINANCING ACTIVITIES

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Issuances

 

 

 

 

 

Bonds convertible, exchangeable or redeemable into shares

21

4,047

3,122

 

Long-term debt

21

1,439

824

 

 

 

 

 

Redemptions and repayments

 

 

 

 

Bonds convertible, exchangeable or redeemable into shares

21

(6,328)

(4,001)

 

Long-term debt

21

(711)

(2,430)

 

Equity portion of hybrid debt

20-21

(64)

(16)

 

 

 

 

 

 

Increase/(decrease) in bank overdrafts and short-term borrowings

21

968

(906)

 

Decrease/(increase) in deposits and other debt-linked financial assets (including cash collateral)

21

672

(330)

 

Exchange rates effects on derivatives, net

 

(378)

(99)

 

Purchase of treasury shares

20

(35)

(214)

 

Capital increase/(decrease) - France Telecom S.A. shareholders

20

11

140

 

Capital increase/(decrease) - minority shareholders

20

(100)

50

 

Dividends paid to minority shareholders

20

(629)

(677)

 

Dividends paid by France Telecom S.A.

20

(4,949)

(3,117)

 

 

 

 

 

Net cash used in financing activities

 

(6,057)

(7,654)

 

 

 

 

 

Net change in cash and cash equivalents

 

907

109

Effect of exchange rates changes on cash and cash equivalents and other non-monetary effects

 

(132)

(54)

Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period

 

4,025

3,970

 

 

 

 

 

Cash and cash equivalents at end of period

 

4,800

4,025

 

 

 

 

 

The accompanying notes are an integral part of the consolidated financial statements







10



Back to Contents



SEGMENT INFORMATION

Analysis by business segment

Main operating indicators by business segment for the year ended December 31, 2008 

Income statement for the year ended December 31, 2008 

(in millions of euros)

PCS

HCS

ECS

Eliminations and

 unallocated items

Total

France

Telecom

Revenues

29,477

22,951

7,778

(6,718)

53,488

- external

28,478

17,730

7,280

-

53,488

- inter-segment

999

5,221

498

(6,718)

-

External purchases

(16,563)

(9,024)

(4,783)

6,718

(23,652)

Other operating income

218

1,047

97

(982)

380

Other operating expense

(1,728)

(1,340)

(172)

982

(2,258)

Labour expenses

- Wages and employee benefit expenses

(1,301)

(5,902)

(1,356)

-

(8,559)

Gross operating margin

10,103

7,732

1,564

-

19,399

 

- Employee profit-sharing

(47)

(253)

(19)

-

(319)

 

- Share-based compensation

(15)

(53)

(14)

-

(82)

Depreciation and amortization

(4,171)

(3,243)

(362)

-

(7,776)

Impairment of goodwill

(42)

(229)

-

-

(271)

Impairment of non-current assets

(1)

23

(31)

-

(9)

Gains (losses) on disposals of assets

-

-

-

11

11

Restructuring costs

(57)

(390)

(23)

-

(470)

Share of profits (losses) of associates

(194)

(17)

-

-

(211)

Operating income

    

10,272

- Allocated by segment

5,576

3,570

1,115

-

10,261

- Non-allocable

-

-

-

11

11

Interest expenses, net

-

-

-

(2,766)

(2,766)

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

-

-

-

(63)

(63)

Discounting expense

-

-

-

(158)

(158)

Income tax

-

-

-

(2,793)

(2,793)

Consolidated net income

    

4,492

Non-cash income and expense items included in operating income allocated by business segment

(4,466)

(2,891)

(362)

-

(7,719)

Investments in property, plant & equipment and intangible assets

     

- excluding telecommunications licenses

3,192

3,319

356

-

6,867

- telecommunications licenses

272

1

-

-

273

- financed through finance leases

33

120

23

-

176

Total investments (1)

3,497

3,440

379

-

7,316

(1)

Including 1,883 million euros for other intangible assets and 5,433 million euros for property, plant and equipment (see Notes 12 and 13).



11



Back to Contents


Balance sheet at December 31, 2008 


(in millions of euros)

PCS

HCS

ECS

Eliminations and

 unallocated items

Total

France

Telecom

Goodwill

24,798

5,592

421

-

30,811

Other intangible assets

8,229

5,946

276

-

14,451

Property, plant and equipment

11,570

14,392

572

-

26,534

Interests in associates

86

86

-

-

172

Other non-current assets

11

1

20

-

32

Non-segment non-current assets (1)

-

-

-

7,629

7,629

Non-current assets

    

79,629

Inventories

632

310

34

-

976

Trade receivables (2)

4,122

6,310

918

(5,187)

6,163

Other current assets

892

1,214

133

(96)

2,143

Prepaid expenses

355

250

82

(106)

581

Non-segment current assets (1)

-

-

-

5,803

5,803

Current assets

    

15,666

Total assets

    

95,295

 

- o/w segment assets

50,695

34,101

2,456

(5,389)

81,863

- o/w non-segment assets

-

-

-

13,432

13,432

Equity

    

31,198

Non-current trade payables

487

11

-

-

498

Non-current employee benefits

27

457

75

-

559

Non-current provisions

404

832

26

-

1,262

Other non-current liabilities

4

707

-

-

711

Non-segment non-current liabilities (1)

-

-

-

34,215

34,215

Non-current liabilities

    

37,245

Current trade payables

9,278

4,585

847

(5,191)

9,519

Current employee benefits

203

1,218

279

-

1,700

Current provisions

203

1,194

56

-

1,453

Other current liabilities

677

1,243

160

(91)

1,989

Deferred income

1,370

1,343

157

(107)

2,763

Non-segment current liabilities (1)

-

-

-

9,428

9,428

Current liabilities

    

26,852

Total equity and liabilities

    

95,295

- o/w segment liabilities

12,653

11,590

1,600

(5,389)

20,454

- o/w non-segment liabilities

-

-

-

74,841

74,841

(1)

Mainly assets and liabilities comprising net financial debt and deferred taxes.

(2)

Some trade receivables generated by the Enterprise Communication Services segment (approximately 313 million euros) are included in the Home Communication Services segment, which is responsible for their collection.




12



Back to Contents


Main operating indicators by business segment for the year ended December 31, 2007 

Income statement for the year ended December 31, 2007 


(in millions of euros)

PCS

HCS

ECS

Eliminations and

 unallocated items

Total

France

Telecom

Revenues

29,119

22,671

7,721

(6,552)

52,959

- external

28,144

17,548

7,267

-

52,959

- inter-segment

975

5,123

454

(6,552)

-

External purchases

(16,296)

(8,497)

(4,912)

6,549

(23,156)

Other operating incomes

258

1,023

97

(938)

440

Other operating expenses

(1,640)

(1,480)

(178)

938

(2,360)

Labour expenses

- Wages and employee benefit expenses

(1,464)

(5,918)

(1,385)

-

(8,767)

Gross operating margin

9,977

7,799

1,343

(3)

19,116

 

- Employee profit-sharing

(65)

(268)

(26)

-

(359)

 

- Share-based compensation

(18)

(232)

(29)

-

(279)

Depreciation and amortization

(4,456)

(3,238)

(420)

3

(8,111)

Impairment of goodwill

-

(26)

-

-

(26)

Impairment of non-current assets

(8)

(6)

(93)

-

(107)

Gains (losses) on disposal of assets

-

-

-

769

769

Restructuring costs

(27)

(153)

(28)

-

(208)

Share of profits (losses) of associates

4

-

-

-

4

Operating income

    

10,799

- Allocated by segment

5,407

3,876

747

-

10,030

- Non-allocable

-

-

-

769

769

Interest expenses, net

-

-

-

(2,521)

(2,521)

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

-

-

-

(4)

(4)

Discounting expense

-

-

-

(125)

(125)

Income tax

-

-

-

(1,330)

(1,330)

Consolidated net income after tax

    

6,819

Non-cash income and expense items included in operating income allocated by business segment

(4,498)

(2,526)

(498)

-

(7,522)

Investments in property, plant & equipment and intangible assets

     

- excluding telecommunication licenses

3,493

3,080

406

-

6,979

- telecommunication licenses

85

-

-

-

85

- financed through finance leases

30

-

14

-

44

Total investments (1)

3,608

3,080

420

-

7,108

(1)

Including 1,693 million euros for other intangible assets and 5,415 million euros for property, plant and equipment (see Notes 12 and 13).



13



Back to Contents


Balance sheet at December 31, 2007 



(in millions of euros)

PCS

HCS

ECS

Eliminations and

 unallocated items

Total

France

Telecom

Goodwill

24,931

6,059

399

-

31,389

Other intangible assets

10,166

6,252

240

-

16,658

Property, plant and equipment

12,073

15,190

586

-

27,849

Interests in associates

273

3

6

-

282

Other non-current assets

35

5

23

-

63

Non-segment non-current assets (1)

-

-

-

9,847

9,847

Non-current assets

    

86,088

Inventories

684

342

42

-

1,068

Trade receivables (2)

3,916

5,254

921

(3,535)

6,556

Other current assets

936

1,072

165

(138)

2,035

Prepaid expenses

362

313

81

(83)

673

Non-segment current assets (1)

-

-

-

4,763

4,763

Current assets

    

15,095

Total assets

    

101,183

 

- o/w segment assets

53,376

34,490

2,463

(3,756)

86,573

- o/w non-segment assets

-

-

-

14,610

14,610

Equity

    

34,523

Non-current trade payables

429

6

-

-

435

Non-current employee benefits

22

429

84

-

535

Non-current provisions

352

1,252

53

-

1,657

Other non-current liabilities

13

857

-

-

870

Non-segment non-current liabilities (1)

-

-

-

35,180

35,180

Non-current liabilities

    

38,677

Current trade payables

7,652

4,646

826

(3,544)

9,580

Current employee benefits

320

1,247

314

-

1,881

Current provisions

214

1,287

91

-

1,592

Other current liabilities

693

1,104

168

(128)

1,837

Deferred income

1,455

1,436

178

(84)

2,985

Non-segment current liabilities (1)

-

-

-

10,108

10,108

Current liabilities

    

27,983

Total equity and liabilities

    

101,183

- o/w segment liabilities

11,150

12,264

1,714

(3,756)

21,372

- o/w non-segment liabilities

-

-

-

79,811

79,811

(1)

Mainly assets and liabilities comprising net financial debt and deferred taxes.

(2)

Some trade receivables (approximately 480 million euros) generated by the Enterprise Communication Services segment are included in the Home Communication Services segment, which is responsible for their collection.



14



Back to Contents


Analysis by geographic segment

Revenue contribution


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

France

28,564

27,856

United Kingdom

6,102

6,706

Poland

 5,140

4,787

Spain

4,015

3,911

Rest of Europe

5,148

5,479

Rest of the world

4,519

4,220

Total Group

53,488

52,959


Investments in property, plant & equipment and intangible assets (including finance leases and telecommunications licenses)


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros )

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

France

3,528

3,273

United Kingdom

488

549

Poland

736

963

Spain

572

627

Rest of Europe

631

719

Rest of the world

1,361

977

Total Group

7,316

7,108


Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets, net (excluding goodwill)


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

France

15,838

15,520

United Kingdom

8,510

11,484

Poland

5,580

7,049

Spain

4,365

4,862

Rest of Europe

2,938

2,773

Rest of the world

3,754

2,819

Total Group

40,985

44,507


15



Back to Contents



Note 1 - Description of business and basis of preparation of the consolidated financial statements  

1.1 Description of business

The France Telecom Group provides consumers, businesses and other telecommunications operators with a wide range of services including fixed telephony and mobile telecommunications, data transmission, Internet and multimedia, and other value-added services.  


1.2 Basis of preparation of 2008 consolidated financial statements

The consolidated financial statements (“the financial statements”) were approved by the Board of Directors at its meeting of March 3, 2009.

In accordance with European regulation n° 1606/2002 dated July 19, 2002, the 2008 consolidated financial statements have been prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) as adopted for use by the European Union. Comparative figures are presented for 2007 compiled using the same basis of preparation.

On the reported periods, the accounting standards and interpretations endorsed by the European Union and compulsory as of December 31, 2008  are similar to the compulsory standards and interpretations published by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) with the exception of the IAS 39 standard, only partially endorsed by the European Union, which has no effect on Group accounts. Consequently, Group accounts are prepared in accordance with the IFRS standards and interpretations, as published by the IASB.

The principles applied to prepare financial data relating to the financial year 2008 are based on:

•

all standards endorsed by the European Union and interpretations compulsory as of December 31, 2008 and any IFRS standards and interpretations with early application. New standards and interpretations applied by the Group in 2008 are:


Standard / Interpretation

Consequences for the Group

Amendments to IAS 39 and IFRS 7

Reclassification of Financial Assets

These amendments, designed for special situations, allows for the reclassification of some financial assets.

The Group did not elect to reclassify any financial assets.

IFRIC 12

Service Concession Arrangements

The application of this interpretation has no effect on the reported financial statements.

IFRIC 13

Customer Loyalty Programs

Loyalty programs consist of granting future benefits to customers (such as call credit and product discounts…).

IFRIC 13 changes the accounting treatment for loyalty programs applied by the Group until December 31, 2007, based on the French GAAP opinion 2004-E of CNC’s Comité d’Urgence (Emerging Issues Accounting Committee). According to IFRIC 13, loyalty programs should be valued at their fair value which is defined as the excess price over the sales incentive that would be granted to any new customer. Loyalty programs were formerly only valued on the basis of sales incentive granted to a loyal customer.

First-time application of IFRIC 13 is accounted for as a change in accounting policy in accordance with IAS 8. It has no effect on the consolidated net income and its main consequence is a decrease in the amount of deferred income relating to loyalty programs awarded.



16



Back to Contents


The accounting consequences of IFRIC 13 change in accounting policy are:



(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2007

Published

IFRIC 13 impact

Restated

Revenues

52 959

-

52 959

Consolidated net income

6 819

-

6 819

Retained earnings

2 334

198

2 532

Total equity

34 325

198

34 523

Deferred tax liabilities

1 440

99

1 539

Current provisions

1 599

(7)

1 592

Deferred income

3 275

(290)

2 985

•

the recognition and measurement options proposed by the IFRS standards:


Standard

Option used

IAS 2

Inventories

Recognition of inventories at their original cost determined by the weighted average unit cost method

IAS 16

Property, Plant and Equipment

Measurement at amortized historical cost

IAS 19

Employee Benefits

Recognition of actuarial gains and losses on pensions and other post-employment benefit obligations as from January 1, 2004 according to the corridor method

IAS 23

Borrowing Costs

Recognition as interest expense incurred during the construction and acquisition period of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets

IAS 31

Interests in Joint Ventures

Accounting for using the proportionate consolidation method

IAS 38

Intangible Assets

Measurement at amortized historical cost

•

the available exemptions regarding the retrospective application of IFRSs at the transition date (January 1, 2004 for the France Telecom Group) hereafter summarized:


Standard

IFRS 1 option used

IFRS 2

Share-based Payment

Retrospective application of provisions of IFRS 2 to equity-settled and cash-settled plans, including those implemented prior to November 7, 2002

IFRS 3

Business Combinations

Non-application of the provisions of this standard for business combinations prior to the transition date

Acquisition of minority interests accounted for as goodwill for the difference between the acquisition cost and the minority interest share in the net equity, without any remeasurement of the assets and liabilities acquired

IAS 16 and

IAS 38

Property, Plant and Equipment and Intangible Assets

Measurement of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets at historical cost, except for certain real estate assets held by TP Group and certain items of property, plant and equipment owned by France Telecom S.A. which were remeasured at fair value at the time of the change in the Company’s status and deregulation of the telecommunications market in 1996

IAS 19

Employee Benefits

Recognition of all actuarial gains and losses existing as of January 1, 2004 in equity

IAS 21

Effect of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates

Transfer into retained earnings of all cumulative translation differences for all foreign operations at January 1, 2004

IAS 39

Financial Instruments

Reclassification of certain financial instruments recognized prior to January 1, 2004 as financial assets and liabilities at fair value through profit or loss or as assets available for sale

Prospective application as of January 1, 2004 of the fair value option relating to initial recognition of certain financial assets and liabilities



17



Back to Contents


•

accounting positions adopted by the Group in accordance with paragraphs 10 to 12 of IAS 8 hereafter:


Topic

Note

Presentation of consolidated financial statements

2.1

Minority interests

2.4

Waste electrical and electronical equipment

2.18

Individual right to training for employees (Droit Individuel à la Formation (DIF))

2.19

Employee share offer

2.20

Lastly, where a specific transaction is not dealt with in any standards or interpretations, management uses its judgment to define and apply an accounting policy that will result in relevant and reliable information, such that the financial statements:

•

present fairly the Group’s financial position, financial performance and cash flows;

•

reflect the economic substance of transactions;

•

are neutral;

•

are prepared on a prudent basis; and

•

are complete in all material respects.




18



Back to Contents


1.3 Standards and interpretations compulsory after December 31, 2008 with no early application decided by the Group

France Telecom has not opted for early application of the following standards, amendments and interpretations published as at December 31, 2008 (already adopted or in the process of being adopted by the European Union).

•

IFRS 8 and IAS 36 amended by IFRS 8

Standard / Interpretation

(application date for the Group)

Consequences for the Group

IFRS 8

Operating Segments

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

IFRS 8 supersedes IAS 14 « Segment reporting ». IFRS 8 provides for the reporting of data relating to the Group operating segments based on the internal reporting and used by the chief operating decision-maker (the Chief Executive Officer for the Group) in order to decide the allocation of resources and the assessment of the operating segments’ performance. IAS 14 required information on two levels: business segments and geographical segments.

In accordance with the strategy of convergence implemented by the NExT plan, the Group has adopted a new reporting based on its organization since January 1, 2009. The operating segments (or group of operating segments) are: enterprise services of Orange Business Services, telecommunications services (fixed-line, broadband and mobile) in France, Poland, United Kingdom, Spain, other countries, shared support services and corporate services.

IAS 36 (amended by IFRS 8)

Impairment of Assets

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

The IFRS 8 dispositions affect the structure of segment reporting and the levels of Cash-Generating Units (CGUs) retained to test the goodwill for impairment: IAS 36 amendment states that goodwill must be allocated to CGUs which are not larger than an operating segment.

This amendment is retrospective, which requires to identify the operating segments following the current internal reporting until December 31, 2008 in accordance with the IFRS 8 principles.

This will retrospectively increase impairment loss for:

•

goodwill relating to fixed-line and broadband businesses of TP amounting to circa 501 millions of euros as at January 1, 2007 (portion attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A.)

•

goodwill relating to fixed-line and broadband businesses of Jordan Telecom amounting to circa 47 millions of euros as at January 1, 2007 (portion attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A.)


•

Others

Standard / Interpretation

(application date for the Group)

Consequences for the Group

IFRS 1 (revised in 2008)

First Time Adoption of IFRS

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

The Group, already applying the IFRSs, is not impacted by this revision.

IAS 1

(revised in 2007)

Presentation of Financial Statements

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

The application of this revision will be without effect on the Group financial position but will modify the presentation of its financial statements, including:

•

the statement of changes in equity will present only transactions between the shareholders, the other transactions being included in a comprehensive income statement;

•

all changes in assets and liabilities for a period will be presented in two statements: a separate income statement (components of profit or loss) and a statement of comprehensive income (components of other comprehensive income).

IAS 23 (revised in 2007)

Borrowing Costs

(applicable to borrowing costs relating to qualifying assets for which the commencement for capitalization is on or after January 1, 2009)

Borrowing costs directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying asset shall be capitalized as part of the cost of that asset which requires a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended use or sale, unlike what has been applied so far by the Group.

The network deployment mode – in the Group assessment – does not generally require a substantial period of time. Consequently, a limited number of assets should qualify for and the effects of this standard application is not expected to be material.


19



Back to Contents



Standard / Interpretation

(application date for the Group)

Consequences for the Group

IFRS 3

and

IAS 27

(revised in 2008)

Business Combinations and Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements

(applicable to accounting for business combinations for which the acquisition date is on or after January 1, 2010)

Changes in a parent’s ownership interest in a subsidiary that do not result in a change of control will be accounted for as changes in equity. Moreover, the revised standard will allow for each takeover with interest ownership below 100% to account goodwill either on a 100% basis or on the acquired interest ownership basis (without any subsequent change in case of additional purchase of minority interests.

Acquisition related costs will be directly expensed.

Changes in a parent’s ownership interest resulting in a loss of control will lead to recognize investment retained in the former subsidiary at its fair value.

The Group will therefore change the accounting for its future business combinations and its future minority interest transactions.

Amendment to IFRS 2

Vesting Conditions and Cancellations

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

This amendment states that fair value of equity instruments awarded has to include all ancillary conditions for the acquisition of rights. Moreover, when one of the parties may elect not to fulfil one of these conditions, this choice has to be accounted for as a cancellation.

The application of this amendment will have no effect on the reported periods.

Amendement to IAS 32

and

IAS 1

Puttable Financial Instruments and Obligations Arising on Liquidation

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

Puttable instruments and obligations arising on liquidation will be classified within equity and no longer within debt.

Firm or contingent commitments to purchase minority interests are not in the scope of this standard.

The Group does not hold such financial instruments at this date and is therefore not affected by this amendment.

Amendment to IFRS 1

and

IAS 27

Cost of an Investment in a Subsidiary, Jointly Controlled Entity or Associate

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009)

This amendment deals only with separate financial statements and not consolidated financial statements.

It will consequently have no effect on the Group consolidated financial statements.

Improvements to IFRSs

Improvements to IFRSs

(applicable for financial years beginning after January 1, 2009, except for IFRS 5 after January 1, 2010)

The impacts of this amendment are currently being analyzed.

Amendment to IAS 39

Eligible Hedged Items

(applicable for financial years beginning after january 1, 2010 )

This amendment states that time value should not be considered in a hedging relationship and inflation can only be designated as hedged item in certain conditions.

This amendment will have no effect on the Group financial statements.

IFRIC 15

Agreements for the Construction of Real Estate

(applicable for financial years beginning after january 1, 2009 )

Agreements in the scope of this interpretation dealing only with construction of real estate, this interpretation has no consequences for the Group.

IFRIC 16

Hedges of a Net Investment in a Foreign Operation

(applicable for financial years beginning after october 1, 2008 )

This interpretation clarifies some principles of net investment hedge:

•

the hedged item can only be an exchange difference between functional currencies, for an amount lower than the net investment carrying amount, and it can only be hedged once ;

•

the hedging instrument may be held in any group entity except the foreign operation that itself is being hedged;

•

the profit or loss relating to the hedge and initially booked in equity has to be reclassified in profit or loss on the disposal of the net investment.

This interpretation will be without effect on the Group financial statements.

IFRIC 17

Distributions of Non-cash Assets to Owners

(applicable for financial years beginning after july 1, 2009 )

This interpretation deals with the accounting treatment for distributions of non-cash assets to owners (excluding distributions between entities under common control). It states the fair value of the distributed assets has to be recognized as debt when the decision is decided and difference with the net booked value of the distributed assets has to be booked through profit or loss on distribution date.

The application of this interpretation is prospective.




20



Back to Contents


1.4 Use of estimates

In preparing the Group financial statements, France Telecom’s management makes estimates, insofar as many elements included in the financial statements cannot be measured with precision. The management revises these estimates if the underlying circumstances evolve or in the light of new information or experience. Consequently, estimates made at December 31, 2008 may subsequently be changed. The underlying assumptions used for significant estimates are described in the following notes.


Estimate

Nature of disclosure

Note 3

Main acquisitions and disposals of companies and changes in scope of consolidation

Where applicable, selection of the key measurement methods and assumptions used to identify intangible assets in business combinations

Goodwill allocation to Cash-Generating Unit (CGU)

Note 4

Revenue

Allocation of each separable component of a packaged offer based on its relative fair value

Straight-line recognition of revenue relating to service access fees invoiced depending on the nature of product and historical contractual relationship

Reporting revenue on a net versus gross basis (analysis of Group’s involvement acting as principal versus agent).   

Note 6

Impairment of assets

Impairment loss determination at the level of CGUs, intangible assets and property, plant and equipment not generating cash inflows that are largely independent of those from CGUs

Level of group of CGUs for goodwill impairment test

Key assumptions used to determine recoverable amounts: value in use (discount rate, perpetual growth rate, expected cash flows), market value (revenue and ebitda multiples for comparable companies or transactions, cash flows)

Assessment of economic and financial environment

Note 10

Income tax

Assumptions used for recognition of deferred tax assets and consequences of tax laws

Notes 12 and 13

Purchases of property, plant and equipment, intangible assets other than goodwill

Useful life of assets assessment

Note 23

Employee benefits

Discount rate, inflation rate, return rate on plan assets, salary increases

Note 23

Share-based payments

Model, assumptions underlying the measurement of fair values: share price of underlying on grant date, volatility

Note 24

Provisions

Provisions for termination benefits and restructuring: discount rate, plan success rate

Provisions for claims and litigations: assumptions underlying risk assessment and measurement

Note 28

Fair value

Models, selection of parameters



21



Back to Contents



Note 2 - Accounting Policies


This note describes the accounting policies applied to prepare the 2008 consolidated financial statements.

2.1 Presentation of the consolidated financial statements

•

Income statement

Expenses are presented in the income statement based on their nature.

Operating income corresponds to net income before:

•

financial income;

•

financial costs;

•

income taxes (current and deferred taxes);

•

net income of discontinued operations or operations held for sale.

The gain or loss of discontinued operations or non-current assets held for sale is reported on a separate line in the income statement.

•

Balance sheet

Current and non-current items are presented separately on the balance sheet: assets and liabilities with a term no more than twelve months are classified as current; whereas, assets and liabilities with a term more than twelve months are classified as non-current.

Assets and liabilities held for sale are reported on a separate line under non current items in the consolidated balance sheet.

•

Statement of cash flows

The statement of cash flows is reported using the indirect method from the consolidated net income and is broken down between three categories:

•

cash flows arising from operating activities;

•

cash flows arising from investing activities;

•

cash flows arising from financing activities.

Financial interests and income tax are included in the cash flows arising from operating activities.

On acquisition date, a finance lease has no effect on cash flows since the transaction is non-monetary. Besides, lease payments over the financing period are broken down between interests (cash flows from operating activities) and reimbursement of principal amount (cash flows arising from financing activities).

•

Segment reporting

France Telecom Group’s management structure is based on: (i) business lines (Home, Personal, Enterprise) and (ii) management teams integrated at country level. Consequently, and in accordance with IAS 14 “Segment Reporting”, the Group has defined the following three business segments as its basis for primary segment reporting:

•

Personal Communication Services (PCS), covering the mobile telecommunications services activities in France, the United Kingdom, Spain, Poland, and the rest of the world. This segment includes all the Orange subsidiaries, as well as the mobile telephony business of FT España in Spain, TP Group (with its subsidiary PTK Centertel) in Poland, and that of other foreign companies in the Group;

•

Home Communication Services (HCS), covering the fixed telecommunications services activities (fixed telephony, internet services, and services to operators) in France, Poland and the rest of the world, as well as revenues from distribution and from the support functions provided to other segments of France Telecom Group;

•

Enterprise Communication Services (ECS), covering business communications solutions and services in France and worldwide.


22



Back to Contents


Each of the segments defined by the Group has its own resources, although they may also share certain resources in the areas of networks and information systems, research and development, distribution networks and other shared competencies.

The use of shared resources is taken into account in segment results based on the terms of contractual agreements between legal entities, or external benchmarks, or by allocating costs among all the segments. The supply of shared resources is included in inter-segment revenues of the service provider, and use of the resources is included in expenses taken into account for the calculation of the service user’s gross operating margin. The cost of shared resources supplied may be affected by changes in regulations and may therefore have an impact on the segment results disclosed from one year to another.

Gross operating margin (GOM) is one of the key measures used by France Telecom internally to i) manage and assess the results of its business segments, ii) make decisions with respect to investments and allocation of resources, and iii) assess the performance of the Group executive management. France Telecom’s management believes that GOM is meaningful for investors because it provides an analysis of its operating results and segment profitability using the same measure used by management. As a consequence and in accordance with IAS 14, paragraph 46, GOM is presented in the analysis by business segment.

GOM is not an explicit measure of financial performance measure under IFRS and may not be comparable to other similarly titled measures for other companies. GOM is disclosed as additional information only and should not be considered as an alternative to operating income or an alternative to cash-flows from operating activities as a measure of liquidity. GOM corresponds to operating income before employee profit sharing, share-based compensation, depreciation and amortization expense, impairment of goodwill and other non-current assets, gains and losses on disposal of assets, restructuring costs and share of profits (losses) of associates.

GOM is calculated by excluding:

•

employee profit sharing and share-based compensation expenses because such expenses are mainly based on either mandatory statutory requirements or depend mainly on the sale of shares by the French State and various shareholders decisions,

•

depreciation and amortization because such expenses reflect the impact of generally long-term capital investments that cannot be significantly influenced by management in the short-term; and

•

impairment charges, restructuring costs and gain and losses on disposals of assets because these elements can be both infrequent and material and are by their nature unpredictable in their amount and/or their frequency.

Segment results correspond to operating income, excluding gains and losses on disposals of assets not directly related to the segment concerned.

The Group has six geographic segments, including four main geographic markets (France, the United Kingdom, Poland and Spain), the rest of Europe and the rest of the world.


2.2 Earnings per share

The Group discloses both basic earnings per share and diluted earnings per share for continuing operations and discontinued operations. Basic earnings per share are calculated by dividing net income for the year attributable to the equity holders outstanding during the year. Diluted earnings per share are calculated based on earnings per share attributable to the equity holders of France Telecom S.A., adjusted for the finance cost of dilutive debt instruments and their impact on employee profit-sharing, net of the related tax effect. The number of shares used to calculate diluted earnings per share takes into account the conversion into ordinary shares of potentially dilutive instruments outstanding during the period. When earnings per share are negative, diluted earnings per share are identical to basic earnings per share. In the event of an issuance of shares at a price lower than the market price, and in order to ensure comparability of earnings per share information, the weighted average numbers of shares outstanding from current and previous periods are adjusted. Treasury shares deducted from consolidated equity are not taken into account in the calculation of basic or diluted earnings per share.



23



Back to Contents


2.3 Consolidation rules

Subsidiaries that are controlled exclusively by France Telecom, directly or indirectly, are fully consolidated. Control is deemed to exist when the Group owns more than 50% of the voting rights of an entity or has power:

•

over more than one half of the voting rights of the other entity by virtue of an agreement;

•

to govern the financial and operating policies of the other entity under a statute or agreement;

•

to appoint or remove the majority of the Members of the Board of Directors or equivalent governing body of the other entity; or

•

to cast the majority of votes at meetings of the Board of Directors or equivalent governing body of the other entity.

Companies that are controlled jointly by France Telecom and a limited number of other shareholders are proportionally consolidated; if these companies have any exclusively controlled, fully consolidated subsidiaries that are not wholly owned, indirect minority interests in these subsidiaries are recognized separately in the France Telecom consolidated financial statements.

Companies over which France Telecom exercises significant influence (generally corresponding to an ownership interest of 20% to 50%) are accounted for using the equity method.

When assessing the level of control or significant influence exercised over a subsidiary or associate, account is taken of the existence and effect of any exercisable or convertible potential voting rights at the balance sheet date.

Material intragroup transactions and balances are eliminated in consolidation.


2.4 Minority interests

Accounting of acquisition of minority interests is not addressed by IFRSs. The Group has therefore applied French GAAP accounting treatment, which consists in recognizing goodwill as the difference between the acquisition cost of minority interests and the minority interest share in the net equity, without any purchase price allocation.

•

Transfer of consolidated shares within the Group resulting in changes in ownership interest

IFRSs do not address the accounting treatment for the transfer of consolidated shares within the Group resulting in changes in ownership interest. The Group applies the following accounting policy:

•

the transferred shares are maintained at historical cost and the gain or loss on the transfer is fully eliminated in the accounts of the acquiring entities;

•

the minority interests are adjusted to reflect the change in their share in the equity against Group retained earnings, with no impact on profit and loss and equity.

•

Acquisition of minority interests in exchange for shares in a consolidated entity

IFRSs do not address the accounting treatment for the transfer by minority shareholders of their interests in a consolidated entity of the Group in exchange for shares of another consolidated entity of the Group, nor do they address the accounting treatment of the resulting decrease in ownership interest. The Group has therefore considered the transfer by the minority shareholders as an acquisition of minority interests and the decrease in ownership interest as a disposal, for which the corresponding net gain or loss is recognized in income as incurred.

•

Commitments to purchase minority interests (put options)

Given the current status of IAS 27 “Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements” and IAS 32 “Financial Instruments: Disclosure and Presentation”, firm or contingent commitments to purchase minority interest are recognized as a financial debt. In the absence of any guidance on this issue from the International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC), the Group has opted to book the financial debt against a reduction in minority interests within equity.

Where the amount of the commitment exceeds the amount of the minority interest, the difference is recorded as a reduction in shareholders’ equity attributable to the equity holders of France Telecom S.A.. The fair value of commitments to purchase minority interests is revised at each balance sheet date and the corresponding debt is adjusted with a contra-entry to financial income or expense.


24



Back to Contents



2.5 Effect of changes in foreign exchange rates

•

Translation of financial statements of foreign subsidiaries

The financial statements of foreign subsidiaries whose functional currency is not the euro or the currency of a hyperinflationary economy are translated into euros (France Telecom’s presentation currency) as follows:

•

assets and liabilities are translated at the year-end rate;

•

items in the statement of income are translated at the average rate for the year;

•

the translation adjustment resulting from the use of these different rates is included as a separate component of shareholders’ equity.

•

Transactions in foreign currencies

Transactions in foreign currencies are converted by the subsidiary into its functional currency at the exchange rate at the transaction date. Monetary assets and liabilities are remeasured at each balance sheet date at the year-end exchange rate and the resulting translation differences are recorded in the income statement:

•

in operating income for commercial transactions;

•

in financial income or finance costs for financial transactions.

Both for transactions qualifying for hedge accounting and for economic hedge, change in fair value currency derivatives that can be attributed to changes in exchange rate is accounted for under operating income when the underlying hedged item is a financial transaction and under financial income when the underlying hedged item is a receivable or a financial debt. For cash flow hedge of a highly probable forecast transaction, it is booked in equity and reclassified in profit or loss following the preceding method when the hedged item affects profit or loss.

The foreign exchange risk arising on the net operating cash flows, less purchases of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets and proceeds from sales of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets of some entities, can be hedged by the Group. The impact of this hedge is recorded in the operating income.


2.6 Revenues  

Revenues from France Telecom activities are recognized and presented as follows, in accordance with IAS 18 “Revenue”:

•

Separable components of packaged and bundled offers

Numerous service offers on the Group’s main markets include two components: an equipment (e.g. a mobile handset) and a service (e.g. a talk plan). For the sale of multiple products or services, the Group evaluates all deliverables in the arrangement to determine whether they represent separate units of accounting. A delivered item is considered a separate unit of accounting if (i) it has value to the customer on a standalone basis and (ii) there is objective and reliable evidence of the fair value of the undelivered item(s).

The total fixed or determinable amount of the arrangement is allocated to the separate units of accounting based on their relative fair value. However, when an amount allocated to a delivered item is contingent upon the delivery of additional items or meeting specified performance conditions, the amount allocated to that delivered item is limited to the non contingent amount. The case arises in the mobile business for sales of bundled offers including a handset and a telecommunications service contract. The handset is considered to have value on a standalone basis to the customer, and there is objective and reliable evidence of fair value for the telecommunications service to be delivered. As the amount allocable to the handset generally exceeds the amount received from the customer at the date the handset is delivered, revenue recognized for the handset sale is generally limited to the amount of the arrangement that is not contingent upon the rendering of telecommunication services, i.e. the amount paid by the customer for the handset.

For offers that cannot be separated in identifiable components, revenues are recognized in full over the life of the contract. The main example is connection to the service: this does not represent a separately identifiable transaction from the subscription and communications, and connection fees are therefore recognized over the average expected life of the contractual relationship.


25



Back to Contents


•

Equipment sales

Revenues from equipment sales are recognized when the significant risks and rewards of ownership are transferred to the buyer.

When an equipment – associated to the subscription of telecommunication services - is sold by a third-party retailer who purchases it from the Group and receives a commission for signing up the customer, the related revenue is:

•

recognized when the equipment is sold to the end-customer;

•

assessed taking into account the Group’s best estimate of the retail price, taking account of any subsidies granted to

•

the retailer at the time of the sale and passed on to the end-customer in the form of a rebate on the equipment.

•

Equipment rentals

In accordance with IFRIC 4 “Determining Whether an Arrangement Contains a Lease”, equipment for which a right of use is granted is analyzed in accordance with IAS 17 “Leases”.

Equipment lease revenues are recognized on a straight-line basis over the life of the lease agreement, except in the case of finance leases which are accounted for as sales on credit.

•

Content sales

The accounting for revenue sharing arrangements and supply depends on the analysis of the facts and circumstances surrounding these transactions. To determine if the revenue must be recognized on a gross or a net basis, an analysis is performed using the following criteria:

•

the Group is the primary obligor of the arrangement;

•

the Group bears inventory risk;

•

the Group has a reasonable latitude in establishing price with the customer for the service;

•

the Group has discretion in supplier selection;

•

the Group is involved in the determination of service specifications; and

•

the Group bears the credit risk.

Therefore, revenue-sharing arrangements (Audiotel, premium rate number, special numbers, etc.) are recognized:

•

gross when the Group has a reasonable latitude in setting prices and determining the key features of the content (service or product) sold to the end-customer; and

•

net of amounts due to the service provider when the latter is responsible for the service and for setting the price to be paid by subscribers.

Similarly, revenues from the sale or supply of content (audio, video, games, etc.) via the Group’s various communications systems (mobile, PC, TV, fixed line, etc.) are recognized:

•

gross when the Group is deemed to be the primary obligor in the transaction with respect to the end-customer (i.e. when the customer has no specific recourse against the content provider), when the Group bears the inventory risk and has a reasonable latitude in the selection of content providers and in setting prices charged to the end-customer; and

•

net of amounts due to the content provider when the latter is responsible for supplying the content to the end-customer and for setting the price to subscribers.

•

Service revenues

Revenues from telephone service and Internet access subscription fees as well as those from the wholesale of access are recognized in revenue on a straight-line basis over the subscription period.


26



Back to Contents


Revenues from charges for incoming and outgoing telephone calls as well as those from the wholesale of traffic are recognized in revenue when the service is rendered.

Revenues from the sale of transmission capacity on terrestrial and submarine cables as well as those from local loop unbundling are recognized on a straight-line basis over the life of the contract.

Revenues from Internet advertising are recognized over the period during which the advertisement appears.

•

Customized contracts

France Telecom offers customized solutions in particular to its business customers. The related contracts are analyzed as multiple-element transactions (including management of the telecommunication network, access, voice and data transmission and migration). The commercial discounts granted under these contracts if certain conditions are fulfilled are recorded as a deduction from revenue based on the specific terms of each contract.

Migration costs incurred by France Telecom under these contracts are recognized in expenses when they are incurred, except in the case of contracts that include an early termination penalty clause.

•

Promotional offers

Revenues are stated net of discounts. For certain commercial offers where customers are offered a free service over a certain period in exchange for signing up for a fixed period (time-based incentives), the total revenue generated under the contract is spread over the fixed, non-cancellable period.

•

Penalties

All the Group’s commercial contracts contain service level commitments (delivery time, service reinstatement time). These service level agreements cover commitments given by France Telecom on the order process, the delivery process, and after sales services.

If the Group fails to comply with one of these commitments, it pays compensation to the end-customer, usually in the form of a price reduction which is deducted from revenues. Such penalties are recorded when it becomes probable that they will due based on the non-achievement of contractual terms.


2.7 Subscriber acquisition and retention costs, loyalty programs and advertising and related cost  

•

Subscriber acquisition and retention costs

Subscriber acquisition and retention costs, other than loyalty programs costs, are recognized as an expense for the period in which they are incurred, that is to say on acquisition or renewal. In some cases, contractual clauses with retailers provide for a profit-sharing based on the recognized and paid revenue: this profit-sharing is expensed when the revenue is recognized.

•

Loyalty programs

Points awarded to customers are treated as a separable component to be delivered of the transaction that triggered the acquisition of points. Part of the invoiced revenue is allocated to this points based on their fair value taking into account of an estimated utilization rate, and deferred until the date on which the points are definitively converted into benefits. Fair value is defined as the excess price over the sales incentive that would be granted to any new customer. This principle is applied for both types of loyalty programs that exist within the Group, those with and those without a contractual renewal obligation.

•

Advertising and related costs

Advertising, promotion, sponsoring, communication and brand marketing costs are expensed as incurred.


2.8 Borrowing costs

The Group does not capitalize interest expense for the period of construction and acquisition of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets.



27



Back to Contents


2.9 Share issuance costs

External costs directly related to share issues are deducted from the related premium (net of any tax savings). Other costs are expenses as incurred.


2.10 Goodwill

Goodwill represents the excess of the purchase price of shares in consolidated companies, including transaction expenses, over the Group’s corresponding equity in the fair value of the underlying net assets at the date of acquisition. When full control is acquired, goodwill is deemed equal to fair value as established by reference to the market value of the underlying shares, or in the absence of an active market, by using generally accepted valuation methods such as those based on revenues or costs. Assets and liabilities acquired are not remeasured at fair value after an additional purchase when control has already been obtained.

•

Impairment test and Cash-Generating Units (CGUs)

A CGU is defined as the smallest identifiable group of assets that generates cash inflows that are largely independent of the cash inflows from other assets or groups of assets.

Goodwill is not amortized but tested for impairment at least once a year or more frequently when there is an indication that it may be impaired. IAS 36 “Impairment of Assets” requires these tests to be performed at the level of each CGU or groups of CGUs likely to benefit from acquisition-related synergies, within a business or geographical segment. This allocation is reviewed if the Group changes the level at which it monitors return on investment for goodwill testing purposes.

Impairment loss for goodwill is recorded in the income statement as a deduction from operating income and is never reversed subsequently.

•

Recoverable amount

To determine whether an impairment loss should be recognized, the carrying value of the assets and liabilities of the CGUs or groups of CGUs is compared to their recoverable amount. The recoverable amount of a CGU is the higher of its fair value less costs to sell and its value in use.

Fair value less costs to sell is the best estimate of the amount obtainable from the sale of a CGU in an arm’s length transaction between knowledgeable, willing parties, less the costs of disposal. This estimate is determined, on November 30, on the basis of available market information including: (i) the discounted present value of future cash flows over a five-year period, plus a terminal value, (ii) revenue and EBITDA multiples for comparable companies adjusted for a control premium, and (iii) revenue and EBITDA for comparable transactions.

Value in use is the present value of the future cash flows expected to be derived from the CGUs or groups of CGUs. Cash flow projections are based on economic and regulatory assumptions, license renewal assumptions and forecast trading conditions drawn up by France Telecom management, as follows:

•

cash flow projections are based on three to five-year business plans;

•

cash flow projections beyond that timeframe are extrapolated by applying a declining or flat growth rate over the next two years (for some CGUs), followed by a growth rate to perpetuity reflecting the expected long-term growth in the market;

•

the cash flows obtained are discounted using appropriate rates for the type of business and the countries concerned.

•

Net book value of CGUs and group of CGUs

Net book values of CGUs and groups of CGUs tested include goodwill, intangible assets with indefinite useful life arising from business combinations (except for the Orange trademark which is tested separately) and assets with finite useful life (property, plant and equipment, intangible assets and net working capital). Net book values are disclosed at the level of the CGUs and groups of CGUs, i.e. including accounting items related to transactions with other CGUs and groups of CGUs.




28



Back to Contents


2.11 Intangible assets

Intangible assets, consisting mainly of trademarks, subscriber bases, licenses, content rights, indefeasible rights of use, patents, development costs and software, are booked at acquisition or production cost.

When intangible assets are acquired in a business combination, their cost is generally determined in connection with the purchase price allocation based on their respective market value. When their market value is not readily determinable, cost is determined using generally accepted valuation methods based on revenues, costs or other appropriate criteria.

Internally generated trademarks and subscriber bases are not recognized as assets.

•

Trademarks

Trademarks having an indefinite useful life, such as the Orange trademark, are not amortized but tested for impairment at least annually. Finite-lived trademarks are amortized over their expected useful life.

•

Subscriber bases

Subscriber bases are amortized over the expected life of the commercial relationship, estimated at between 3 and 7 years.

•

Licenses

Licenses to operate mobile telephone networks are amortized on a straight-line basis over the license period from the date when the network is technically ready and the service can be marketed. The right to operate a mobile network is recorded in an amount corresponding to the fixed portion of the royalties due when the license was granted. The variable user fee (in France corresponding to 1% of qualifying revenues generated by the second and third generation network) is expensed as incurred.

•

Content rights

Library features and distribution rights are recognized at their acquisition cost as intangible assets when the content has been accepted technically and the rights have become valid.

Film co-production rights are accounted for based on the stage of completion of the film.

Content rights are amortized using the film forecast method (i.e. based upon the proportion of the film’s revenues recognized for the period to the film’s total estimated revenues).

Firm purchase commitments relating to content rights are recorded as off-balance sheet items, less any prepayments made, which are recognized as prepaid expenses.

•

Indefeasible Rights of Use

Indefeasible Rights of Use (IRUs) correspond to the right to use a portion of the capacity of a terrestrial or submarine transmission cable granted for a fixed period. IRUs are recognized as an asset when France Telecom has the specific indefeasible right to use an identified portion of the underlying asset, generally optical fibers or dedicated wavelength bandwidth, and the duration of the right is for the major part of the underlying asset’s economic life. They are depreciated over the shorter of the expected period of use and the life of the contract.

•

Patents

Patents are amortized on a straight-line basis over the expected period of use, not to exceed 20 years.

•

Software and research and development costs

The Group’s research and development projects mainly concern:

•

upgrading the network architecture or functionality;

•

developing service platforms aimed at offering new services o the Group’s customers.

These projects generally give rise to the development of software that does not form an integral part of the network’s tangible assets within the meaning of IAS 38.


29



Back to Contents


Development costs are recognized as intangible assets when the following conditions are met:

•

the intention to complete the intangible asset and use or sell it and the ability of adequate technical and financial resources for this purpose;

•

the probability for the intangible asset to generate future economic benefits for the Group; and

•

the reliable measurement of the expenditure attributable to the intangible asset during its development.

Research costs and development costs not fulfilling the above criteria are expensed as incurred.

Capitalized development costs and presented in the same way as software on the “other intangible assets” line. They are amortized on a straight-line basis over their expected useful life generally not exceeding 3 years.

Software is amortized on a straight-line basis over its expected useful life which does not exceed 5 years.

•

Other development costs

Website development costs are capitalized when all of the following conditions are met:

•

it is probable that the website will be successfully developed, the Group has adequate resources (technical, financial and other) and  has the intention of and the ability to complete the site and use or sell it;

•

the website will generate future economic benefits;

•

the Group has the ability to reliably measure the expenditure attributable to the website during its development.

Expenditure incurred after the website has been completed is recorded as an expense, except where it enables the website to generate future additional economic benefits and if it can be reliably estimated and attributed to the website.


2.12 Property, plant and equipment

•

Cost

The cost of tangible assets corresponds to their purchase or production cost, including costs directly attributable to bringing the asset to the location and condition necessary for it to be capable of operating in the manner intended by management. It also includes the initial estimate of the costs of dismantling and removing the item and restoring the site on which it is located, representing the obligation incurred by the Group.

The cost of networks includes design and construction costs, as well as capacity improvement costs.

The total cost of an asset is allocated among its different components and each component accounted for separately, when the components have different useful lives or when the pattern in which their future economic benefits are expected to be consumed by the entity varies. Depreciation is then revised accordingly.

Maintenance and repair costs are expensed as incurred, except where they serve to increase the asset’s productivity or prolong its useful life.

•

Finance leases

Assets acquired under leases that transfer the risks and rewards of ownership to France Telecom are recorded as assets and an obligation in the same amount is recorded in liabilities. The risks and rewards of ownership are considered as having been transferred to France Telecom when:

•

the lease transfers ownership of the asset to the lessee by the end of the lease term;

•

the Group has the option to purchase the asset at a price that is expected to be sufficiently lower than fair value at the date the option becomes exercisable for it to be reasonably certain, at the inception of the lease, that the option will be exercised;

•

the lease term is for the major part of the estimated economic life of the leased asset;

•

at the inception of the lease, the present value of the minimum lease payments amounts to at least substantially all of the fair value of the leased asset.


30



Back to Contents


Most of these agreements relate to network buildings.

Assets leased by France Telecom as lessor under leases that transfer the risks and rewards of ownership to the lessee are treated as having been sold.

•

Satellite capacity

Contracts relating to satellite capacity have been reviewed in light of the criteria set out in IFRIC 4. As no specific assets have been identified, these contracts have been classified as services.

•

Government grants

France Telecom may receive non-repayable government grants in the form of direct or indirect funding of capital projects, mainly provided by local and regional authorities. These grants are deducted from the cost of the related assets and recognized in the income statement, based on the pattern in which the related asset’s expected future economic benefits are consumed.

•

Depreciation

Property, plant and equipment are depreciated to write off their cost less any residual value on a basis that reflects the pattern in which their future economic benefits are expected to be consumed. Therefore, the straight-line basis is usually applied over the following estimated useful lives:

Buildings and leasehold improvements

10 to 30 years

Switching, transmission and other network

Equipment

5 to 10 years

Cables and civil works

15 to 30 years

Computer hardware

3 to 5 years

Other

3 to 14 years

These useful lives are reviewed annually and are adjusted if current estimated useful lives are different from previous estimates. These changes in accounting estimates are recognized prospectively.


2.13 Impairment of non-current assets other than goodwill and trademarks

In the case of a decline in the recoverable amount of an item of property, plant and equipment or an intangible asset to below its net book value, due to events or circumstances occurring during the period (such as obsolescence, physical damage, significant changes to the manner in which the asset is used, worse than expected economic performance, a drop in revenues or other external indicators) an impairment loss is recognized.

The recoverable amount of an asset is the higher of its fair value less costs to sell and its value in use, assessed by the discounted cash flows method, based on management’s best estimate of the set of economic conditions.

The impairment loss recognized is equal to the difference between net book value and recoverable amount.

Given the nature of its assets and activities, most of France Telecom’s individual assets do not generate independent cash flows that are independent of those from CGUs. The recoverable amount is then determined at the level of the CGU to which the asset belongs, except where:

•

The fair value less costs to sell of the individual asset is higher than its book value; or

The value in use of the asset can be estimated as being close to its fair value less costs to sell, where fair value can be reliably determined.




31



Back to Contents


2.14 Interests in associates

The carrying amount of investment in associates corresponds to the initial cost increased to recognize the investor’s share of the profit or loss of the investee after the date of acquisition. In case of losses and after the carrying amount of investment is reduced to zero, the Group ceases to recognize the additional share of losses since it is not committed beyond its investment.

An impairment test is performed when there is objective evidence of impairment, as for instance a decrease in quoted price when the investee is listed, significant financial difficulty of the investee, observable data indicating that there is a measurable decrease in the estimated future cash flows, information about significant changes with an adverse effect over the investee.

An impairment loss is recorded when the recoverable amount becomes lower to the carrying amount, recoverable amount being the higher of value in use and fair value less costs to sell (see note 2.10). Impairment loss can be reversed when the recoverable amount exceeds the carrying amount again.


2.15 Financial assets and liabilities

Financial assets and liabilities are recognized initially at fair value. They are subsequently measured either at fair value or amortized cost using the effective interest method, in accordance with the IAS 39 category they belong to.

The effective interest rate is the rate that discounts estimated future cash payments through the expected contractual term, or the most probable expected term of the financial instrument, to the net carrying amount of the financial liability. This calculation includes all fees and points paid or received between parties to the contract.

•

Recognition and measurement of financial assets

France Telecom does hold any financial assets qualifying as held-to-maturity assets.

Available-for-sale assets

Available-for-sale assets consist mainly of shares in non-consolidated companies, marketable securities that do not fulfill the criteria for classification in any of the other categories of financial assets, and certain assets related to in-substance defeasance transactions and cross-border leases (Qualified Technological Equipment (QTE) leases). They are recognized and subsequently measured at fair value. Fair value corresponds to quoted price for listed securities or, for non-listed securities, a valuation technique determined according to the most appropriate financial criteria in each case (comparable transactions, multiples for comparable companies, discounted present value of future cash flows).

Temporary changes in value are booked as “Gains (losses) on financial assets available-for-sale” within equity.

When there is an objective evidence that available-for-sale assets are impaired, the cumulative impairment loss included in equity is reclassified from equity to income.

Loans and receivables

This category mainly includes trade receivables, cash, some cash collateral, as well as other loans and receivables. These instruments are recognized at fair value upon origination and are subsequently measured at amortized cost by the effective interest method. Short-term receivables with no stated interest rate are measured at original invoice amount unless any significant impact of the application of an implicit interest rate.

If there is any objective evidence of impairment for these assets, the value of the asset is reviewed at each balance sheet date. An impairment is recognized in the income statement when the financial asset carrying amount is higher than its recoverable amount;

Impairment of trade receivables is based on two methods:

•

a statistic method: it depends on historical losses and leads to a separate impairment rate for each ageing balance category. This analysis is performed over an homogenous group of receivables, with similar credit characteristics because they belong to a customer category (mass-market, small offices and home offices). This method is used for Home and Personal Communication Services;


32



Back to Contents


•

a stand-alone method: the assessment of impairment probability and its amount are based on a set of relevant factors (ageing of late payment, other balance sheet positions with the counterpart, rating from independent agencies, geographical area). This method is used for carriers and operators (domestic and international, local, regional and national authorities) and for large accounts of Enterprise Communication Services.

Impairment losses identified for a group of receivables represent the intermediate step preceding impairment identification for individual receivable. When information is available (clients under bankruptcy or equivalent judicial proceedings), these receivables are then excluded from the statistic database and individually impaired.

Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss

Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss are:

•

assets held for trading that the Group acquired principally for the purpose of selling them in the near term;

•

assets that form a part of a portfolio of identified financial instruments that are managed together and for which there is evidence of a recent actual pattern of short-term profit taking;

•

derivative assets not qualifying for hedge accounting;

•

assets voluntarily classified at inception in this category because:

•

this classification allows to eliminate or significantly reduce a measurement or recognition inconsistency regarding recognition of assets or liabilities linked together, that would otherwise be assessed differently (for instance, a financial asset measured at fair value, linked to a financial liability measured at amortized cost);

•

a group of financial assets, financial liabilities or both is managed and its performance is valued on a fair value basis, in accordance with a documented risk management or investment strategy, and information about this group of financial instruments is provided internally on that basis to the Group’s key management personnel;

•

the entity decides not to separate from the host contract a separable embedded derivative. It should then assess the entire hybrid instrument at its fair value.

France Telecom can designate as at fair value at inception cash and cash equivalents with high liquidity and low volatility investments such as negotiable debt securities, deposits, mutual funds (OPCVM). These investments can be classified as cash equivalent on balance sheet if they meet the conditions required by the French Securities Regulator (AMF) (assets easily convertible into a determined cash amount and subject to a remote risk of change in value).

•

Recognition and measurement of financial liabilities

Financial liabilities at amortized cost

With the exception of financial liabilities at fair value, borrowings and other financial liabilities are recognized upon origination at fair value of the sums paid or received in exchange for the liability, and subsequently measured at amortized cost using the effective interest method. Interest-free payables are booked at their nominal value.

Transaction costs that are directly attributable to the acquisition or issue of the financial liability are deducted from the liability’s carrying value. The costs are subsequently amortized over the life of the debt, by the effective interest method.

Within France Telecom Group, some financial liabilities at amortized cost, including borrowings, are subject to hedge accounting. It relates mostly to fix rate borrowings hedged against changes in interest rate and currency value (fair value hedge) and to foreign currency borrowings in order to hedge to future cash flows against changes in currency value (cash flow hedge).

Compound instruments

Certain financial instruments comprise both a liability component and an equity component. For the France Telecom Group, they comprise perpetual bonds redeemable for shares (TDIRA) and bonds convertible into or exchangeable for new or existing shares (OCEANE).



33



Back to Contents


On initial recognition, the fair value of the liability component is the present value of the contractually determined stream of future cash flows discounted at the rate of interest applied at that time by the market to instruments of comparable credit status and providing substantially the same cash flows, on the same terms, but without the conversion option.

The equity component is assigned to the residual amount after deducting from the fair value of the instrument as a whole the amount separately determined for the liability component.

The equity component determined at initial recognition is not subsequently remeasured.

Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss

The abovementioned comments relating to financial assets at fair value through profit or loss are applicable to the financial liabilities of identical nature.

•

Recognition and measurement of derivative instruments

Derivative instruments are measured at fair value in the balance sheet and presented according to their maturity date, whether or not they qualify for hedge accounting under IAS 39.

Derivatives are classified as financial assets or liabilities through profit or loss or as a separate line item on the face of the balance sheet when they qualify for hedge accounting.

Hedge accounting is applicable when:

•

at the inception of the hedge, there is a formal designation and documentation of the hedging relationship;

•

at the inception of the hedge and in subsequent periods, the hedge is expected to be highly effective in achieving offsetting changes in fair value or cash flows attributable to the hedged risk during the period for which the hedge is designated (i.e. the actual results of the hedge are within a range of 80-125%).

Hedge accounting can be done in three different ways:

•

the fair value hedge is a hedge of the exposure to changes in fair value of a recognized asset or liability (or an identified portion of the asset or liability) that are attributable to a particular interest rate and/or currency risk and could affect profit or loss;

Hedged portion of these items is remeasured at fair value. Change in this fair value is booked in profit or loss and balanced by the symmetrical changes in the hedging financial instruments fair value to the limit of the hedge effectiveness.

•

the cash flow hedge is a hedge of the exposure to variability in cash flows that is attributable to a particular interest rate and/or currency risk associated with a recognized asset or liability or a highly probable forecast transaction (such as a future purchase or sale) and could affect profit or loss.

The hedged item being not recognized, the effective portion of change in fair value of the hedging instrument is booked in equity. The amounts recorded in equity are reclassified in profit or loss when the hedged item affects the profit or loss.

•

the net investment hedge is a hedge of the exposure to changes in values attributable to exchange risk of a net investment in a foreign operation and could affect profit or loss on the disposal of the foreign operation.

The effective portion of the net investment hedge is recorded in equity. The amounts booked in equity are reclassified in profit or loss on the disposal of the net investment.

Hedge accounting can be terminated in the following circumstances:

•

hedged item derecognition: amounts booked in equity are reclassified in profit or loss;

•

voluntary revocation: amounts booked in equity are reclassified in profit or loss on a straight-line basis over the residual term of the underlying item.

In both cases, subsequent changes in value are recorded in profit or loss.



34



Back to Contents


2.16 Broadcasting rights and equipment inventories

Network maintenance equipment and equipment to be sold to customers are stated at the lower of cost or net realizable value, taking into account expected revenues from the sale of packages comprising a mobile handset and a subscription. Cost corresponds to purchase or production cost determined by the weighted average cost method.

Film or sports broadcasting rights are recognized on the balance sheet when they are available for exhibition and expensed when broadcast.


2.17 Deferred taxes

Deferred taxes are recognized for all temporary differences between the book values of assets and liabilities and their tax basis, as well as for unused tax losses, using the liability method. Deferred tax assets are recognized only when their recovery is considered probable.

A deferred tax liability is recognized for all taxable temporary differences associated with investments in subsidiaries, branches and associates, and interests in joint ventures, except to the extent that both of the following conditions are satisfied:

•

the Group is able to control the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference (e.g. the payment of dividends); and

•

it is probable that the temporary difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future.

Accordingly, for fully and proportionally consolidated companies, a deferred tax liability is only recognized in the amount of the taxes payable on planned dividend distributions by these companies.

Deferred tax assets and liabilities are not discounted.

At each period end, France Telecom reviews the recoverable amount of the deferred tax assets carried by certain tax entities with significant tax loss carryforwards.

Deferred tax assets arising on these tax losses are not recognized under certain circumstances specific to each company/tax consolidation group concerned, and particularly where:

•

entities cannot assess the probability of the tax loss carryforwards being set off against future taxable profits, due to forecasts horizon and uncertainties as to the economic environment;

•

entities have not yet begun to use the tax loss carryforwards;

•

entities do not expect to use the losses within the timeframe allowed by tax regulations;

•

tax losses are uncertain to be used due to risks of differing interpretations with regard to the application of tax legislation.


2.18 Provisions

A provision is recognized when the Group has a present obligation towards a third party and it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation.

The obligation may be legal, regulatory or contractual or it may represent a constructive obligation deriving from the Group’s actions where, by an established pattern of past practice, published policies creating a valid expectation on the part of other parties that it will discharge certain responsibilities.

The estimate of the amount of the provision corresponds to the expenditure likely to be incurred by the Group to settle its obligation. If a reliable estimate cannot be made of the amount of the obligation, no provision is recorded and the obligation is deemed to be a contingent liability.


35



Back to Contents


Contingent liabilities are disclosed in the notes to the financial statements. They correspond to:

•

probable obligations that are not recognized because their existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within the Group’s control, or

•

present obligations arising from past events that are not recognized because it is not probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation or because the amount of the obligation cannot be measured with sufficient reliability.


•

Restructuring

Provisions for restructuring costs are recognized only when the restructuring has been announced and the Group has drawn up or has started to implement a detailed formal plan, prior to the balance sheet date.

•

Provisions for dismantling and restoring sites

The Group is required to dismantle equipment and restore sites. The provision is based on the best estimate of the amount required to settle the obligation. It is discounted by applying a discount rate that reflects the passage of time, based on market yields on high quality corporate bonds (or on government bonds when no corporate bond). This estimate is yearly revised and adjusted where appropriate against the asset to which it relates.

•

Provisions for the treatment of Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment

European Directive 2002/96/EC as amended by Directive 2003/108/EC distinguishes the waste of electrical and electronic equipment between the users (private households or professional) and between the responsibility of the market participants before and after August 13, 2005. The Group believes that its obligations principally involve equipment used for its own needs (network equipment, information systems equipment, etc.). In accordance with this Directive, the France Telecom Group has adopted the following principles:

•

obligations relating to collection, treatment and recovery of waste electrical and electronic equipment attached to the professional use and produced before August 13, 2005 are accrued for. The related liability is booked against the recognition of a tangible asset and is valued using an estimated volume to be recycled and an average cost per ton, and discounted as it will be settled at a future date;

•

obligations relating to waste of electrical and electronic equipment attached to the private households use before August 13, 2005, as well as those related to waste of electrical and electronic equipment attached to private households and professional use after August 13, 2005 have been considered as immaterial by the Group and have not therefore been accrued for.


2.19 Employee benefits

•

Post-employment benefits and other long-term benefits

Depending on the laws and practices in force in the countries where it operates, the Group has obligations in terms of employee benefits, among others:

•

civil servant’s pension plans in France: civil servants employed by France Telecom are covered by the government-sponsored civil and military pension plans, France Telecom’s obligation under these plans is limited to the payment of annual contributions (Act no. 96-660 dated July 26, 1996). Consequently, France Telecom has no obligation to fund future deficits of the pension plans covering its own civil servant employees or any other civil service plans.

•

retirement bonuses and other similar benefits: under the laws of some countries, employees are entitled to certain lump-sum payments or bonuses either on retirement or subsequent to retirement, depending on their years of service and end-of-career salary.

•

benefits other than pensions: France Telecom offers retired employees certain benefits such as free telephone lines and coverage of certain healthcare.


36



Back to Contents


These employee benefits are granted through:

•

defined contribution plans: the contributions payable are expensed when service is rendered; or

•

defined benefit plans: obligations under these plans are measured using the projected unit credit method:

•

their calculation is based on demographic (staff turnover, mortality, …) and financial assumptions (salary increase, inflation rate, etc.) defined at the level of each entity concerned and is discounted;

•

the discount rate is defined by country or geographical area and by reference to market yields on high quality corporate bonds (or government bonds where no active market exists);

•

actuarial gains and losses on defined benefit plans are booked in profit or loss using the corridor method (recognition of a specified portion of the net cumulative actuarial gains and losses that exceed 10% of the greater of (i) the present value of the defined benefit obligation; and (ii) the fair value of plan assets, over the average expected remaining working lives of the employees participating in the plan), contrary to those relating to other long-term benefits (seniority awards, long-term compensated absences, etc.) which are booked in profit and loss when they are incurred;

•

the Group’s defined benefit plans are generally not financed. In the rare cases where they are, hedging assets are measured at their fair value. Most of these assets being listed securities, fair value is determined by reference to quoted price.

•

Termination benefits

France Telecom set up an early retirement plan for civil servants and contract-based employees in France from 1996 to 2006. These employees receive 70% of their salary between the age of 55 and 60. This benefit is accounted for in the same way as lump-sum benefits payable on termination of service: a provision is recognized for the obligation.

Any other termination benefits are also covered by provisions. For all commitments where termination of employment contracts would trigger payment of an indemnity, actuarial gains and losses are recognized in profit or loss for the period when the assumptions are revised.

•

Individual training rights for employees (Droit Individuel à la Formation - DIF)

The Group has applied French GAAP (opinion 2004-F of CNC’s Comité d’urgence (Emerging Accounting Issues Committee)) to account for statutory training rights. Any expenditure incurred in this respect is recorded as a current expense and no provision is recognized. The credit of training hours is disclosed.

In the limited number of cases (request for individual training leave, redundancy or resignation) where these costs cannot be considered as remuneration of future services, the resulting short-term obligation is provided for as soon as its settlement becomes probable or certain.


2.20 Share-based compensation

The fair value of stock-options, employee shareholding plans and bonus shares concerning the shares of France Telecom or its subsidiaries is determined on the grant date.

The Group assumes that the grant date is the date when the main terms of the offer are announced to the employees, in accordance with the CNC communication dated December 21, 2004 on employee share ownership plans (Plans d’Epargne Entreprise - PEE ).

If applicable, a non-transferability discount is estimated by valuing the cost of a hedging strategy combining the forward sale of the non-transferable shares and the purchase of an equivalent number of transferable shares for cash, financed by borrowings, using a valuation model based on market data.

•

Employee shareholding plan

Following the sale by the State of a portion of France Telecom’s capital, preferred subscription rights must be awarded to the Group’s current and former employees, in accordance with Article 11 of the 1986 French Privatization Act.

Compensation cost is estimated based on fair value at grant date of the shares awarded. As no vesting period applies, the amount is expensed directly against equity.


37



Back to Contents


•

Other share-based payments

The fair value of stock-options and bonus shares is generally determined by reference to the exercise price, the life of the option, the current price of the underlying shares at the grant date, the expected share price volatility, expected dividends and the risk-free interest rate over the options’ life. Vesting conditions other than market conditions are not part of the fair value assessment but of the grant assumptions.


The amount so determined is recognized in labour expenses on a straight-line basis over the vesting period against:

•

employee benefit liabilities for cash-settled plans, revalued against profit or loss at each year-end ; and

•

equity for equity-settled plans.


2.21 Treasury shares

Treasury shares are recorded as a deduction from equity, at cost. When shares are sold out of treasury shares, the resulting profit or loss is recorded in equity net of tax.



38



Back to Contents



Note 3 - Main acquisitions, disposals of companies and changes in scope of consolidation


Year ended December 31, 2008


MAIN ACQUISITIONS

•

FT España

During 2008, through successive purchases, France Telecom acquired an additional 2.3% stake in FT España from the minority shareholders for a total of 169 million euros, thereby increasing its shareholding to 81.6%.

•

Orange Uganda

On October 17, 2008, France Telecom and Hits Telecom Uganda created Orange Uganda Limited to provide telecommunication services in Uganda under the Orange brand. France Telecom paid a total cash consideration of 95 million dollars (71 million euros). Of this, 50 million dollars (40 million euros) were paid on December 31, 2008 and the balance is payable in 2009. Hits Telecom Uganda transferred its license and its main telecom assets.

France Telecom controls Orange Uganda Limited with a 53% ownership interest. No goodwill was recognized on this transaction since Orange Uganda Limited is a new entity and the transfer of assets were made at fair value.

•

Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie (CET)

On January 15, 2008, France Telecom subscribed to CET group’s increase in capital (CET owns Photo Station and Photo Service), in consideration for 35% of the CET group's share capital. On November 14, 2008, France Telecom acquired an additional 13.5% of the share capital, thereby increasing its interest ownership to 48.5%. The total consideration of this investment was 68 million euros, including 36 million euros of offset receivables. As the other shareholders control the CET group, France Telecom accounts for its investment under the equity method.


OTHER CHANGES IN THE SCOPE OF CONSOLIDATION

•

Telkom Kenya

On December 21, 2007, the consortium formed between France Telecom (78.5%) and Alcazar Capital Limited (21.5%) acquired a 51% stake in Telkom Kenya Limited. The consideration paid by the Group amounted to 270 million euros. In 2008, the entity was consolidated by the Group, which identified the assets acquired and the liabilities assumed.


39



Back to Contents



Breakdown of assets acquired and liabilities assumed:


(in millions of euros)

Historical cost at

December 31, 2007

Allocation of

 purchase price

Fair value at

December 31, 2007

Other intangible assets

o/w brand

o/w subscriber bases

o/w favourable contracts

38

81

5

44

32

119

Property, plant and equipment

64

 

64

Other non-current assets

7

 

7

Total non-current assets

109

81

190

Trade receivables, net

91

 

91

Current assets

18

 

18

Cash and cash equivalents

5

 

5

Other current assets

109

 

109

Total current assets

223

 

223

Non-current financial liabilities at amortized cost excluding trade payables

(7)

 

(7)

Non-current employee benefits

(11)

 

(11)

Deferred tax liabilities

(0)

(24)

(24)

Total non-current liabilities

(18)

(24)

(42)

Current trade payables

(92)

 

(92)

Current employee benefits

(113)

 

(113)

Other current liabilities

(55)

 

(55)

Total current liabilities

(260)

 

(260)

Net assets acquired

53

57

110

Assets and liabilities attributable to minority interests

(26)

(28)

(54)

Net assets acquired attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A. (A)

27

29

56

Goodwill (B)

  

216

Purchase price consideration (A) + (B)

  

272 (1)

(1)

Including 2 million euros of direct costs attributable to the acquisition.


The brand was measured using the relief from royalty methodology, based on the present value of royalties that would have been paid to a third party for the use of the brand had the Group not owned it.

Subscriber bases were measured using the future cash flows generated by existing customers at the acquisition date. They are amortized over 14 years.

Contracts concluded on favourable conditions relating to emphyteotic land leases with the Kenyan government, were measured at fair value, that is, the difference between rents effectively paid to the Kenyan government and the rents that the company would have paid under normal market conditions. These assets are amortized over 70 years.


40



Back to Contents


The acquisition of Telkom Kenya resulted in recognition of residual goodwill of 216 million euros, mainly attributable to the planned launch of mobile operations in Kenya and to synergies between the fixed-line and mobile businesses.

Telkom Kenya generated revenues of 107 million euros over the full year 2008. France Telecom's consolidated net income for the year ended December 31, 2008 includes Telkom Kenya's net income, which was (97) million euros including (3) million euros of amortization of identified acquired assets (net of deferred taxes reversals) and (57) million euros of goodwill impairment (see Note 6).


•

Increase of ownership interest in Mobistar

During the first half of 2008, Mobistar purchased 2,0% of its own shares for a total of 74 million euros. France Telecom's interest in Mobistar therefore rose from 50.2% to 51.2%. Goodwill relating to this transaction amounted to 28 million euros. In addition, in May 2008, Mobistar reduced its capital by an amount of 248 millions euros. This operation, without effect on France Telecom's percentage interest  in Mobistar, results in a decrease of minority interests by an amount of 120 million euros.

During the second half of 2008, through a second share buyback program, Mobistar purchased 3.2% of its own shares for a total of 101 million euros. France Telecom's interest in Mobistar therefore rose from 51.2% to 52.9%. Goodwill relating to this transaction amounted to 43 million euros.

•

Increase of ownership interest in TP Group

During the second half of 2008, TP S.A. purchased 2.4% of its own shares for a total of 200 million euros. France Telecom's interest in TP S.A. therefore rose from 48.6% to 49.8%. Goodwill relating to this transaction amounted to 39 million euros.



Year ended December 31, 2007

MAIN ACQUISITIONS

•

Telkom Kenya

On December 21, 2007, the consortium formed between France Telecom (78.5%) and Alcazar Capital Limited (21.5%) acquired a 51% stake in Telkom Kenya, the historical Kenyan telecom operator, for a total consideration of 270 million euros. Telkom Kenya, which has 280,000 fixed-line customers, has been granted a new mobile license.

At December 31, 2007, the investment in Telkom Kenya was presented under "Non-consolidated investments" (see Note 15).

•

Ya.com

On July 31, 2007, France Telecom acquired the entire share capital of T-Online Telecommunications Spain (now called FT España ISP) from Deutsche Telekom for a total cash consideration of 150 million euros. FT España ISP is Spain's third broadband operator and trades under the name Ya.com.

Goodwill relating to this transaction amounted to 125 million euros, after recognizing 76 million euros of identified assets acquired and liabilities assumed, mainly subscriber bases (see Note 11). Taking account of the intercompany loans acquired from the former shareholder and the cash acquired, the net cash out was 319 million euros.

•

Orange Moldova

On July 2, 2007, France Telecom indirectly acquired, for a cash consideration of 103 million euros, an additional stake in Orange Moldova, bringing its total stake to 94.3%. Goodwill relating to this transaction amounted to 85 million euros.

•

VOXmobile

On July 2, 2007, Mobistar, which is 50.17% owned by France Telecom, acquired 90% of Luxembourg mobile operator VOXmobile for a cash consideration of 80 million euros. After analysis of the agreements between the parties regarding the remaining 10% interest, France Telecom was deemed to have acquired 100% of VOXmobile. Goodwill relating to the transaction amounted to 71 million euros, after recognizing 11 million euros of identified assets acquired and liabilities assumed.


41



Back to Contents


•

Acquisition of Groupe Silicomp

On January 4, 2007, France Telecom acquired a controlling block of approximately 54% of the capital of Groupe Silicomp, a company listed on Eurolist by Euronext Paris S.A., for a cash consideration of 50 million euros. Groupe Silicomp provides services in consulting, creation of software, and development and implementation of network infrastructures. Pursuant to the standing market offer (garantie de cours) launched from February 7 through February 27, 2007 at a price per share equal to the price paid for the controlling block, France Telecom acquired an additional 36.5% stake of Groupe Silicomp for 43 million euros. At December 31, 2007, France Telecom owned 96.1% of the shares. Goodwill relating to the transaction amounted to 70 million euros, after recognizing identified assets acquired and liabilities assumed. Taking account of the cash acquired, the net cash out of the acquisition amounted to 96 million euros.


MAIN DISPOSALS

•

Sale of Orange's Dutch mobile and internet businesses

On October 1, 2007, France Telecom sold its Dutch mobile and internet subsidiaries to Deutsche Telekom for a total of 1,317 million euros, net of disposal costs. The net gain on disposal before tax was 299 million euros (see Note 7). Taking account of the cash sold, the net proceeds amounted to 1,306 million euros.

•

Sale of the shareholding in Bluebirds

In 2007, pursuant to the disposal by Bluebirds of its interest in Eutelsat Communications, France Telecom received 110 million euros in February 2007 and disposed of all its interests in Bluebirds in May 2007. The net gain on disposal before tax was 104 million euros (see Note 7).


OTHER CHANGES IN THE SCOPE OF CONSOLIDATION

•

One

On October 2, 2007, the consortium formed between the investment fund Mid Europa Partners and France Telecom acquired the entire share capital of One GmbH for an enterprise value of 1.4 billion euros. The amount received by France Telecom for the sale of its 17.5% interest in One GmbH and the reimbursement of its shareholder's loan will be partially reinvested in order to obtain an indirect 35% stake in One GmbH.

The proceeds of this transaction amounted to 36 million euros, net of costs (see Notes 7 and 14). The transaction had a net positive effect of 82 million euros on cash flow.

•

Increase of ownership interest in TP Group

During 2007, TP S.A. purchased 2% of its own shares for a total of 185 million euros. As a result, France Telecom's ownership interest in TP S.A. rose from 47.5% to 48.6%. Goodwill relating to this transaction amounted to 37 million euros.


42



Back to Contents



Note 4 - Revenues


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Personal Communication Services (a)

29,477

29,119

France

10,516

9,998

United Kingdom

5,689

6,217

Spain

3,382

3,404

Poland

2,464

2,133

Other

7,573

7,550

Intra-segment eliminations

(147)

(183)

Home Communication Services (b)

22,951

22,671

France

18,071

17,957

Poland

2,995

2,886

Other

2,214

2,100

Intra-segment eliminations

(329)

(272)

Enterprise Communication Services (c)

7,778

7,721

Business network legacy

3,443

3,648

Advanced business network services

2,054

1,964

Integration and outsourcing of extended business services

1,349

1,139

Other business services

932

970

Inter-segment eliminations (d)

(6,718)

(6,552)

Total (a)+(b)+(c)+(d)

53,488

52,959

France Telecom generates substantially all of its revenues from services.


43



Back to Contents



Note 5 - Operating income and expenses


5.1 Labor expenses

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros )

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Average number of employees (1) (full-time equivalents) (unaudited)

182,793

183,799

Wages and employee benefit expenses

(8,559)

(8,767)

o/w 

- Wages and salaries

(6,381)

(6,518)

 

- Social security charges

(2,125)

(2,170)

 

- Capitalized costs (2)

606

575

 

- Other labor expenses (3)

(659)

(654)

Employee profit sharing

(319)

(359)

Share-based compensation (4)

(82)

(279)

o/w 

- Free Share Award plans

(57)

(149)

 

- Stock option plans

(25)

(23)

 

- Employee Shareholding Plan

-

(107)

Total labor expenses

(8,960)

(9,405)

(1)

Of whom approximately 36.6% are French civil servants at December 31, 2008 compared with 38.2% at December 31, 2007.

(2)

Capitalized labor expenses correspond to labor expenses included in the cost of assets produced by the Group.

(3)

Other labor expenses comprise other short-term allowances and benefits and payroll taxes.

(4)

See Note 26.


5.2 External purchases

External purchases comprise:

•

commercial expenses, which include purchases of handsets and other products sold, retail fees and commissions, and advertising, promotional, sponsoring and rebranding costs;

•

service fees and inter-operator costs;

•

other network charges and IT charges, which include outsourcing fees relating to technical operation and maintenance and IT;

•

and other external purchases, which include overheads, real estate fees, purchases of equipment and call center outsourcing fees, net of capitalized goods and services costs.


44



Back to Contents



 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Commercial expenses (1)

(8,329)

(8,082)

Service fees and inter-operator costs

(7,979)

(7,895)

Other network charges, IT charges

(2,916)

(2,822)

Other external purchases

(4,428)

(4,357)

     o/w rental expenses

(1,253)

(1,260)

Total external purchases  

(23,652)

(23,156)

(1)

Advertising, promotional, sponsoring and rebranding costs amounted to (1,283) million euros at December 31, 2008, and (1,258) million euros at December 31, 2007.


5.3 Other operating income

Other operating income primarily includes late-payment interest on trade receivables, proceeds from trade receivables written off, income from universal service, income relating to damage to lines, and penalties and reimbursements received.


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Total other operating income

380

440



5.4 Other operating expenses

Other operating expenses primarily include:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Business tax

(886)

(972)

Frequency use charges

(291)

(286)

Other taxes

(455)

(405)

Allowances and losses on trade receivables

(406)

(382)

Other charges

(220)

(315)

Total other operating expenses

(2,258)

(2,360)




45



Back to Contents



Note 6 - Impairment

Impairment tests are carried out annually, or when indicators show that assets may be impaired. This note describes the impairment tests carried out for 2007 and 2008. 


6.1 Definition of CGUs and groups of CGUs

•

Definition of cash-generating units (CGUs)

At December 31, 2008, the France Telecom Group had 39 main CGUs, generally corresponding to an operation in a particular country. The CGUs break down as follows by primary business segment:


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Personal Communication Services (PCS) (1)

26

24

Home Communication Services (HCS) (2)

11

10

Enterprise Communication Services  (ECS)

2

3

Total

39

37

(1)

In 2008, launch of mobile business in Niger.

(2)

In 2008, acquisition of Telkom Kenya.


•

Level of goodwill impairment testing

In accordance with the accounting policies described in Note 2.10, the main groups of CGUs used by France Telecom are the two CGUs representing the fixed-line and mobile businesses in Poland, the two CGUs representing the fixed-line and mobile businesses in Senegal, the two CGUs representing the fixed-line and mobile business in Jordan and the two CGUs representing the fixed-line and mobile businesses in Mauritius.

Other items of goodwill are tested at the level of each CGU, which is generally either the fixed-line or mobile business in each country.


46



Back to Contents


At December 31, 2008, the main items of goodwill and intangible assets with an indefinite useful life included in the net book values of the CGUs or groups of CGUs tested were:


(in millions of euros)

Goodwill

Intangible assets

 with an indefinite
useful life (1)

 

net book value

o/w impairment loss

PCS France

12,873

   

PCS Spain

4,658

   

PCS Romania

1,806

   

PCS UK

1,186

(1,665)

  

PCS Belgium

1,006

   

PCS Slovakia

806

   

PCS Switzerland

672

   

HCS France

2,117

(6)

  

HCS UK

229

   

HCS Spain

271

(140)

  

Poland (PCS and HCS)

2,628

(291)

 

192

ECS

421

(643)

  

Other

2,138

(151)

 

3,025

Total

30,811

(2,896)

 

3,217

(1)

Intangible assets with an indefinite useful life mainly comprise the Orange and TP brands (see Note 12).


6.2 Key assumptions used to determine recoverable amounts of the main CGUs and groups of CGUs

•

Basis for calculating recoverable amounts

See Note 2.10.

•

Key assumptions used to determine recoverable amounts

Key assumptions used to determine the value in use of assets in the telecommunications segment are similar in nature. They include:

•

market level, penetration rate and market share; decisions of regulators in terms of the pricing, accessibility of services, and Internet service provider tariffs between operators; the level of commercial expenses required to replace products and keep up with existing competitors or new market entrants; the impact on costs of changes in net revenues; and 

•

the level of investment spends, which may be affected by the roll-out of necessary new technologies.

The values assigned to each of these parameters reflect past experience and expected changes over the timeframe of the business plan. In the economic environment implied by the financial crisis:

•

business plans were built during the fourth quarter of 2008 in order to consider the latest trends, particularly regarding the first year of the plans;

•

the discount rate used to determine values in use may incorporate a specific risk premium to account for contingencies in the execution of certain business plans;

•

the perpetual growth rates used were maintained, as in the Group’s assessment carried out at the end of 2008, the current economic crisis should not lead to modify the long terms if its industry.


47



Back to Contents


The evolutions of economic and financial environment, legal and regulatory decisions, or changes in competitors’ behavior in response to the economic environment will affect the estimate of recoverable amounts, as unforeseen evolutions of political, economic or legal systems of some countries.

Other assumptions which influence the estimation of recoverable amounts are:


At December 31, 2008

Main CGUs and groups of CGUs

PCS

France

PCS

 UK

PCS

 Spain

PCS

 Romania

HCS

France

ECS excluding

 Globecast

HCS and

PCS Poland

Basis of recoverable amount

Value in use

Value in use

Value in use

Value in use

Fair value

Value in use

Value in use


Source used

5-year plans


 

Discounted cash flow


Growth rate to perpetuity

1.0%

2.0%

2.0%

4.0%

0.0%

0.0%

0.0 to 3.0%

Post-tax discount rate

8.25%

8.75%

8.25%

11.0%

7.5%

10.0%

11.0%

Pre-tax discount rate

12.1%

10.9%

10.3%

12.5%

n/a

15.8%

12.1 to 13.1%


At December 31, 2007 

Main CGUs and groups of CGUs

PCS  

France

PCS

 UK

PCS

Spain

HCS

France

ECS excluding

 Globecast

HCS and

 PCS Poland

Basis of recoverable amount

Fair value

Fair value

Value in use

Fair value

Value in use

Value in use

Source used

5-year plans

Plan

5-year plans

5-year plans

5-year plans

5-year plans

 

Discounted cash flow

EBITDA multiples

Discounted cash flow

Discounted cash flow

Discounted cash flow

Discounted cash flow

Growth rate to perpetuity

1.0%

n/a

2.0%

0.0%

0.0%

0.0 to 3.0%

Post-tax discount rate

7.7%

n/a

8.25%

7.7%

8.50%

11.0%

Pre-tax discount rate

n/a

n/a

10.7%

n/a

14.0%

13.1 to 13.5%


In accordance with IAS36, the basis used for impairment testing (fair value or value in use) may vary from one period to another; the recoverable amount is the higher of estimated value in use and fair value.


•

Sensitivity of recoverable amounts

At December 31, 2008, among the main CGUs or groups of CGUs listed above:

•

for PCS France, HCS France, PCS Romania and ECS excluding Globecast, the Group considers it improbable that there will be a change in valuation parameters that would bring the recoverable amount into line with the book value;

•

For PCS UK, a 225 basis point increase in the post-tax discount rate assumption or a 325 basis point decrease in the perpetual growth rate assumption would bring the value in use into line with the book value; likewise, a 28.9% fall in cash flow after the fifth year would bring the value in use into line with the book value;


48



Back to Contents


•

For PCS Spain, a 48 basis point increase in the discount rate assumption or a 63 basis point decrease in the perpetual growth rate assumption would bring the value in use into line with the book value; likewise, an 8.9% fall in cash flow after the fifth year would bring the value in use into line with the book value;

•

In Poland (PCS and HCS), a 154 basis point increase in the post-tax discount rate assumption or a 248 basis point decrease in the perpetual growth rate assumption would bring the value in use into line with the book value; likewise, a 20.6% fall in cash flow after the fifth year would bring the value in use in to line with the book value.


6.3 Impairment, net of reversals


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

 

Goodwill

Assets with a finite useful life

Assets with an indefinite useful life

Goodwill

Assets with a finite useful life

Assets with an indefinite useful life

HCS Spain

(140)

(2)

-

-

(1)

-

HCS Kenya

(57)

-

-

(26)

-

-

PCS Ivory Coast

(42)

-

-

-

-

-

HCS France

-

(4)

-

-

5

-

Other

(32)

(3)

-

-

(81)

(30)

Total

(271)

(9)

-

(26)

(77)

(30)


In Spain, the 140 million euro impairment charge is based on the market value of the domestic fixed-line market. In 2008, this amount factors in a material decline in the market valuation of revenues per broadband subscriber based on comparable transactions.

Impairment recognized for Kenya is due to difficulties in implementing the transition plan and in starting up mobile business operations, due mainly to the post-election riots in Kenya at the beginning of 2008.


49



Back to Contents



Note 7 - Gains and losses on disposals of assets

The main disposals are set out in Note 3.


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Tower Participations

-

307

Orange's Dutch mobile and internet businesses

-

299

Bluebirds

-

104

One

-

36

Other

11

23

Total

11

769




50



Back to Contents



Note 8 - Restructuring costs  

Restructuring costs, net of restructuring provision reversals, break down as follows:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Public service secondment costs in France

(69)

(66)

Early retirement plan in France (1)

(35)

19

Other restructuring costs

(366)

(161)

   o/w France Telecom S.A.

(185)

(97)

   o/w TP S.A.

(49)

-

   o/w FT España

(38)

-

   o/w Orange UK

(28)

(31)

Total

(470)

(208)

(1)

Primarily impact from discount rate revision and from 2008 Social Security Financing Act.


51



Back to Contents



Note 9 - Finance costs, net


The tables below show all gains and losses on financial assets and liabilities.


 

Year ended December 31, 2008

 

Finance costs

Operating income

Equity

(in millions of euros)

Cost of net financial debt

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

Other net financial expenses

 

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

Other

Retained earnings

Assets available for sale

9

3

-

 

-

1

(54)(6)

Loans and receivables

136

(970)

-

 

(10)

(333)(5)

-

Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss, excluding derivatives

169

(86)

-

 

-

-

-

Liabilities at amortized cost (1)

(2,630)

710

(26)(2)

 

(11)

(3)

-

Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss, excluding derivatives

-

-

24(3)

 

-

-

-

Derivatives

(67)

280

(381)(4)

 

112

-

434(6)

Total

(2,383)

(63)

(383)

(2,829)

91

(335)

380

Discounting expense

   

(158)

   

Finance costs, net

   

(2,987)

   

(1)

Including the change in fair value of hedged liabilities.

(2)

Redemptions of perpetual bonds redeemable for shares (TDIRA) for (26) million euros.

(3)

Change in fair value of the commitment to purchase the minority interests in Ten for 14 million euros and in Orange Madagascar for 10 million euros.

(4)

Change in fair value of the price guarantee given to the minority shareholders of FT España.

(5)

Mainly receivables written off for (421) million euros and sundry interests on receivables for 77 million euros.

(6)

See Note 20.



At December 31, 2008, net finance costs include financial income of 314 million euros, from which 195 million euros generated by France Telecom S.A..


52



Back to Contents



 

Year ended December 31, 2007

 

Finance costs

Operating income

Equity

(in millions of euros)

Cost of net financial debt

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

Other net financial expenses

 

Foreign exchange gains (losses)

Other

Retained earnings

Assets available for sale

5

(6)

-

 

-

-

(38)

Loans and receivables

48

(445)

-

 

(28)

(286)(4)

-

Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss, excluding derivatives

257

-

-

 

-

-

-

Liabilities at amortized cost (1)

(2,766)

1,177

(64)(2)

 

29

(2)

-

Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss, excluding derivatives

-

-

(32)(3)

 

-

-

-

Derivatives

31

(730)

-

 

(7)

-

319

Total

(2,425)

(4)

(96)

(2,525)

(6)

(288)

281

Discounting expense

   

(125)

   

Finance costs, net

   

(2,650)

   

(1)

Including the change in fair value of hedged liabilities.

(2)

Redemptions of perpetual bonds redeemable for shares (TDIRA) for (64) million euros.

(3)

Change in fair value of the commitment to purchase the minority interests in Orange Madagascar for (32) million euros.

(4)

Mainly receivables written off for (379) million euros and sundry interests on receivables for 96 million euros.


At December 31, 2007, net finance costs included financial income of 304 million euros, from which 196 million euros generated by France Telecom S.A..


53



Back to Contents



Note 10 - Income tax

10.1

France Telecom Group tax proof

Income tax for 2008 is based on the application of the effective tax rate on pre-tax income for the year ended December 31, 2008. In France, deferred taxes are calculated based on enacted tax rates, i.e. 34.43% for 2008 and thereafter.

The reconciliation between effective income tax expense on continuing operations and the theoretical tax calculated based on the French statutory tax rate is as follows:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Net income of continuing operations before tax

7,285

8,149

Impairment of goodwill

271

26

Net income from continuing operations before tax and impairment of goodwill

7,556

8,175

Statutory income tax rate

34.43%

34.43%

Theoretical tax

(2,602)

(2,815)

Share of profits (losses) of associates

(73)

1

Recognition of share-based compensation

(9)

(30)

Recognition / (Derecognition) of tax assets

(268)

809

Difference in tax rates

328

283

Change in local tax rate

(3)

84

Capital gains and losses of equity investments not taxable at the current tax rate

1

283

Price guarantee granted to the minority shareholders of FT España

(130)

-

Other

(37)

55

Effective tax

(2,793)

(1,330)




54



Back to Contents


10.2 Income tax benefit/(charge)

The income tax split between the tax groups and the other subsidiaries is as follows:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

France tax group

(1,971)

(499)

 

- Current taxes

(46)

3

 

- Deferred taxes

(1,925)

(502)

UK tax group

18

110

 

- Current taxes

(1)

(3)

 

- Deferred taxes

19

113

Spain

(619)

(494)

 

- Current taxes

-

22

 

- Deferred taxes

(619)

(516)

TP Group

(116)

(147)

 

- Current taxes

(160)

(174)

 

- Deferred taxes

44

27

Other subsidiaries

(105)

(300)

 

- Current taxes

(478)

(457)

 

- Deferred taxes

373

157

Income Tax

(2,793)

(1,330)

 

- Current taxes

(685)

(609)

 

- Deferred taxes

(2,108)

(721)


•

France tax group

The deferred tax charge in 2008 for the France tax group mainly consisted of (1,905) million euros in tax loss carryforwards utilization.

In 2007, the deferred tax change for the France tax group included (2,172) million euros in tax loss carryforwards utilized and 1,573 million euros due to reassessment of the recoverability horizon.

France Telecom and its main French subsidiaries were audited by the French tax authorities for the years 2000 to 2005 inclusive, except for the entities of the former Orange tax consolidation group, which were audited for the years 2002 to 2005 inclusive. These audits have been completed and the tax adjustments that were accepted had no material impact on France Telecom's 2008 financial statements. As for the tax adjustments that were contested, the relevant companies have made their comments and are awaiting a final decision by the tax authorities.

•

UK tax group

In 2007, the change in the income tax rate in the United Kingdom led to an 84 million euro increase in deferred tax income for the period.

•

Spain

At December 31, 2008, the deferred tax charge mainly comprised (577) million euros for reassessment of the recoverability horizon for the Spanish tax assets. At December 31, 2007, the deferred tax charge included (474) million euros for this item.

Members of the former Auna tax group were subject to an audit by the tax authorities for the years 2003 to 2005 inclusive. This audit has not been completed.


55



Back to Contents


•

Other tax entities

A net deferred tax gain of 406 million euros was recognized within other tax entities that have evidenced the probable nature of their future taxable profits.


10.3 Balance sheet tax position


  

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Assets

Equity and liabilities

Net

Assets

Equity and liabilities

Net

France tax group

      
 

- Current taxes

11

22

(11)

51

23

28

 

- Deferred taxes

4,060

-

4,060

6,003

-

6,003

UK tax group

      
 

- Current taxes

-

12

(12)

-

8

(8)

 

- Deferred taxes

-

1,003

(1,003)

-

1,322

(1,322)

Spain

      
 

- Current taxes

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

- Deferred taxes

461

127

334

1,038

85

953

TP Group

      
 

- Current taxes

40

3

36

14

4

10

 

- Deferred taxes

62

-

62

28

-

28

Other subsidiaries

      
 

- Current taxes

93

240

(147)

46

296

(250)

 

- Deferred taxes

559

158

401

204

132

72

Net balance sheet income tax

      
 

- Current taxes

144

277

(133)

111

331

(220)

 

- Deferred taxes

5,142

1,288

3,854

7,273

1,539

5,734




56



Back to Contents


The balance sheet tax position by class of temporary difference breaks down as follows:


  

Year ended

  

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

 

Net

Net

Provisions for early retirement plans

 

411

618

Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets

 

(813)

(881)

Tax loss carryforwards

 

3,709

5,408

Other differences

 

547

589

Net deferred taxes - France Telecom Group

 

3,854

5,734


At December 31, 2008, unrecognized deferred tax assets for France Telecom Group amounted to 5.4 billion euros (4.8 billion euros in 2007), mainly comprising tax loss carry-forwards located in many jurisdictions and that were not recognised in the consolidated financial statements in accordance with the accounting policies described in Note 2.17.



10.4 Changes in Group net deferred taxes


  

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance (balance sheet asset position)

 

5,734

6,402

Changes in the scope of consolidation

 

(50)

(11)

Recognition in net income

 

(2,108)

(721)

Recognition in equity

 

(24)

(106)

Translation adjustments and other items (1)

 

302

170

Closing balance (balance sheet asset position)

 

3,854

5,734

(1)

In 2008, including 299 million euros mainly for conversion of tax assets and liabilities in the United Kingdom.



57



Back to Contents



Note 11 - Goodwill


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007


(in millions of euros)

Cost

Accumulated impairment losses

Net

Net

PCS

26,504

(1,706)

24,798

24,931

HCS (1)

6,139

(547)

5,592

6,059

ECS

1,064

(643)

421

399

Total

33,707

(2,896)

30,811

31,389

(1)

Goodwill on TP Group is included in the HCS segment. It is tested for impairment at the level of the "Poland Group" of CGUs (see Note 6).


Movements in the net book value of goodwill are as follows:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

31,389

31,517

Acquisitions (1)

366

436

Disposals (2)

(5)

(334)

Impairment (3)

(271)

(26)

Translation adjustment (4)

(674)

(79)

Reclassifications and other items (5)

6

(125)

Closing balance

30,811

31,389

(1)

See Note 3. Including, in 2008, Telkom Kenya for 216 million euros, Mobistar for 71 million euros and TP Group for 39 million euros. Including, in 2007, FT España ISP (Ya.com) for 125 million euros, Orange Moldova 85 million euros, VOXmobile 71 million euros and Groupe Silicomp for 70 million euros.

(2)

See Note 3. In 2007, (334) million euros relating to the sale of Orange's Dutch mobile and internet businesses.

(3)

See Note 6.

(4)

In 2008, this item mainly includes (409) million euros for TP Group, (354) million euros for Orange in the United Kingdom and 83 million euros for Orange Slovensko.

(5)

In 2007, (184) million euros of remeasurement relating to the merger of the Spanish entities in 2006.



58



Back to Contents



Note 12 - Other intangible assets


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007


(in millions of euros)

Cost

Accumulated depreciation and amortization

Impairment

Net

Net

Telecommunication licenses

8,549

(2,640)

-

5,909

7,172

Brands

3,928

-

(711)

3,217 (1)

4,090

Subscriber bases

5,681

(4,445)

(4)

1,232 (2)

1,671

Software

9,596

(5,824)

(38)

3,734

3,442

Other intangible assets

946

(422)

(165)

359

283

Total

28,700

(13,331)

(918)

14,451

16,658

(1)

Including, at December 31, 2008, the Orange brand for 2,961 million euros and the TP brand for 192 million euros.

(2)

Including, in 2008, FT España for 1,005 million euros, the Jordanian entities for 97 million euros and Sonatel for 76 million euros.


Movements in the net book value of other intangible assets were as follows:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

16,658

18,713

Acquisitions of other intangible assets (1)

1,883

1,693

Impact of changes in the scope of consolidation (2)

238

(220)

Disposals

(15)

(10)

Depreciation and amortization (3)

(2,365)

(2,532)

Impairment

(13)

(37)

Translation adjustment (4)

(2,134)

(801)

Reclassifications and other items

199

(148)

Closing balance

14,451

16,658

(1)

In 2008, it mainly relates to software for an amount of 1,530 million euros and licenses for an amount of 273 million euros. In 2007, this item mainly related to software for an amount of 1,477 million euros.

(2)

In 2008, this item mainly relates to the acquisition of Telkom Kenya for 120 million euros and the acquisition of Orange Uganda for 68 million euros. In 2007, this item mainly related to the sale of the Dutch businesses for an amount of (374) million euros and the acquisition of FT España ISP (Ya.com) for an amount of 92 million euros.

(3)

In 2008, this item mainly relates to telecommunication licenses for an amount of (551) million euros and subscriber bases for an amount of (468) million euros (respectively (624) million euros and (531) million euros in 2007).

(4)

In 2008, this item mainly relates to Orange in United Kingdom for (2,020) million euros (in 2007, (828) million euros).




59



Back to Contents


Information on telecommunication licenses at December 31, 2008 

France Telecom's commitments under licenses awarded are disclosed in Note 30.



(in millions of euros)

Cost

Net

Residual useful life(1)

GSM

563

250

6.7

UMTS

4,301

3,136

12.9

United Kingdom

4,864

3,386

 

GSM

188

163

11.2

UMTS

639

487

11.2

Spain

827

650

 

GSM

281

229

12.3

UMTS

629

462

12.6

France

910

691

 

GSM (2 licenses)

146

26

4.8 to 5.7

UMTS

393

322

14.9

Poland

539

348

 

Other (2)

1,409

834

 

Total telecommunication licenses

8,549

5,909

 

(1)

In number of years at December 31, 2008.

(2)

This item mainly relates to licenses in Belgium and Egypt.


Capitalized expenditure


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Net

Net

External purchases

484

463

Labour expenses

337

317

Total

821

780



60



Back to Contents



Note 13 - Property, plant and equipment


 

                                                                   Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007


(in millions of euros)

Cost

Accumulated depreciation and amortization

Impairment

Net

Net

Land and buildings

6,812

(3,334)

(388)

3,090

3,098

Networks and terminals

73,304

(51,472)

(232)

21,600

23,002

IT equipment

3,912

(2,947)

(15)

950

1,149

Other property, plant and equipment

1,975

(1,053)

(28)

894

600

Total

86,003

(58,806)

(663)

26,534

27,849


Movements in the net book value of property, plant and equipment were as follows:


 

          Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

27,849

28,222

Acquisitions of property, plant and equipment (1)

5,433

5,415

Impact of changes in the scope of consolidation (2)

123

(290)

Disposals and retirements

(226)

(82)

Depreciation and amortization (3)

(5,411)

(5,579)

Impairment

4

(70)

Translation adjustment (4)

(1,146)

16

Reclassifications and other items

(92)

217

Closing balance

26,534

27,849

(1)

In 2008, this item relates mainly to networks and terminals for an amount of 4,161 million euros (4,481 million euros in 2007). Including 176 million euros acquired under finance leases at December 31, 2008 (44 million euros at December 31, 2007).

(2)

In 2008, this item mainly relates to the acquisition of Telkom Kenya for 64 million euros and the acquisition of Orange Uganda for 31 million euros. In 2007, this item related to the sale of the Dutch businesses for an amount of (418) million euros and the acquisition of FT España (Ya.com) for an amount of 97 million euros.

(3)

In 2008, this item relates mainly to networks and terminals for an amount of (4,615) million euros (in 2007, (4,834) million euros).

(4)

In 2008, this item relates mainly to TP Group for (720) million euros and Orange in the United Kingdom for (532) million euros.




61



Back to Contents


Property, plant and equipment held under finance leases 


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Net

Net

Land and buildings

300

195

Networks and terminals

288

363

IT equipment and other

14

15

Total

602

573


Capitalized expenditure


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Net

Net

External purchases

665

691

Labour expenses

269

258

Other

68

64

Total

1,002

1,013


62



Back to Contents



Note 14 - Interests in associates

14.1 Investments in associates

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

282

360

Dividends

-

(1)

Share of profits (losses)

(12)

4

Impairment (1)

(199)

-

Acquisitions  (2)

107

-

Disposals of investments  

(6)

(35)

Other impact of changes in scope of consolidation

-

(46)

Closing balance

172

282

(1)

Relates to Sonaecom.

(2)

Including Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie for 68 million euros in 2008.


The net book values of France Telecom's investments in associates are as follows:

(in millions of euros)

 

Year ended


Company


Main activity

% interest

December 31, 2008


December 31, 2008


December 31, 2007

Sonaecom

Telecommunications operator in Portugal

20%

84

273

Orange Austria (ex-One)

Telecommunications operator in Austria

35%

-

-

Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie (1)

Distributor

48.50%

54

-

Other

 

-

34

9

Total

  

172

282

(1)

See Note 3.

14.2 Main financial aggregates – investments in associates

Unless otherwise indicated, the main financial aggregates for 100% of each associate as of December 31 were as follows:

•

Sonaecom

France Telecom's ownership interest in Sonaecom was 20% at December 31, 2008 (19.19% at December 31, 2007).

The main financial aggregates for Sonaecom are as follows:

(in millions of euros)

 

2008 (1)

2007

Revenues

 

727

893

Net income

 

(8)

37

Total assets

 

1,808

1,759

Equity

 

921

935

France Telecom share in equity

 

184

179

(1)

Latest figures reported for the nine months ended September 30, 2008 (unaudited).


63



Back to Contents


•

Orange Austria (ex-One)

In October 2007, One, which has then been renamed Orange Austria, underwent a Leveraged Buy Out (LBO). France Telecom's share of the total cash consideration received was 154 million euros on the transaction date.

At the same time, France Telecom and the Mid Europa Partners (MEP) investment fund entered into an investment agreement through which France Telecom invested 108 million euros in Orange Austria, giving it an interest of 35% in Orange Austria, compared with its 17.45% stake in One before the LBO.

Other than the shares pledged as collateral, France Telecom provided no guarantee for any liability, nor entered into any agreement that would require it to provide financial support to Orange Austria in any manner whatsoever.

France Telecom's ownership interest in Orange Austria was 35% at December 31, 2008 and 2007.

The main financial aggregates for Orange Austria are as follows:

(in millions of euros)

 

2008

2007 (1)

Revenues

 

615

164

Net income

 

(82)

(73)

Total assets

 

878

895

Non-current financial liabilities

 

1,264

1,235

Equity

 

(626)

(544)

France Telecom share in equity

 

(219)

(190)

(1)

3 months to December 31, 2007.


Based on the terms of this transaction, France Telecom deemed that its stake in Orange Austria is identical to the stake it previously held in One, plus a cash distribution, as Orange Austria is the same company as One, only more leveraged. Equity recognized on the LBO transaction date amounted to (471) million euros for 100%, representing One's pre-LBO equity less 774 million euros of distributions paid to One's historical shareholders (net of the amount reinvested by France Telecom) plus the 200 million euro investment of the new shareholder, MEP. Given negative equity and the absence of commitment, the contribution to the consolidated financial statements is nil. The distribution, net of France Telecom's reinvestment, was first recorded as a reduction of the carrying amount (10 million euros before the transaction), and the amount of 36 million euros in excess of this value was recognized as a gain.

France Telecom will subsequently start to recognize a share of income in Orange Austria only when France Telecom's share of Orange Austria's cumulative net income equals the gain recognized in the transaction, in accordance with IAS 28. The share of Orange Austria's net income that was not recognized in the France Telecom Group's consolidated financial statements amounted to (29) million euros in 2008 and (26) million euros in 2007.

•

Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie

France Telecom's ownership interest in CET was 48.5% at December 31, 2008.

The main financial aggregates for CET are as follows:

(in millions of euros)

 

2008 (1)

Revenues

 

149

Net income

 

(38)

Total assets

 

 NC

Equity

 

(52)

France Telecom share in equity

 

(25)

(1)

The share of CET's earnings recognized in the consolidated financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2008 was determined based on an estimate of the net income of CET, whose closing date occurs after France Telecom financial results publication.



64



Back to Contents



Note 15 - Assets available for sale


  

Year ended

  

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

% interest

Fair value

Fair value

Bull S.A. (1)

10%

11

37

Freenet AG (ex MobilCom) (1)

1%

2

10

Telkom Kenya (2)

40%

-

244

Investment funds(3)

-

44

65

Other companies

-

52

45

Total non-consolidated investments

 

109

401

Deposits relating to QTE leases and similar items  (4)

-

90

105

Other financial assets at fair value (5)

-

4

12

Assets available for sale

 

203

518

(1)

Listed companies.

(2)

Consolidated since 2008.

(3)

Principally in research and development.

(4)

See Notes 21 and 29.

(5)

Assets available for sale include marketable securities and investments held for over one year.


Changes in assets available for sale are summarized in the table below:


(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

518

338

Change in fair value (1)


(54)

(38)

Other changes (2)

(261)

218

Closing balance

203

518

(1)

Recorded in equity in the assets available for sale reserve (see Note 20).

(2)

Including, in 2008, Telkom Kenya for an amount of (244) million euros.



65



Back to Contents



Note 16 - Inventories


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Inventories of handsets

692

740

Other products/services sold

234

272

Available Broadcasting rights

32

-

Other supplies

96

139

Gross value (1)

1,054

1,151

Provisions for obsolescence

(78)

(83)

Net value

976

1,068

(1)

Includes stocks in channel for approximately 129 million euros in 2008 on entity Orange France and 94 million euros in 2007.



66



Back to Contents



Note 17 - Loans and receivables



  

Year ended

  

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

 

Cost

Depreciation

Net

Net

Trade receivables

 

7,380

(1,217)

6,163

6,556

Loans and other receivables

 

1,757

(140)

1,617

2,041

Cash

 

1,034

-

1,034

1,303

Loans and receivables

 

10,171

(1,357)

8,814

9,900

Cash and cash equivalents amount to 4,800 million euros at December 31, 2008 (4,025 million euros at December 31, 2007), including 3,766 million euros of cash equivalents (see Note 18).


17.1 Trade receivables

The France Telecom Group is committed in trade receivables securitization programs in France and in the United Kingdom. As France Telecom has not transferred all risks related to the securitized trade receivables, and particularly the credit risk, the conditions for derecognition are not met. Accordingly, these receivables (2.5 billion euros) and the external liabilities of the securitization vehicles (1.2 billion euros) remain in the balance sheet.

Net trade receivables are broken down as follows:

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Trade receivables depreciated according to their age

1,676

1,935

Trade receivables depreciated according to other criteria

373

988

Net trade receivables past due

2,049

2,923

Not past due

4,114

3,633

Net trade receivables

6,163

6,556


The following table provides an aging balance of net trade receivables past due and depreciated according to their age:

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Past due - under 180 days

1,339

1,591

Past due - 180 to 360 days

198

143

Past due - over 360 days

139

201

Total net trade receivables past due and depreciated according to their age

1,676

1,935



67



Back to Contents


The table below provides an analysis of the change in provision for trade receivables:


(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

(1,123)

(1,136)

Change in provision for depreciation

15

(3)

Translation adjustment

69

15

Impact of changes in the scope of consolidation

(146)

8

Reclassifications and other items

(32)

(7)

Closing balance

(1,217)

(1,123)

421 million euros of trade receivables were written off at December 31, 2008 (379 million euros at December 31, 2007).


17.2 Loans and other receivables


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Cost

Depreciation

Net

Net

Cash collateral paid (1)

238

-

238

788

Escrow deposit  (2)

964

-

964

757

Deposits related to QTE leases and assimilated (3)

14

-

14

91

Receivables from non-consolidated companies and current accounts

177

(140)

37

69

Other (4)

364

-

364

336

Total loans and other receivables

1,757

(140)

1,617

2,041

o/w current loans and other receivables

63

-

63

81

o/w non-current loans and other receivables

1,694

(140)

1,554

1,960

(1)

See Note 27.3.

(2)

See Note 30.

(3)

See Note 21.

(4)

Mainly comprises security deposits and sundry loans.


The table below provides an analysis of the change in provision for loans and other receivables:


(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

(133)

(144)

Change in provision for depreciation

(1)

(10)

Translation adjustment

(6)

13

Impact of changes in the scope of consolidation

-

8

Closing balance

(140)

(133)

For loans and other receivables, amounts past due but not depreciated are not material.


68



Back to Contents



Note 18 - Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Deposits

1,060

89

Certificates of deposit

1,249

2,213

Commercial papers

450

344

Mutual funds (SICAV and FCP)

866

69

Other

141

7

Cash equivalents

3,766

2,722

Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss

827

588

Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss

4,593

3,310



The table below shows a breakdown of other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss:


 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Current

Non-current

Total

Current

Non-current

Total

Negotiable debt securities (1)

608

-

608

488

-

488

Derivatives held for trading (assets) (2)

110

106

216

44

54

98

Other investments at fair value

3

-

3

2

-

2

Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss

721

106

827

534

54

588

(1)

Maturing on January 2, 2009.

(2)

See Note 22.


Apart from derivative assets, which are classified by nature as financial assets at fair value through profit or loss, the other financial assets are included in this category, as they are short-term investments for which management and performance are evaluated on the basis of fair value.



69



Back to Contents



Note 19 - Other assets and prepaid expenses

19.1 Other assets


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

VAT receivables

1,365

1,266

Other tax receivables

73

52

Employee and payroll-related receivables

38

42

Advances and down payments relating to non-current assets (1)

79

245

Other

620

493

Total

2,175

2,098

o/w other non-current assets

32

63

o/w other current assets

2,143

2,035

(1)

Including, in 2007, 145 million euros relating to the purchase of buildings.


19.2 Prepaid expenses


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Prepaid external purchases

550

573

Other prepaid operating expenses

31

100

Total

581

673


70



Back to Contents



Note 20 - Equity

At December 31, 2008, France Telecom S.A.’s share capital amounted to 10,459,964,944 euros, comprising 2,614,991,236 ordinary shares with a par value of 4 euros each.

At December 31, 2008, the French State owned 26.65% of France Telecom S.A.'s share capital either directly or indirectly through ERAP and 26.75% of the voting rights.


20.1

Changes in share capital

During the period ended December 31, 2008, France Telecom S.A. issued 642,325 new shares following the exercise of stock options, including:

•

5,350 shares in respect of plans granted by France Telecom S.A. from 2005 to 2007;

•

204,334 shares in respect of plans granted by Wanadoo between 2000 and 2003, then transferred to France Telecom S.A. when the merger of Wanadoo occured; and

•

432,641 shares in respect of plans granted by Orange between 2001 and 2003 and for which the holders received options liquidity instruments.

The capital increase resulting from the issuance of these new shares was noted by the Board of Directors at its meeting of March 3, 2009.


20.2

 Treasury shares

Pursuant to the authorization of the Shareholders’ Meeting of May 21, 2007, the Board of Directors implemented a share buyback program (the "2007 Buyback Program"). The description of the program was published on May 21, 2007.

On May 27, 2008, pursuant to the authorization of the Shareholders’ Meeting held on the same day, the Board of Directors implemented a new share buyback program (the "2008 Buyback Program") and ended the unused portion of the 2007 Buyback Program with immediate effect. The description of the 2008 Buyback Program was published on May 28, 2008. During the period ended December 31, 2008, France Telecom S.A. bought back 1,000,000 shares under the authorized program (excluding shares bought back under the liquidity contract), and granted 504 shares before the vesting date under the free share award plan.

The liquidity contract entered into on May 9, 2007 with an investment services provider was renewed on its anniversary date for a period of one year and has continued to be implemented under the 2008 Buyback Program. An amount of 100 million euros has been allocated to the liquidity account for purposes of implementing the contract.

At December 31, 2008, the company held 10,113,380 of its own shares (and no shares under the terms of the liquidity contract), recorded as a reduction in equity.

At December 31, 2007, the company held 10,528,884 of its own shares (including 1,415,000 shares under the terms of the liquidity contract), recorded as a reduction in equity.





71



Back to Contents


20.3 Earnings per share

The following table provides a reconciliation of the net income figures used for the purpose of calculating basic and diluted earnings per share:

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Net income used for calculating basic earnings per share

4,069

6,300

Impact on net income of converting each category of dilutive financial instrument:

  

- TDIRA (1)

-

193

- OCEANE

25

25

Net income used for calculating diluted earnings per share

4,094

6,518

(1)

At December 31, 2008, the TDIRAs were considered to be anti-dilutive and were therefore excluded from the calculation of diluted earnings per share. At December 31, 2007, the TDIRAs were considered to be dilutive.



The following table shows the weighted average number of ordinary shares used for calculating basic and diluted earnings per share:

 

Year ended

(number of shares)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding - basic

2,611,889,097

2,601,559,094

- TDIRA (1)

-

110,067,701

- OCEANE  

42,260,020

44,688,733

France Telecom stock option plans and similar items (2)

2,419,249

3,901,336

Treasury shares held to cover free share award plans

1,987,449

3,707,995

Weighted average number of shares outstanding - diluted

2,658,555,815

2,763,924,859

(1)

TDIRAs represented 101,965,284 shares at December 31, 2008.

(2)

Diluted earnings per share do not include subscription options whose exercise price is greater than the 12-month average market price.



20.4

Dividends

France Telecom’s Shareholders' Meeting of France Telecom S.A. held on May 27, 2008 decided to distribute to France Telecom shareholders a cash dividend of 1.30 euro per share in respect of 2007. The dividend was paid on June 3, 2008 for a total amount of 3,386 million euros.

In addition, at its meeting of July 30, 2008, the Board of Directors decided to distribute an interim dividend of 60 euro cents per share. This interim dividend was paid on September 11, 2008 for a total amount of 1,563 million euros.

The Annual Shareholders' Meeting of France Telecom held on May 21, 2007 decided to distribute to shareholders a cash dividend of 1.20 euro per share in respect of 2006. The dividend was paid on June 7, 2007 for a total amount of 3,117 million euros.



72



Back to Contents


20.5 Cumulative translation adjustment

At December 31, 2008, the negative translation adjustment was mainly due to the variation of the pound sterling for an amount of (1,465) million euros, including (354) million euros for the goodwill of Orange in the United Kingdom.

At December 31, 2007, the negative translation adjustment was mainly due to the variation of the pound sterling for an amount of (664) million euros, including (141) million euros for the goodwill of Orange in the United Kingdom.


20.6 Gains and losses recognized directly in equity

•

Assets available for sale reserve


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Bull

4

30

Steria

2

11

Freenet AG (ex-MobilCom)

-

11

Other

20

28

Total

26

80


Unrealised gains and losses arising from the revaluation of available-for-sale assets at fair value are recognised in equity. When the loss is recognized as an impairment, the cumulative loss is reclassified from equity to profit or loss. The change in fair value of available-for-sale assets over the year is analyzed as follows:


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

Profit (loss) recognized in equity during the period

(53)

Amount reclassified from equity to profit or loss of the period

(1)

Total

(54)


•

Hedging instruments reserves 

Certain derivatives qualify for hedge accounting and are therefore accounted for as cash flow or net investment hedges. The effective portion of the gain or loss realized on the hedging instrument is recorded under equity in the hedging instruments reserves. For France Telecom S.A., this mainly comprises the effective portion of cross-currency interest rate swaps which qualify for cash flow or net investment hedge accounting.

When a hedging relationship is discontinued either because the hedging instrument has been wound up or no longer qualifies for hedge accounting, but the hedged item remains on the balance sheet, the portion held in the cash flow hedge reserve is amortized over the remaining term of the hedging relationship as documented at inception.



73



Back to Contents



 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Effective component of cash flow hedges

500

220

Amortization of residual reserve for discontinued hedges

123

(12)

Effective component of net investment hedges

(26)

-

Contribution of France Telecom S.A.

597

208

Contribution of other entities

48

3

Total

645

211


The deferred tax relating to the hedging instruments reserves amounted to:

•

(219) million euros at December 31, 2008, relating to France Telecom S.A.;

•

(74) million euros at December 31, 2007, relating to France Telecom S.A.


20.7 Minority interests

•

Minority interests on the income statement

At December 31, 2008, net income attributable to minority interests mainly related to TP Group (321 million euros) and Mobistar (141 million euros).

At December 31, 2007, net income attributable to minority interests mainly related to TP Group (315 million euros) and Mobistar (144 million euros).

•

Dividends

At December 31, 2008, dividends paid out to minority shareholders mainly related to TP Group (302 million euros), Mobistar (85 million euros), the Senegalese entities (136 million euros) and ECMS (61 million euros).

At December 31, 2007, dividends paid out to minority shareholders mainly related to TP Group (273 million euros), Mobistar (142 million euros), the Senegalese entities (88 million euros) and ECMS (71 million euros).

•

Minority interests reflected on the balance sheet

At December 31, 2008, minority shareholders mainly related to TP Group (1,679 million euros), the Spanish entities (710 million euros), the Senegalese entities (475 million euros) and Mobistar (223 million euros).

At December 31, 2007, minority interests mainly related to TP Group (2,000 million euros), the Spanish entities (1,153 million euros), the Senegalese entities (528 million euros), and Mobistar (393 million euros).


74



Back to Contents



Note 21 - Financial liabilities and net financial debt

21.1 Financial liabilities


 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

 (in millions of euros)

Non-current

Current

Total

Non-current

Current

Total

Financial liabilities at amortized cost

31,649

8,236

39,885

32,532

8,694

41,226

Trade payables

498

9,519

10,017

435

9,580

10,015

Deposits received from customers(1)

133

-

133

-

-

-

Financial liabilities at amortized cost

32,280

17,755

50,035

32,967

18,274

51,241

Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss o/w:

495

913

1,408

154

730

884

- Amena price guarantee

-

810

810

-

516

516

- Derivatives held for trading liabilities

492

51

543

137

151

288

- Commitments to purchase minority interests

3

52

55

17

61

78

Hedging derivatives (liabilities) (2)

650

2

652

955

353

1,308

Total financial liabilities

33,425

18,670

52,095

34,076

19,357

53,433

(1)

At December 31, 2007, deposits received from customers were included in other non-current liabilities for 116 million euros.

(2)

See Note 22.


21.2 Net financial debt

Net financial debt as defined and used by France Telecom corresponds to financial liabilities excluding operating payables (translated at the year-end closing rate), less (i) derivative instruments carried in assets held for trading, cash flow hedges, fair value hedges, and net investment hedges, (ii) cash collateral paid on derivative instruments, (iii) cash and cash equivalents and financial assets at fair value, and (iv) deposits paid on certain specific transactions (if the associated liability is included in gross financial debt). Derivatives qualifying as cash flow hedge and net investment hedge are set up to hedge items that are not included in net financial debt (future cash flows, net assets in foreign currencies). However, the market value of these derivatives is included in the calculation. The "effective portion of cash flow hedges" and the "unrealized gain or loss on net investment hedges" are added to net financial debt to offset this temporary difference.


75



Back to Contents



(in millions of euros)

 

Note

December 31,  2008

December 31, 2007

TDIRA

 

21.3

2,860

3,354

Bonds, excluding TDIRA (1)

 

21.4

29,932

32,169

Bank loans

 

21.5

3,670

2,674

Finance lease liabilities (2)

  

1,233

1,525

Commercial papers

  

603

100

Bank overdrafts

  

132

189

Securitization debt (3)

  

1,231

1,111

Other financial liabilities

  

224

104

Financial liabilities at amortized cost excluding trade payables

  

39,885

41,226

Commitments to purchase minority interests

  

55

78

Amena price guarantee

 

29

810

516

Derivatives - liabilities

 

22

1,195

1,596

Derivatives - assets 

 

22

(915)

(152)

Gross financial debt after derivatives

(a)

 

41,030

43,264

Deposits related to QTE leases and assimilated (Assets available for sale)

15

90

105

Deposits related to QTE leases and assimilated (Loans and receivables)

17

14

91

Cash collateral paid

 

17

238

788

Other financial assets at fair value, excluding derivatives

 

18

611

490

Cash equivalents

 

18

3,766

2,722

Cash

 

17

1,034

1,303

Assets included in the calculation of net financial debt

(b)

 

5,753

5,499

Effective portion of cash flow hedges

(c)

 

608

215

Unrealized gain (loss) on net investment hedges

(c)

 

(26)

-

Net financial debt

(a)-(b)+(c)

 

35,859

37,980

(1)

Includes private issues EMTN (Euro Medium Term Notes) of France Telecom S.A. for 1,131 million euros at December 31, 2008 (1,722 million euros at December 31, 2007). Previously, these loans were presented under Bank loans.

(2)

Finance lease liabilities primarily include:

-

Liabilities related to in-substance defeasance operations of Orange in the UK, for 813 million euros at December 31, 2008 (1,116 million euros at December 31, 2007), for which the final settlement payments are due after 2017 (see Note 29).

-

Liabilities related to QTE leases of France Telecom S.A., for 121 million euros at December 31, 2008 (98 million euros at December 31, 2007).

-

At December 31, 2007, liabilities related to QTE leases of Orange in Switzerland for 103 million euros. Orange in Switzerland discontinued this arrangement in 2008.

(3)

Including gross debt carried by securitization vehicles for receivables of France Telecom S.A., Orange France and Orange in the UK.


Debt maturity schedules are presented in Note 27 (Liquidity risk management).



76



Back to Contents


•

Analysis of net financial debt by currency

The table below provides an analysis of net financial debt by currency after hedging derivatives.



(equivalent value in millions of euros at the year-end closing rate)

EUR

GBP

PLN

CHF

USD

Other

Total

Net debt by currency of issue (1)

25,062

3,964

845

522

4,258

1,208

35,859

Nominal amount of currency derivatives

3,341

126

640

457

(4,129)

(435)

-

Net financial debt by currency after taking into account the nominal amount of derivatives

28,403

4,090

1,485

979

129

773

35,859

(1)

Including the market value of derivatives in local currency.


•

Analysis of net financial debt by entity

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

France Telecom S.A.

30,195

32,392

TP Group

1,300

1,512

FT España

1,268

1,426

Securitization debt

1,231

1,111

Other

1,865

1,539

Total

35,859

37,980


21.3 Perpetual bonds redeemable for shares (TDIRA)

On March 3, 2003, under the terms of the MobilCom Settlement Agreement (see Note 30), France Telecom issued 430,705 perpetual bonds redeemable for shares (TDIRA), with a nominal value of 14,100 euros each, representing a total amount of 6,073 million euros, of which 341,910 were reserved for members of the banking syndicate (the "Bank Tranche") and 88,795 for MobilCom's suppliers (the "Supplier Tranche"). The TDIRA are listed on Eurolist by Euronext Paris (international section) and were approved by the Commission des Opérations de Bourse (French Securities Regulator) on February 24, 2003.

They are redeemable for new France Telecom ordinary shares, at any time at the holders' request or, under certain conditions as described in the appropriate information memorandum, at France Telecom's initiative based on a ratio of 444.5073 shares for one TDIRA for the Bank Tranche (i.e. redemption price of 31.72 euros) and 376.5616 shares for one TDIRA for the Supplier Tranche (i.e. redemption price of 37.44 euros), as the initial ratio of 300 shares for one TDIRA has been adjusted several times to protect bondholders’ rights. In addition, during the first seven years, the redemption rate for the Bank Tranche of the TDIRA will be adjusted to compensate for any dividend distribution, if these distributions are not otherwise taken into account through another adjustment.

Since January 1, 2006 and until December 31, 2009 inclusive, as France Telecom has fulfilled the credit rating and share price conditions as described in the above mentioned information memorandum, the interest rate on the TDIRAs has been 5.25%. It will be 3-month Euribor + 2.5% thereafter. The interest is recorded on an annual basis in the income statement. On January 2, 2009, France Telecom paid a coupon of 171 million euros.

If no dividend payment is voted in the Ordinary Shareholders' Meeting or no interim dividend is paid by the Board of Directors during the 12 months preceding the coupon payment, France Telecom can delay the payment of the coupon. The amount of interest due will bear interest at 12-month Euribor rate until the deferred payments are made. This deferred interest must be paid in full - including the related accrued interests - at the payment date of the coupon following any decision to pay a dividend or interim dividend and before redemption of the TDIRA. When payment is deferred, identified interests and/or capitalized interests are recognized as accrued interests and included in the "TDIRA" line under liabilities.


77



Back to Contents


In 2008, France Telecom redeemed 44,637 TDIRA from the Bank Tranche for a nominal amount of 629 million euros including 517 million euros in respect of the liability component. Taking account of redemptions made since their issue, 230,382 TDIRA remain outstanding at December 31, 2008, including 143,360 for the Bank Tranche and 87,022 for the Supplier Tranche, for a nominal amount of 3,248 million euros.

The TDIRA are classified as hybrid instruments, with the following breakdown at December 31, 2008:

•

a liability component of 2,860 million euros;

•

an equity component before deferred taxes of 1,092 million euros.


The liability component breaks down as follows:

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

Number

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

275,019

3,354

3,609

Redemptions (1)

(44,637)

(517)

(307)

Impact of measuring bonds at amortized cost

 

57

71

Change in accrued interests

 

(34)

(19)

Closing balance

230,382

2,860(2)

3,354

Effective interest rate on the liability component

 

7.51%

8.90%

Interest expense

 

220

232

(1)

In 2008, the redemptions generated an expense of 48 millions euros which represents the difference between amortized cost and the liability/equity breakdown on the redemption date (60 millions euros at December 2007).

(2)

Including an amortized cost of 221 million euros at December 31, 2008 (203 million euros at December 31, 2007).


21.4 Bonds, excluding TDIRA

 The overall effective interest rates on bonds before derivatives amount to:

•

for France Telecom S.A., 6.33% at December 31, 2008 (6.40% at December 31, 2007);

•

for TP Group, 4.72% at December 31, 2008 (6.74% at December 31, 2007).

•

France Telecom S.A. - bonds convertible and/or exchangeable into new or existing France Telecom shares (OCEANE)

These are bonds with a nominal value of 2,581 euros that are convertible and/or exchangeable for new or existing France Telecom shares. They have been redeemable or exchangeable since October 20, 2004, at a rate of 103,621 France Telecom shares per bond, i.e. a conversion price of 24.91 euros per share.The initial ratio of 100 France Telecom shares per bond was adjusted on several occasions to protect the bondholders’ rights. These bonds are classified as hybrid instruments, with the following breakdown at December 31, 2008:

•

a liability component of 659 million euros;

•

an equity component before deferred taxes of 97 million euros.



78



Back to Contents


The liability component breaks down as follows:

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

Number

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Opening balance

445,564

1,142

1,116

Redemptions

(194,177)

(501)

-

Impact of measuring bonds at amortized cost

 

26

26

Change in accrued interests

 

(8)

0

Closing balance

251,387

659 (1)

1,142

Effective interest rate on the liability component

 

5.18%

3.97%

Interest expense

 

18

18

(1)

Including an amortized cost of 55 million euros at December 31, 2008 (70 million euros at December 31, 2007).


Since September 2008, France Telecom has redeemed OCEANE for a nominal value of 501 million euros.

The OCEANE were totally redeemed on January 2, 2009.


79



Back to Contents


•

France Telecom S.A. – other bonds

EMTN private issues are now presented under Bonds. In 2007, they were presented under Bank loans for an amount of 1,722 million euros.


 (in millions of euros)

 

Outstanding at

Initial currency

Initial nominal amount

Maturity

Nominal interest rate (%)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of currency units)

 

 

  

Bonds maturing in 2008

 

 

 

4,610

FRF (3)

1,500

January 25, 2009

TEC10 (1) less 0.75

229

229

EUR (5)

50

May 11, 2009

5.294

50

50

EUR

2,500

December 23, 2009

7.000

2,500

2,500

EUR (5)

300

June 9, 2010

3.813

300

300

FRF (3)

3,000

July 25, 2010

5.700

457

457

EUR

1,000

October 14, 2010

3.000

1,000

1,000

EUR

1,400

November 10, 2010

6.625

1,400

1,400

USD (2)

3,500

 March 1, 2011

7.750

2,432

2,299

GBP (2)

600

March 14, 2011

7.500

614

798

JPY (5)

15,000

May 10, 2011

1.820

119

91

JPY (5)

7,000

May 10, 2011

1.218

55

42

CAD

250

June 23, 2011

4.950

147

173

EUR

750

January 23, 2012

4.625

750

750

EUR (4)

 1,225

February 21, 2012

4.375

1,225

1,000

CHF

400

April 11, 2012

2.750

269

242

GBP

250

May 24, 2012

5.500

263

341

EUR

3,500

January 28, 2013

7.250

3,500

3,500

EUR (4)

750

May 22, 2014

5.250

750

-

CHF

400

December 4, 2014

3.500

269

242

EUR (4)

1,150

October 14, 2015

3.625

1,150

1,000

CAD

200

June 23, 2016

5,500

118

138

EUR (4)

1,900

February 21, 2017

4.750

1,900

1,500

EUR (5)

100

December 4, 2017

2.600

100

100

GBP

500

December 20, 2017

8.000

525

682

EUR (4)

1,550

May 22, 2018

5.625

1,550

-

EUR (4)

465

July 25, 2018

EUR HICP (6)

465

-

GBP

450

November 10, 2020

7.250

472

614

EUR (5)

500

November 13, 2022

4.219

500

500

GBP

350

December 5, 2025

5.250

367

477

GBP (4)

500

November 20, 2028

8.125

525

-

USD (2)

2,500

March 1, 2031

8.500

1,769

1,697

EUR

1,500

January 28, 2033

8.125

1,500

1,500

GBP

500

January 23, 2034

5.625

525

682

GBP

250

March 29, 2037

6.000

263

341

Total other bonds outstanding

28,058

29,255

Accrued interests

827

930

Other adjustments

44

(42)

Total

28,929

30,143

(1)

TEC10: variable-rate (constant benchmark index) with a 10-year maturity, determined by the Comité de Normalisation Obligataire.

(2)

Bonds with a step-up clause (clause that triggers an increase in interest payments if France Telecom's credit rating from the rating agencies drops).

(3)

These bonds, initially denominated in French francs, have been translated into euros.

(4)

Bonds or new tranches issued during 2008.

(5)

EMTN private issues, which were previously presented under Bank loans.

(6)

EUR HICP: Harmonized Index of Consumer Prices, an indicator of inflation and price stability calculated by the European Central Bank.



80



Back to Contents


France Telecom S.A.'s bonds at December 31, 2008 are repayable at maturity, and no specific guarantee has been given in relation to their issuance. Certain bonds may be redeemed in advance, at the request of the issuer.


•

TP Group

(in millions of euros)

  

Outstanding at

Initial currency

Initial nominal amount

Maturity

Nominal interest rate (%)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

(in millions of currency units)

    

Bonds maturing in 2008

   

543

EUR

300

July 5, 2011

4.625

300

300

Total bonds outstanding

300

843

Accrued interests

(1)

(2)

Other adjustments

8

8

Total

307

849


21.5 Bank loans

The table below provides an analysis of bank loans by issuer:

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

TP Group (1)

1,420

523

FT España  (1)

1,140

1,420

ECMS (1)

499

337

France Telecom S.A.

270

175

Other (2)

341

219

Total

3,670

2,674

(1)

Credit line drawdowns.

(2)

Includes 102 million euros of credit lines drawn down at December 31, 2008 (140 million euros at December 31, 2007).


The overall effective interest rates on bank borrowings before derivatives amount to:

•

for TP Group, 6.31% at December 31, 2008 (5.45% at December 31, 2007);

•

for  FT España, 3.04% at December 31, 2008 (4.71% at December 31, 2007);

•

for ECMS, 12.59% at December 31, 2008 (10.21% at December 31, 2007);

•

for France Telecom S.A., 5.46% at December 31, 2008 (6.00% at December 31, 2007).



81



Back to Contents


•

Credit lines

At December 31, 2008, the France Telecom Group has access to credit facilities in the form of bilateral credit lines and syndicated credit lines.


  

Year ended

    

December 31, 2008

 
 

Currency

Amount available in foreign currency

Euro-equivalent

Amounts drawn down

Maturity

  

(in millions)

(in millions)

(in millions of euros)

 

Bank overdrafts

     

- France Telecom S.A.

EUR

150

150

-

-

Syndicated credit lines

     

- France Telecom S.A.

EUR

8,000

8,000

-

June 20, 2012

- TP Group

EUR

550

550

-

April 18, 2010

 

PLN

2,500

602

602

February 20, 2011

 - FT España

EUR

1,140

1,140

1,140

June 30, 2010

- ECMS

EGP

1,050

137

137

April 30, 2013

 

EGP

1,639

214

214

August 14, 2014

 

EGP

1,568

204

135

February 26, 2015

- Orange Slovensko

SKK

6,000

199

60

December 5, 2011

- Other

  

45

40

 

Bilateral credit lines

     

- TP Group

PLN

1,000

241

241

June 30, 2010

 

EUR

117

117

117

June 15, 2012

 

PLN

182

44

44

June 15, 2012

 

PLN (1)

1,391

335

335

September 15, 2013

 

EUR

59

59

59

December 15, 2015

 

USD

18

13

13

January 2, 2021

- FT España

EUR

180

180

-

2009 (2)

- Other

  

31

0

 

Total

  

12,261

3,137

 

(1)

Amounts may be drown in different currencies (zloty, euro, dollar, pound sterling).

(2)

This credit line comprises six tranches of 30 million euros, with maturities between February 15 and December 21, 2009.


Most of the Group's credit lines bear interest at floating rates.

Any specific contingent commitments in respect of compliance with financial ratios are presented in Note 27.4.



82



Back to Contents



Note 22 - Derivative instruments


 

At December 31, 2008

At December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Assets

Liabilities

Net

Assets

Liabilities

Net

Cash flow hedge derivatives

572

(96)

476

11

(379)

(368)

Fair value hedge derivatives

127

(529)

(402)

43

(929)

(886)

Net investment hedge derivatives

-

(27)

(27)

-

-

-

Hedging derivatives

699 (1)

(652)

47

54 (2)

(1,308)

(1,254)

Amena price guarantee (3)

-

(810)

(810)

-

(516)

(516)

Derivatives held for trading

216

(543)

(327)

98

(288)

(190)

Total derivative instruments

915

(2,005)

(1,090)

152

(2,112)

(1,960)

of which foreign exchange impacts

  

(980)

  

(1,774)

of which interest rate impacts

  

700

  

322

(1)

Of which 624 million euros non-current and 75 million euros current.

(2)

Of which 42 million euros non-current and 12 million euros current.

(3)

See Note 29.


22.1 Cash flow hedges

To hedge the exposure of some of their financial cash flows, the subsidiaries of the France Telecom Group have set up risk hedging policies.



Entity


Currency

Hedged nominal amount  

(in millions of currency units)

Maturity date of hedged item

Hedging instrument

Hedged risk

France Telecom S.A.

CAD

250

June 23, 2011

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

Currency risk

TP S.A.

EUR

130

July 5, 2011

Cross-currency swaps and cross-currency interest rate swaps

Currency risk

TP S.A.

EUR

44

June 15, 2012

Cross-currency swaps

Currency risk

TP S.A.

PLN

182

June 15, 2012

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk

France Telecom S.A.

CHF

400

December 4, 2014

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

Currency risk

France Telecom S.A.

CAD

200

June 23, 2016

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

Currency risk

France Telecom S.A.

EUR

350

July 25, 2018

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk (HICP inflation index)

FTImmoH

EUR

96

June 29, 2020

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk

France Telecom S.A.

USD

2,198

March 1, 2031

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

Currency risk



83



Back to Contents


For each hedging relationship, the hedged item has an impact on the income statement:

•

each year on interest payment dates;

•

each year, on recognition of unrealized foreign exchange gains or losses upon revaluation of the nominal amount;

•

at maturity of the hedged item, on recognition of the realized foreign exchange gains or losses upon revaluation of the nominal amount.


To hedge the exposure of some of their operating cash flows (purchase or sale) in foreign currencies, the subsidiaries of the France Telecom Group have set up risk hedging policies.



Entity


Currency

Hedged nominal amount  

(in millions of currency units)

Maturity date of hedged item

Hedging instrument

Hedged risk

Orange Romania

RON

79

2009

Forward purchases - Romanian lei

Operating income in Romanian leu

Orange in the UK

EUR

413

2009

Forward purchases - euros

Purchases in euros

Orange in Switzerland

EUR

58

2009

Forward purchases - euros

Purchases in euros

TP Group

EUR

53

2009/2012

Forward purchases - euros

Payment for UMTS license in euros


For each hedging relationship, the hedged item has an impact on the income statement of 2009.

 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

Gain (loss) recognised in equity during the period

436

Amount reclassified from equity to income for the period

24

Effectiveness recycled to operating income

(2)

Effectiveness recycled to financial income

(22)

Ineffectiveness (finance costs, net)

(5)


As the nominal amount of the issued bonds in foreign currencies is revalued at the year-end closing rate in the financial statements, an unrealized foreign exchange gain or loss on the hedged item is recognized in the income statement. Accordingly, the unrealized foreign exchange gain or loss on the foreign exchange derivatives is recorded directly in the income statement to offset the impact.




84



Back to Contents


22.2 Fair value hedges

The main purpose of the France Telecom Group's fair value hedges is to switch its fixed-rate debt into variable rate debt and, for certain hedges, to convert foreign currency issues into euro issues.


Entity

Currency

Hedged nominal amount  

(in millions of currency units)

Maturity date of hedged item

Hedging instrument

Hedged risk

TP S.A.

EUR

10

July 5, 2011

Cross-currency swaps

Currency risk

France Telecom S.A.

USD

1,500

March 1, 2011

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

 Interest and currency risk

France Telecom S.A.

JPY

15,000

May 10, 2011

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

 Interest and currency risk

France Telecom S.A.

CHF

400

April 11, 2012

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk

France Telecom S.A.

GBP

250

May 24, 2012

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk

France Telecom S.A.

EUR

300

May 22, 2018

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk

France Telecom S.A.

EUR

115

July 25, 2018

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk

(HICP inflation index)

France Telecom S.A.

GBP

350

December 5, 2025

Interest rate swaps

Interest rate risk, partial maturity hedge until December 5, 2010

France Telecom S.A.

GBP

500

January 23, 2034

Interest rate swaps

interest rate risk, partial maturity hedge until January 23, 2011

France Telecom S.A.

GBP

250

March 29, 2037

Cross-currency interest rate swaps

Interest and currency risk, partial maturity hedge until March 29, 2012



 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

Gain (loss) recognised on hedging instruments existing at December 31, 2008

172

Accrued interests

(7)

Gain (loss) recognised on hedging instruments (excluding accrued interests) (1)

179

Gain (loss) recognised on hedged items

(170)

Ineffectiveness (finance costs, net)

9

(1)

Used in effectiveness tests.





85



Back to Contents


22.3 Net investment hedges

In 2008, the France Telecom Group set up derivatives to hedge its foreign exchange risk on its net investment in Switzerland. These are cross currency interest rate swaps for which the foreign exchange component qualified as a net investment hedge.

At December 31, 2008, the hedged nominal amount adds up to 400 million euros for net assets in Swiss francs amounting to 865 millions euros excluding net debt (see Note 27).


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

Gain (loss) recognised in equity during the period

(26)

Amount reclassified from equity to income for the period

-

Effectiveness recycled to income statement

-

Ineffectiveness (finance costs, net)

(1)



86



Back to Contents



Note 23 - Employee benefits

23.1 Key figures


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

Notes

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Pensions and other long-term employee benefit obligations

23.2

591

598

Provision for employment termination benefits

23.3 and 24

897

1,472

Liabilities connected with the employee shareholding plans

 

21

40

Other employer-related payables and payroll taxes due

 

1,647

1,778

Total employee benefit obligations

 

3,156

3,888

Of which non-current employee benefits

 

559

535

Of which current employee benefits

 

1,700

1,881

Of which provisions

 

897

1,472



23.2

 Pensions and other long-term employee benefit obligations

Pensions and other long-term employee benefit obligations, which are estimated taking account for actuarial assumptions, comprise          post-employment benefits and other long-term benefits.

Post-employment benefits include:

•

retirement compensation;

•

other pension plans: the benefits provided under these plans are primarily based on years of service and average compensation, or a monthly retirement benefit amount;

•

benefits other than pensions.

Other long-term benefits granted by France Telecom mainly concern seniority awards and long-term leaves.

France Telecom offers these benefits mostly under defined contribution plans. The Group's obligations under defined contribution plans are limited to the payment of contributions to independant institutions, which are in charge of their administrative and financial management. The expense related to pensions recognized under defined contribution plans amounts to 990 million euros in 2008 (1,017 million euros in 2007).

France Telecom also uses defined benefit plans which, unlike defined contribution plans, create future obligations for the Group. Part of these obligations is pre-financed through employer and employee contributions, which are managed by separate legal entities whose investments are subjected to fluctuations in the financial markets. These entities are generally administrated by joint committees comprising representatives of the Group and of the beneficiaries. Each committee adopts its own investment strategy, which is designed to strike the optimum balance between liabilities to be funded and assets invested, based on specific analyses carried out by external experts. The implementation of the investment strategies is generally carried out by fund managers selected by the joint committees and depends on market opportunities. Assets are mostly invested in listed securities (equities, debt securities, mutual funds), and the use of other asset classes is limited.



87



Back to Contents


The actuarial assumptions used for the main geographic areas, which account for 70% of France Telecom's pension and other long-term employee benefit obligations, are the following:

 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Euro area (1)

  

Discount rate

5.25% to 5.30% (long term)

4.50% (medium term)

5.00% to 5.50% (long term)

4.75% to 5.00% (medium term)

Average expected long-term increase in salaries

2% to 4%

2% to 4%

Long term inflation rate

2%

2%

Expected return on plan assets

4.30%

4.90%

UK (2)

  

Discount rate

6.50%

5.75%

Average expected long-term increase in salaries

3.25%

3.25%

Long term inflation rate

2.75%

3.25%

Expected return on plan assets

6.00% and 7.50%

5.50% and 7.25%

Poland (3)

  

Discount rate

6.00%

5.50%                        

Average expected long-term increase in salaries

3.50%

3.00%

Long term inflation rate

2.50%

2.00%

(1)

Obligations in this area amount to 54% of the Group's total obligations.

(2)

Obligations in this area amount to 9% of the Group's total obligations.

(3)

Obligations in this area amount to 7% of the Group's total obligations.


The discount rates, which are determined by country or geographic area, are based on the yields of top-rated corporate bonds. They have been calculated based on external indices commonly used as a reference. Owing to unusual market conditions in 2008, the Group ascertained that these indices were relevant by analyzing their composition (and primarily, the quality of the issuers). When necessary, the indices including bond issues from certain financial institutions were restated. Due to the lack of a liquid market for corporate bonds in Poland, the discount rate applied is the rate on government bonds.

A 100 basis point fall in the discount rates used in the Euro area would lead to a 38 million euro increase in obligations.

The expected long-term return on plan assets has been determined on a plan-by-plan analysis taking account of the expected return on each type of asset in the portfolio. The expected return rate on each type of asset is estimated using an analysis of changes in the rate of inflation, long-term interest rates and the associated risk premium. These factors are combined and compared to the market to determine long-term return assumptions.



88



Back to Contents


The retirement plan assets are mainly located in Kenya (39%), United Kingdom (26%), Switzerland (20%) and France (11%).

The following table provides a breakdown of France Telecom plan assets:  

 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Plan assets

  

Equities

24.0%

45.1%

Debt securities

33.8%

38.0%

Money market assets

25.3%

10.3%

Real estate

15.6%

5.6%

Other

1.3%

1.0%

Total

100.0%

100.0%


The table below provides details on the movements in value of obligations related to defined benefit plans :


 

Post-employment benefits

Long-term benefits

Year ended



(in millions of euros)

Annuity-based plans

Capital-based plans

Other post-employment benefits

December 31, 2008

December 31,

2007

Benefit obligations at the beginning of the year

348

300

66

251

965

943

Service cost

16

22

1

24

63

70

Discounting cost

17

16

3

3

39

36

Employee contributions

4

-

-

-

4

5

Plan amendments

-

1

-

-

1

17

Curtailments/settlements

(5)

(5)

(1)

(3)

(14)

(14)

Actuarial losses/(gains) arising from changes of assumptions

(19)

(2)

-

-

(21)

(15)

Actuarial losses/(gains) arising from experience

6

1

5

-

12

17

Benefits paid

(31)

(25)

(4)

(33)

(93)

(76)

Changes in the scope of consolidation 

-

3

-

-

3

(6)

Acquisitions/disposals

164

(2)

-

7

169

-

Other (exchange differences)

(51)

(2)

(3)

(6)

(62)

(12)

Benefit obligations at the end of the year (A)

449

307

67

243

1 066

965

- o/w benefit obligations at the end of the year in respect of employee benefit plans that are wholly or partly funded

449

-

-

-

449

348

- o/w benefit obligations at the end of the year in respect of employee benefit plans that are wholly unfunded

-

307

67

243

617

617


89



Back to Contents


Changes in plan assets break down as follows:


 

Post-employment benefits

Long-term benefits

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

Annuity-based plans

Capital-based plans

Other post-employment benefits


December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Fair value of plan assets at the beginning of the year

257

-

-

-

257

246

Actual return on plan assets

(35)

-

-

-

(35)

17

- expected return on plan assets

14

-

-

-

14

13

- actuarial (gains)/losses arising from experience

(49)

-

-

-

(49)

4

Employer contributions

37

-

-

-

37

40

Employee contributions

4

-

-

-

4

5

Settlements

(4)

-

-

-

(4)

(10)

Benefits paid by the fund

(31)

-

-

-

(31)

(27)

Changes in the scope of consolidation 

-

-

-

-

-

-

Acquisitions/disposals

161

-

-

-

161

-

Other (exchange differences)

(48)

-

-

-

(48)

(14)

Fair value of plan assets at the end of the year (B)

341

-

-

-

341

257



The corresponding provisions at end of 2008 are as follows:


 

Post-employment benefits

Long-term benefits

Year ended


(in millions of euros)

Annuity-based plans

Capital-based plans

Other post-employment benefits


December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Net funded status (A)-(B)

108

307

67

243

725

708

Unrecognized actuarial gains/losses

(50)

(43)

(12)

-

(105)

(68)

Unrecognized prior service cost

-

(32)

(3)

-

(35)

(42)

Asset ceiling adjustment

-

-

-

-

-

-

Provisions

64

232

52

243

591

600

Net plan assets

(6)

-

-

-

(6)

(2)

of which current provisions

0

18

3

40

61

83

of which non-current provisions

64

214

49

203

530

517


90



Back to Contents


Changes in provisions can be broken down as follows:


 

Post-employment benefits

Long-term benefits

Year ended


(in millions of euros)

Annuity-based plans

Capital-based plans

Other post-employment benefits

December 31,  

2008

December 31,  

2007

Provision at the beginning of the year

78

214

55

251

598

581

Net periodic pension cost

22

43

4

22

91

111

Employer contributions

(37)

-

-

-

(37)

(40)

Benefits directly paid by the employer

-

(25)

(4)

(33)

(62)

(49)

Changes in the scope of consolidation 

-

3

-

-

3

(6)

Acquisitions/disposals

3

(2)

-

7

8

-

Other

(8)

(1)

(3)

(4)

(16)

1

Provision at the end of the year

64

232

52

243

591

600

Net plan assets

(6)

-

-

-

(6)

(2)


The following table provides a breakdown of the net periodic pension cost:


 

Post-employment benefits

Long-term benefits

Year ended



(in millions of euros)

Annuity-based plans

Capital-based plans

Other post-employment benefits

December 31,

 2008

December 31,  

2007

Service cost

16

22

1

24

63

70

Discounting cost(1)

17

16

3

3

39

36

Expected return on plan assets (1)

(14)

-

-

-

(14)

(13)

Actuarial (gains)/losses

4

2

-

-

6

13

Amortization of unrecognized prior service cost

-

8

-

-

8

10

Impact of curtailments/settlements

(1)

(5)

-

(5)

(11)

(5)

Total

22

43

4

22

91

111

(1)

Items included in the financial income


The total amount of obligations arising from healthcare coverage amounts to 8 million euros at December 31, 2008. A one-point percentage increase or decrease in the assumed healthcare cost trend rate would have had no material impact on the valuation of obligations at December 31, 2008 or on the amount of the expense for 2008.

France Telecom plans to pay 22 million euros during 2009 for its defined benefit plans.



91



Back to Contents


23.3 Provisions for employment termination benefits

Provisions for employment termination benefits are composed of:

•

early retirement plans in France  for civil servants and employees under private contract;

•

other termination benefits.

The assumptions used for early retirement plans granted in France, which account for 99% of France Telecom's obligations for termination benefits, are the following:

 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Early retirement plan – France

  

Discount rate

4.00%

4.75%

Average expected long-term increase in salaries

2.00%

2.00%

Inflation rate

2.00%

2.00%

Due to the remaining duration of the early retirement plan, a reduction in the discount rate would not produce a material impact on the amount of obligations at the end of the year.

The table below provides details of movements in the value of these obligations:

 

Termination benefits

Year ended


(in millions of euros)

Early retirement plan

Other employment termination benefits

December 31,  

2008

December 31,  

2007

Benefit obligations at the beginning of the year

1,466

6

1,472

2,329

Service cost

-

4

4

1

Discounting cost

49

-

49

69

Employee contributions

-

-

-

-

Plan amendments

-

-

-

-

Curtailments/settlements

-

-

-

-

Actuarial losses/(gains) arising from changes of assumptions

26

-

26

(18)

Actuarial losses/(gains) arising from experience

9

-

9

(3)

Benefits paid

(661)

-

(661)

(907)

Changes in the scope of consolidation 

-

(1)

(1)

-

Acquisitions/disposals

-

-

-

-

Other (exchange differences)

-

(1)

(1)

1

Benefit obligations at the end of the year

889

8

897

1,472

- o/w benefit obligations at the end of the year in respect of employee benefit plans that are wholly or partly funded

-

-

-

-

- o/w benefit obligations at the end of the year in respect of employee benefit plans that are wholly unfunded

889

8

897

1,472

Provisions at the end of the year

889

8

897

1,472

of which current provisions

489

5

494

671

of which non-current provisions

400

3

403

801



92



Back to Contents


There are no plan assets associated with termination benefits.


The net periodic cost of these benefits is presented in the table below:

 

Termination benefits

Year ended


(in millions of euros)

Early retirement plan

Other employment termination benefits

December 31,  

2008

December 31,  

2007

Service cost

-

4

4

1

Discounting cost(1)

49

-

49

69

Actuarial (gains)/losses

35

-

35

(21)

Amortization of unrecognized prior service cost

-

-

-

-

Impact of curtailments/settlements

-

-

-

-

Asset ceiling adjustment

-

-

-

-

Total

84

4

88

49

(1)

Item included in the financial income


93



Back to Contents



Note 24 - Provisions

24.1 Provisions analysis






(in millions of euros)



Notes

December 31,  2007

Additions

Utilizations  

Reversals

(releases)


Discounting

Changes in scope,

reclassifications and translation adjustments


December 31, 2008

Early retirement plan

23.3 and 29

1,466

35

(661)

-

49

-

889

Other employment termination benefits

23.3

6

4

-

-

-

(2)

8

Restructuring provisions

24.2

191

149

(128)

(2)

1

(14)

197

Provisions for claims and litigations

30

472

106

(54)

(33)

-

4

495

Provisions for dismantling and restoring sites

24.3

532

-

(23)

-

18

39

566

Other provisions

 

582

186

(129)

(44)

-

(35)

560

Total

 

3,249

480 (1)

(995)

(79) (2)

68

(8)

2,715

o/w non-current provisions

 

1,657

149

(798)

(35)

67

222

1,262

o/w current provisions

 

1,592

331

(197)

(44)

1

(230)

1,453

(1)

Including a negative impact on operating income of 469 million euros

(2)

Including a positive impact on operating income of 79 million euros.




94



Back to Contents


24.2 Restructuring provisions


(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2007

Additions

Utilizations

Reversals (releases)

Discounting

Changes in scope, reclassifications and translation adjustments

December 31, 2008

Employee termination benefits

3

19

(18)

-

-

(1)

3

Site reorganization costs

11

12

(10)

-

-

(1)

12

Other

4

-

-

-

-

1

5

Sub-total PCS (1)  (2)

18

31

(28)

-

-

(1)

20

Employee termination benefits

5

21

(23)

-

-

(1)

2

Other

-

21

-

-

-

-

21

Sub-total HCS (1)  (3)

5

42

(23)

-

-

(1)

23

Employee termination benefits

5

-

(4)

-

-

-

1

Site reorganization costs

29

2

(3)

-

-

(3)

25

Sub-total ECS (1)  (4)

34

2

(7)

-

-

(3)

26

Employee termination benefits

45

52

(34)

(1)

1

(9)

54

Other

2

-

-

(1)

-

-

1

Sub-total TP S.A. (5)

47

52

(34)

(2)

1

(9)

55

Employee termination benefits

26

4

-

-

-

-

30

Site reorganization costs

27

18

(22)

-

-

-

23

Other

34

-

(14)

-

-

-

20

Sub-total France Telecom S.A. (6)

87

22

 (36)

-

-

-

73

Total

191

149

(128)

(2)

1

(14)

197

(1)

Excluding TP S.A. and France Telecom S.A.     

(2)

At December 31, 2008, mainly concerns costs related to vacant leased properties in the United Kingdom.

(3)

At December 31, 2008, mainly concerns costs for FT e-commerce restructuring.

(4)

At December 31, 2008, mainly concerns costs related to vacant leased properties, principally at Equant.

(5)

At December 31, 2008, mainly comprises employee termination costs relating to TP S.A., in accordance with the restructuring plan (concerns approximately 4,900 people from 2008 to 2011).

(6)

At December 31, 2008, mainly comprises:

-

departures in connection with the offer open to French civil servants of secondment within the public sector  (see Note 30.4),

-

costs related to leased properties that have become vacant;

-

contributions to the Works Council in respect of early retirement plans.


24.3 Provisions for dismantling and restoring sites

The measurement of the obligation is based on dismantling costs (on a per-unit basis for telephone poles, terminals and public phones, and on a per-site basis for mobile antennae) incurred by France Telecom to meet its environmental commitments and annual scheduled asset returns for telephone poles and public telephones, and its estimated site departures for mobile antennae. These dismantling costs are calculated on the basis of the identified costs for the current financial year, extrapolated for future years using the best estimate of future trends in prices, inflation, etc., and are discounted at a risk-free rate. Forecasts of estimated site departures or asset returns are revised in light of future changes in regulations or technological requirements.



95



Back to Contents


At December 31, 2008, the provision booked for dismantling and restoring sites mainly covered costs relating to:

•

restoring mobile telephony antennae sites:  237 million euros (215 million euros at December 31, 2007);

•

dismantling telephone poles: 164 million euros (156 million euros at December 31, 2007);

•

management of waste electrical and electronic equipment: 64 million euros (65 million euros at December 31, 2007);

•

dismantling public telephones: 53 million euros (62 million euros at December 31, 2007).



96



Back to Contents



Note 25 - Other liabilities and deferred income

25.1 Other liabilities


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

VAT payable

888

952

Other taxes

352

351

Cable network access fees

606

653

Deferred gains and losses on securities (1)

143

157

Other

711

594

Total

2,700

2,707

Of which other non-current liabilities

711

870

Of which other current liabilities

1,989

1,837

(1)

At December 31, 2008, this item mainly comprises the deferred gain following the merger of FT España, FTOT and Amena for an amount of 115 million euros.



25.2 Deferred income


 

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Prepaid telephone cards

577

634

Service access fees

898

1,000

Loyalty programs

208

128

Deferred revenue

1,017

1,146

Other

63

77

Total

2,763

2,985



97



Back to Contents



Note 26 - Other information relating to share-based payment and similar compensation

The share-based payment expense is presented as follows:


(in millions of euros)

Notes

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Free share award plans

26.1

  

France Telecom –  France Plan

 

36

146

France  Telecom - International Plan

 

19

-

ECMS

 

2

3

Employee shareholding plan

26.2

-

107

Stock option plans

26.3

  

France Telecom 2005

 

14

18

France Telecom 2007

 

9

5

Other

 

2

-

Total

 

82

279

IThe share-based payment expense for 2008 is recognized with a corresponding increase in equity, except for the costs relating to the employee liabilities and the joint social contributions under the international free share award plan (6 million euros), which are recognized in the balance sheet under employee benefits.


26.1 Free share award plans and similar compensation

•

France Telecom S.A. –  France Plan

In 2007, France Telecom granted a free share award plan covering 10.8 million shares. The plan covers approximately 113,000 employees from France Telecom S.A. and most of its majority-owned French subsidiaries.

The free share award plan will vest on April 25, 2009 and the acquisition of the shares is contingent upon :

•

performance conditions: achievement of the cash flow set out in the NExT plan in 2007 and 2008, and cost of the plan to be covered by additional cash flow generated over the same period ; the cash flow performance conditions were met in 2007 and 2008;

•

beneficiaries must be contractually employed by the Group at the end of the vesting period.

The expense recognized in 2008 amounts to 36 million euros, against equity. A further expense estimated at 12 million euros will be recognized over the remaining vesting period until April 25, 2009.

•

France Telecom S.A. –  International Plan

In addition to the free share award plan granted in France, an International Plan has been set up in various countries.

The shares will be awarded on December 4, 2009 (December 4, 2011 in the United Kingdom). In countries were local regulations, tax laws or labor laws do not allow the award of free shares, the beneficiaries of the International Plan will receive a cash amount equivalent to the France Telecom S.A. share price on December 4, 2009.

The vesting conditions for shares and cash equivalent are the same as those applying under the France Plan.

The shares awarded may not be sold for a period of two years after the vesting date (three years for Spain) i.e. before December 4, 2011 (December 4, 2012 in Spain).


98



Back to Contents


The fair value of the plan has been determined using a binomial model based on the following assumptions:


 

Share award plan

Similar compensation plan
(payment in cash)

Accounting grant date of rights (1)

03/18/2008

03/18/2008

Grant date of shares (or cash equivalent)

12/04/2009 or 12/04/2011

12/04/2009

End of non-transferability period

12/04/2011 or 12/04/2012

-

Price of underlying at the grant date of rights

21.50 €

21.50 €

Price of underlying at the closing date

-

19.96 €

Subscription price (zero in the case of free share award plan)

0.00 €

-

Expected dividend payout ratio

6.0%

6.0%

Risk-free yield

3.48%

3.48%

Lending-borrowing rate  (2)

5.24%

-

Fair value per share of benefit granted to employees

17.21 to 17.95

19.13  (3)

(1)

Date of the individual information of beneficiaries.

(2)

If applicable, corresponds to the lending-borrowing rate on France Telecom shares used to calculate the non-transferability cost.

(3)

If the plan involves a cash payment, at each closing date, the per-unit fair value of the benefit granted to employees is adjusted based on changes in actuarial assumptions and on the France Telecom S.A. share price up to the date of payment.


The fair value of the instruments granted represents a total of 46 million euros, including a non-transferability cost of 2 million euros. The non-transferability discount has been estimated by valuing the cost of a hedging strategy, the market variables of which are described above, combining the forward sale of the non-transferable shares and the purchase of an equivalent number of transferable shares for cash, financed by borrowings due at maturity.

An expense of 19 million euros (including social contributions) is recognized at December 31, 2008, with corresponding entries:

•

in equity (13 millions);

•

in employee benefits (liabilities and corresponding social contributions) for the cash-settled portion of the plan (6 millions).

A further expense estimated at 27 million euros will be progressively recognized over the remaining vesting period until December 4, 2011.

•

ECMS

In 2007, ECMS granted a free share award plan covering 417,000 shares which will vest progressively over a period of 40 months.

The expense recognized in 2008 amounts to 2 million euros, with a corresponding entry in equity. A further expense estimated at 1 million euros will be progressively recognized over the remaining vesting period until August 22, 2010.


26.2 Employee shareholding plan

As the French State sold 130 million of France Télécom shares in June 2007, employees and former employees of the France Telecom Group were proposed France Télécom shares and they acquired 14.4 million of them in 2007 (this number will be increased by a maximum of 0.6 million free shares offered by the French State subject to a holding period of three years applicable to the shares acquired under the transaction). As no vesting period was necessary to acquire shares, the full amount of the expense was recognised in 2007, for an amount of 107 million euros.




99



Back to Contents


26.3 Stock option plans


26.3.1 Plans set up in 2008

No new stock option plan was granted during 2008 within the France Telecom Group.


26.3.2 Plans set up before 2008

•

France Telecom S.A. – 2007 plan

On May 21, 2007, France Telecom S.A. granted 10,093,300 stock options to certain executive officers and employees of the Group. The options may be exercised during a period of seven years beginning on May 21, 2010 and ending on May 21, 2017. The exercise price was set at 21.61 euros.

The shares acquired upon exercise of the options are subject to a non-transferability period ending on May 21, 2011. In addition, the options will not vest unless the beneficiaries have been employed by the Group for a period of at least three years beginning on of May 21, 2007.

•

TP S.A. – 2007 plan

TP S.A. granted 6,047,710 stock options to certain executive officers, exercisable for a period of seven years beginning on October 9, 2010 and ending on October 9, 2017.

The exercise price was set at 5.19 euros (by considering the closing exchange rate on December 31, 2008).

•

France  Telecom S.A. – 2005 plan

In 2005, France Telecom S.A. granted stock options to its executive officers and employees. The scope of this plan was enlarged in 2006 following the consolidation of the Amena group. The weighted average exercise price is 23.46 euros.

The options are exercisable for a period of ten years. The vesting period is three years.

•

France Telecom S.A. plan (ex-Wanadoo)

Following the purchase of the minority interests in Wanadoo in September 2004, France Telecom undertook to guarantee the liquidity of the Wanadoo stock option plans by exchanging Wanadoo options for France Telecom S.A. options. These options are exercisable for a period of ten years from 2006.

•

Orange

Orange stock option plans, which have been exercisable since 2006, can be split into four categories:   “International “, “France “, “USA “and   "Sharesave “.

Following the purchase of the minority interests in Orange, France Telecom proposed a liquidity contract to the holders of Orange stock options and, in September 2005, it issued options liquidity instruments to facilitate the delivery of France Telecom S.A.'s shares.


Plan

Number of options granted

Remaining term to maturity (months)

End of vesting period

International

85,693,210

17

2006

France

45,983,363

19 to 49

2006

USA

3,621,755

16

2006

 “Sharesave  UK  Save - 5 years

4,037,379

-

2006

 “Sharesave  UK  Save - 3 years

5,839,507

-

2006

 “Sharesave" Netherlands

232,186

-

2006



100



Back to Contents


26.3.3 Changes in stock option plans

The following table summarizes the stock option plans granted to France Telecom Group employees at December 31, 2008 and December 31, 2007:

 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007


STOCK OPTION PLAN

Number of options

Weighted average exercise price (euros)

Number of options

Weighted average exercise price (euros)

France Telecom plan (2005/2007)

    

Options outstanding at the beginning of the year

23,664,255

22.70

14,551,905

23.46

Granted

-

-

10,093,300

21.61

Exercised

(5,350)

23.46

(91,640)

22.58

Cancelled, lapsed

(1,034,340)

22.72

(889,310)

22.68

Options outstanding at the end of the year

22,624,565

22.70

23,664,255

22.70

France Telecom plan (ex-Wanadoo)

    

Options outstanding at the beginning of the year

4,869,159

20.36

6,880,597

21.82

Exercised

(204,334)

15.31

(1,326,010)

14.99

Cancelled, lapsed

(20,591)

22.07

(685,428)

45.43

Expired

-

-

-

-

Options outstanding at the end of the year

4,644,234

20.57

4,869,159

20.36

Orange plan(1)

    

Options outstanding at the beginning of the year

39,838,976

8.94

57,940,516

8.80

Granted

-

-

-

-

Exercised

(986,339)

7.51

(14,101,219)

8.12

Cancelled, lapsed

(566,098)

9.42

(4,000,321)

9.73

Options outstanding at the end of the year

38,286,539

8.97

39,838,976

8.94

TP S.A. plan

    

Options outstanding at the beginning of the year

6,033,024

6.03

  

Granted

-

-

6,047,710

6.03  

Exercised

-

-

-

-

Cancelled, lapsed

(1,286,922)

6.16  (2)

(14,686)

5.73

Options outstanding at the end of the year

4,746,102

5.19  (3)

6,033,024

6.03

Mobistar plan

    

Options outstanding at the beginning of the year

-

-

1,831

34.15

Granted

-

-

-

-

Exercised

-

-

(1,831)

34.15

Cancelled, lapsed

-

-

-

-

Options outstanding at the end of the year

-

-

-

-

(1)

Due to the issuance of the options liquidity instruments and France Telecom's decision to grant new shares, the exercise of these options results in issuing  new France Telecom S.A. shares.

(2)

Exchange rate used : average rate for 2008.

(3)

Exchange rate used : closing rate at December 31, 2008.



101



Back to Contents


26.3.4 Options exercisable at year-end

Options exercisable at year-end were as follows:


 

Year ended December 31, 2008



STOCK OPTION PLANS

Number of unexercised options at year-end

Weighted average residual vesting period (in months)

Exercise price range

Number of options exercisable at year-end

France Telecom plan (2005/2007)

22,624,565

90

21.61 € - 23.48 €

13,068,815

France Telecom plan (ex-Wanadoo)

4,644,234

38

13.84 € - 48.70 €

4,644,234

Orange plan

38,286,539

26

6.14 € - 10.00 €

38,286,539

TP S.A. plan

4,746,102

105

5.19 €

55,072



 

Year ended December 31, 2007



STOCK OPTION PLANS

Number of unexercised options at year-end

Weighted average residual vesting period (in months)

Exercise price range (euros)

Number of options exercisable at year-end

France Telecom plan (2005/2007)

23,664,255

101

21.61 € - 23.48 €

-

France Telecom plan (ex-Wanadoo)

4,869,159

51

13.84 € - 48.70 €

4,869,159

Orange plan

39,838,976

35

4.30 € - 10.00 €

39,838,976

TP S.A. plan

6,033,024

117

6.03 €

-



102



Back to Contents



Note 27 - Other information on exposure to market risks and financial instruments

France Telecom's Treasury and Financing Committee reports to the Group Management Committee. It is chaired by the Group's Deputy Chief Financial Officer and meets quarterly.

It sets the guidelines for managing the Group's debt, especially its liquidity, interest rate,foreign exchange rate and counterparty risks exposure over the following months, and reviews past management (realized transactions, financial results).


27.1

Interest rate risk management

France Telecom seeks to balance its fixed-rate/variable-rate exposure in euros in order to minimize interest costs by using interest rate firm and conditional derivative instruments such as swaps, futures, caps and floors within limits established by the Treasury and Financing Committee.


Management of fixed-rate/variable-rate debt

In 2008, France Telecom S.A. issued a total debt of 4.3 billion euros with an average maturity of approximately 10 years and a weighted average coupon of approximately 5.94%. Most of the notes issued during the second half 2008 were converted to variable-rate debt owing to prospective declines in interest rates.

At December 31, 2008, 85% of the Group's net debt is at fixed rates, about the same as a year earlier (85.5% at December 31, 2007).

The average maturity of the Group's net debt, excluding TDIRAs, is 7.5 years (7.1 years at end 2007).


Analysis of the Group's sensitivity to changes in interest rates based on probable scenarii

The sensitivity of the Group's financial assets and liabilities to interest rate risk is analyzed only for components of net financial debt. Only these components are interest-bearing and are therefore exposed to interest rate risk.

•

Sensitivity of financial expense

Based on a constant amount of debt and a constant management policy, a 1% rise in interest rates would result in an increase of 38 million euros in financial expense and a 1% fall in interest rates would result in a decrease of 21 million euros.

•

Sensitivity of financial debt

A 1% rise in interest rates would lead to a reduction in the market value of net financial debt after derivatives of approximately 1.50 billion euros, which represents 4% of its market value. A 1% fall in interest rates would lead to an increase of approximately 1.52 billion euros (4% of its market value).

•

Sensitivity of cash flow hedge reserves

A 1% rise in interest rates would reduce the market value of derivatives designated as cash flow hedges and the associated cash flow hedge reserves by approximately 46 million euros, which represents 8% of their current value. Conversely, a 1% fall in interest rates would result in a 58 million euro increase in these reserves, which represents 10% of their current value.




103



Back to Contents


27.2 Foreign exchange risk management

•

Foreign exchange risk of entities

The Group's foreign operations are carried out by subsidiaries that operate in their own country and in their own currency. Their operational exposure to currency risk is therefore fairly limited.

To hedge the exposure of some of their operating cash flows (purchase or sale) in foreign currencies, the subsidiaries of the France Telecom Group have set up risk hedging policies (see Note 22).

•

Translation risk at Group level

Due to its international presence, the France Telecom Group is exposed to foreign exchange risk arising from the conversion of income statements denominated in foreign currencies of its foreign subsidiaries.

The table below summarizes the sensitivity of France Telecom's consolidated income statement to a change of plus or minus 10% in foreign exchange rates against the euro, arising from the conversion of income statements denominated in foreign currencies of its foreign subsidiaries.


 

Contribution to consolidated financial statements

Sensitivity to a change in exchange rates of main currencies against the euro

(in millions of euros)

EUR

and SKK (1)

GBP

PLN

 

USD

Other currencies

Total

+ 10%

- 10%

Revenues

36,417

6,024

5,138

 

1,140

4,769

53,488

1,367

(1,118)

Gross operating margin (2)

13,988

1,242

2,209

 

291

1,669

19,399

416

(340)

Operating income

7,943

460

969

 

188

712

10,272

180

(147)

(1)

As Slovakia adopted the euro on January 1, 2009, the Group is no longer exposed to foreign exchange risk on the Slovak koruna.

(2)

See definition of GOM in Note 2.

France Telecom set up euro-zloty and euro-pound sterling economic hedges at Group level in 2008 to reduce the foreign exchange risk related to the conversion of operating cash flows from Poland and the United Kingdom.

•

Foreign exchange risk at finance cost level

The Group's subsidiaries finance themselves in their functional currency whenever possible.

France Telecom S.A. generally hedges its foreign currency issues with derivatives or with assets in the same currency.

The following table provides details of the exposure to foreign exchange rate fluctuations of the net financial debt in foreign currencies of the entities with the highest exposure to currency risks. It also shows the sensitivity of these entities to a probable 10% change in the foreign exchange rates of the currencies to which they are exposed.


 

Currency exposure

Sensitivity to a change in foreign exchange rates against the euro or the zloty (in millions of euros)


(in millions of currency units)

USD

GBP

CHF

DKK

PLN

EUR

Total converted

in euros

Change

+ 10%

Change  

 - 10%

France Telecom S.A.

(17)

(18)

(83)

(1)

(0)

-

(87)

(10)

8

TP Group

(13)

-

-

-

-

(218)

(227)

(21)

25

Total (currency units)

(30)

(18)

(83)

(1)

(0)

(218)

(314)

  

Total (euros)

(22)

(18)

(56)

(0)

(0)

(218)

(314)

  



104



Back to Contents


•

Translation and foreign exchange risks at balance sheet level

Due to its international presence, France Telecom Group's balance sheet is exposed to foreign exchange fluctuations. A rise in the euro affects the translation into the consolidated balance sheet of subsidiaries' assets denominated in foreign currencies. The currencies concerned are mainly the pound sterling and the zloty.

To hedge its largest foreign asset exposures, France Telecom has issued debt in the relevant currencies.


 

Contribution to consolidated financial statements

Sensitivity to a change in all currencies against the euro

 (in millions of euros)

EUR

and SKK (1)

GBP

PLN

CHF

USD

Other currencies

Total

Change  

+ 10%

Change  

 - 10%

Assets excluding net debt by currency (2)

48,163

6,637

6,938

865

51

4,403

67,057

2,099

(1,718)

Net debt by currency (3)

28,403

4,090

1,485

979

129

773

35,859

828

(678)

Net assets by currency

19,760

2,547

5,453 (4)

(114)

(78)

3,630

31,198

1,271

(1,040)

(1)

As Slovakia adopted the euro on January 1, 2009, the Group is no longer exposed to foreign exchange risk on the Slovak koruna.

(2)

Net assets by currency does not include components of net financial debt.

(3)

See Note 21.2.

(4)

Net assets in zlotys attributable to equity holders of France Telecom S.A. amount to 2,715 million euros.

In 2008, the decline in the pound sterling resulted in a 1.2 billion euro decline in gross financial debt.

To limit the translation risk on the balance sheet while taking advantage of attractive financing rates, in 2008, France Telecom secured 400 million euros of net investment hedges in Swiss francs.


27.3

 Liquidity risk management

The France Telecom Group's policy is that it must be able to meet its upcoming loan repayments from available cash and existing credit lines, without recourse to additional financing, for at least the next 12 months.

•

Diversified sources of financing

France Telecom has diversified sources of financing:

•

issues in the short-term securities markets under the commercial papers program;

•

regular issues in the bond markets under the EMTN program;

•

undrawn syndicated credit line of 8 billion euros, maturing in June 2012.

In 2008, France Telecom took advantage of every market window to prepare for refinancing its bond redemptions:

•

in March and April 2008, it issued three bonds for 975 million euros via private issues and reopening existing bond issues;

•

in May 2008, it issued 2 billion euros in bonds in two tranches, a 6-year tranche and a 10-year tranche;

•

in September 2008, it issued 350 million euros in inflation-indexed bonds;

•

in November 2008, it issued i) an additional 300 million euro tranche of the 10-year bond issued in May 2008; ii) an additional 115 million euro tranche of the inflation-indexed bond; and iii) a 500 million pound sterling (approximately 590 million euro) bond issue.

 France Telecom's five-year Credit Default Swap remained relatively stable in 2008, by comparison with the market, with an average spread of approximately 97 basis points.


105



Back to Contents


•

Liquidity of investments

France Telecom invests its cash surplus in negotiable debt securities, mutual funds (OPCVM) and term deposits. As liquidity is the main priority for these short-term investments, most of them are invested for terms of less than three months.

•

Smoothing debt maturities  

Debt maturities are spread consistently over the next years, as evidenced by the average maturity of net debt, which is 7.5 years at the end of 2008.

The following table shows undiscounted future cash flows for each financial liability shown on the balance sheet. The key assumptions used are:

•

Amounts in foreign currencies are translated at the year-end closing rate;

•

Future variable-rate interest is based on the last fixed coupon, except if a better estimate is available;

•

As the perpetual bonds redeemable for shares (TDIRA) are undated, redemptions of the nominal amount are not dated. In addition, from January 1, 2010, interest payable on the bonds will switch to a variable rate over an undetermined period of time (see Note 21.3). Accordingly interests from that date are no longer included as it would not provide relevant information.

•

The maturity dates of revolving credit facilities are the contractual maturity dates.


106



Back to Contents



  

December 31, 2008

H1 2009

H2 2009

(in millions of euros)

Note

 

Nominal amounts

Interests

Nominal amounts

Interests

TDIRA

21

2,860

-

171

-

-

Bonds, excluding TDIRA

21

29,932

930

967

2,500

775

Bank loans

21

3,670

561

108

573

83

Finance lease liabilities

21

1,233

80

26

28

23

Commercial papers

21

603

600

4

-

-

Bank overdrafts

21

132

132

-

-

-

Securitized debt

21

1,231

436

-

795

-

Other financial liabilities

21

224

45

4

46

3

Financial liabilities at amortized cost excluding trade payables

 

39,885

2,784

1,280

3,942

884

Commitment to purchase minority interests

21

55

52

-

-

-

Amena price guarantee

22

810

810

-

-

-

Derivatives - liabilities

22

1,195

41

27

1

42

Derivatives - assets

22

(915)

(84)

(29)

(29)

5

Gross financial debt after derivatives

 

41,030

3,603

1,278

3,914

931

Deposits received from customers

 

133

-

-

-

-

Trade payables

 

10,017

8,728

12

707

11

Total financial liabilities (including derivative assets)

 

51,180

12,331

1,290

4,621

942

(1)

The amounts shown in this column are used to reconcile the nominal amounts breakdown with the balance on the balance sheet.


At December 31, 2008, the liquidity position of France Telecom is sufficient to cover its 2009 commitments linked to the net financial debt:

 

 

Year ended

 

Note

December 31, 2008

Bank overdrafts

21

(132)

Cash and cash equivalents

17 and 18

4,800

Other financial assets at fair value, excluding derivatives

18

611

Available undrawn amount of credit facilities

21

9,124

Liquidity position

 

14,403




107



Back to Contents




2010

2011

2012

2013

2014 and beyond

Undated

Non-cash
items(1)

Nominal amounts

Interests

Nominal amounts

Interests

Nominal amounts

Interests

Nominal amounts

Interests

Nominal amounts

Interests

Nominal amounts

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

3,248

(388)

3,186

1,548

3,670

1,274

2,510

1,137

3,500

1,026

12,748

8,623

 

888

675

137

858

102

509

84

138

50

327

25

 

29

75

45

88

42

103

38

168

32

631

80

 

60

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

3

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

-

8

5

15

5

12

4

11

4

89

13

 

(2)

3,944

1,735

4,631

1,423

3,134

1,263

3,817

1,112

13,795

8,741

3,248

590

3

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 

-

-

63

839

-

106

20

-

38

58

362

 

150

(1)

(18)

(21)

(30)

-

(22)

-

(10)

115

(222)

 

(895)

3,946

1,780

5,449

1,393

3,240

1,261

3,817

1,140

13,968

8,881

3,248

(155)

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

133

-

 

-

104

37

36

11

30

11

29

11

300

138

 

83

4,050

1,817

5,485

1,404

3,270

1,272

3,846

1,151

14,401

9,019

3,248

(72)

            


•

Cash collateral on derivatives

The Group has negotiated cash collateral agreements which may result in monthly amounts payable to or receivable from various banks, representing the mark-to-market impact of all derivative instruments set up with these banks. Consequently, the amount of this cash collateral varies as the value of these operations changes in line with interest and exchange rates, and the thresholds set in the contracts. The amounts do not therefore change on a linear basis or identically by instrument. For France Telecom S.A., the amount of cash collateral is highly correlated with changes in the US dollar given the importance of cross-currency "euro borrower/US dollar lender" swaps in the derivatives portfolio. As the market value of foreign exchange derivatives increased over the period, primarily due to the appreciation in the euro-US dollar exchange rate, the deposit amounts to 238 million euros at December 31, 2008 (788 million euros at December 31, 2007). These deposits are presented under “Loans and other receivables“ (see Note 17).


108



Back to Contents


•

France Telecom's debt ratings

France Telecom's debt ratings did not change in 2008. At December 31, 2008, they are as follows:


 

Standard & Poor's

Moody's

Fitch IBCA

Long-term debt

A-

A3

A-

Outlook

Stable

Stable

Stable

Short-term debt

A2

P2

F1


A portion of the debt (4.8 billion euros of the outstanding balance at December 31, 2008) is subject to step-up clauses. This amount does not include the TDIRA, whose step-up clauses are described in Note 21.

As France Telecom's ratings did not change in 2008, the step-up clauses were not triggered.


27.4 Management of covenants

•

Commitments with regard to financial ratios

Neither France Telecom S.A. nor TP Group has any credit facilities or borrowings subject to specific covenants with regard to financial ratios.

In respect of its 2003 bank financing contract, FT España must comply with the following ratios:

•

a EBITDA to interest expense ratio equal to or greater than 6.00 (EBITDA and interest expense as defined in the agreement contracts with the banks);

•

a net bank debt to EBITDA ratio equal to or less than 2.60 (net bank debt and EBITDA as defined in the contracts);

In respect of its 2005, 2007 and 2008 bank financing contracts, ECMS must comply with the following covenant:

•

a net senior debt to EBITDA ratio equal to or less than 3.00 (net senior debt and EBITDA as defined in the contracts).

In addition, in respect of its 2005 bank financing contracts, ECMS must comply with the following covenant:

•

a net senior debt below 9.7 billion Egyptian pounds (net senior debt as defined in the contracts).

At December 31, 2008, these ratios are fully compliant.

As regards structured financing contracts, several refund scenarii are possible for France Telecom S.A.'s trade receivables securitization programs: (i) standard repayment scenarios on the contractual maturity date of the programs; (ii) accelerated payment, notably in the event that France Telecom's long-term rating is downgraded to BB- or Ba3. In the case of accelerated payment, the securitization conduits cease to participate in financing new receivables, and cash received on receivables previously sold is used to repay holders of beneficial interests progressively.

•

Commitments related to instances of default or material adverse changes

Most of France Telecom's financing agreements, including in particular the 8 billion euro syndicated credit facility set up on June 20, 2005, as well as the bonds issued within the scope of the EMTN program and bilateral credit line of France Télécom S.A., are not subject to cross default or prepayment clauses in the event of a material adverse change. When such clauses exist, accelerated repayment clauses stipulate that default on a given contract does not automatically lead to the accelerated repayment of all other contracts.




109



Back to Contents


27.5

 Credit risk and counterparty risk management

Financial instruments that could potentially subject France Telecom to concentrations of counterparty risk consist primarily of trade receivables, cash and cash equivalents, investments and derivative financial instruments.

France Telecom considers that it has an extremely limited exposure to concentrations of credit risk with respect to trade accounts receivable due to its large and diverse customer base (residential, professional and large business customers) operating in numerous industries and located in many French regions and foreign countries. In addition, the maximum value of the counterparty risk on these financial assets is equal to their recognized net book value. An analysis of credit risk on net trade receivables past due is provided in Note 17.

France Telecom's policy is to invest its cash, cash equivalents and marketable securities with financial institutions and industrial groups with a long-term rating of A-/A3 or above. On the rare occasions when investments are made with lower-rated counterparties, the rating is therefore the best available rating in the country concerned.

France Telecom enters into interest rate and foreign exchange contracts with leading financial institutions. France Telecom also has collateralization agreements with the main counterparties to which it has the highest exposures. France Telecom believes that the risk of these counterparties defaulting is extremely low, since their credit ratings are monitored and financial exposure to any one financial institution is limited. Limits are set based on each financial institution's rating and equity, as well as on periodic analyses carried out by the Treasury and Financing Management Division. The maximum commitment is then determined based on the notional amounts of interest rate and foreign exchange contracts outstanding, to which coefficients are applied that take into account the remaining duration of the operation and the type of transaction involved. These ratios are monitored periodically to reflect the risk. Limits are monitored and reported daily to the Group treasurer and head of dealing room.


27.6

Equity market risk

At December 31, 2008, France Telecom S.A. has no option to purchase its own shares and holds 10,113,380 treasury shares (see Note 20.2). Besides, the Group's exposure to market risk on shares of listed companies included in assets available for sale is not material and investments mutual funds (OPCVM) held at year-end do not contain any equity component. The France Telecom Group is exposed to equity risk through certain retirement plan assets (see Note 23) and, to a limited extent, through free share award plans and similar compensation (see Note 26.1).

Lastly, the representation of France Telecom's assets on the balance sheet may be affected by the market value of its subsidiaries' shares, which is one of the measurement variables used in impairment testing.


27.7

Equity management

France Telecom manages its equity as part of a balanced financial policy, aiming both to ensure flexible access to the capital markets, including for the purpose of investing in value creating projects, and to provide its shareholders with an attractive remuneration. This remuneration determined on the basis of the Group's organic cash flow, while taking account of sector practices.

Organic cash flow is measured as net cash provided by operating activities less acquisitions of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets (net of the change in non-current trade payables) plus the proceeds on disposal of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets. Organic cash flow is not an explicit measure of financial performance under IFRS and may not be comparable to other similarly titled measures for other companies.


This policy has led France Telecom to set targets for net financial debt to EBITDA and shareholders’ remuneration.

EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) corresponds to the operating income before depreciation and amortization and before impairment of goodwill and impairment of non-current assets. In addition to items covered by the Gross Operating Margin (GOM) which was used until now, EBITDA includes employee profit sharing and share-based compensation, gains/losses on disposal of assets, restructuring costs and the share of profits/losses of associates. EBITDA is included as additional information and should not be considered as a substitute for operating income. EBITDA is not a financial performance indicator as defined by the IFRS standards and is not directly comparable to indicators referenced by the same name in other companies.

The targets for 2009 are as follows:

•

The group will continue to reduce debt with a net debt to EBITDA ratio below 2 in order to preserve the Group’s financial independence and flexibility;

•

The group will keep a distribution rate above or equal to 45% of its organic cash flow while maintaining a strong liquidity position.



110



Back to Contents




 

Year ended

 

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Net financial debt to GOM ratio

1.85

1.99

Organic cash flow (in millions of euros)

8,016

7,818

Dividends paid by the parent company (in millions of euros)

(4,949) (1)

 (3,117)

(1)

Including the 1,563 million euro interim dividend paid in 2008.


111



Back to Contents



Note 28 - Other information on the fair value of financial assets and liabilities


The main methods and assumptions used to estimate the fair value of financial instruments are described below.


•

Assets available for sale

The market value of non-consolidated investment securities in quoted companies and listed marketable securities is based on quoted prices at year-end.

Unlisted securities are measured using available information such as transaction value, discounted future cash flows and comparable multiples.

•

Loans and receivables

For cash and cash equivalents, trade receivables and various deposits, France Telecom considers their carrying amount to be the best estimation for market value, due to the short-term maturity of these instruments.

•

Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss 

For very short-term investments such as deposits, certificates of deposit, commercial papers or negotiable debt securities, France Telecom considers that the nominal value of the investment and the related accrued interests, to be the best estimation for market value.

The market value of mutual funds (OPCVM) is the latest settlement value.

•

Financial liabilities at amortized cost 

For trade payables and deposits received from customers, France Telecom considers the carrying value to be the best estimation for market value, due to the high liquidity of these instruments.

The market value of financial liabilities is determined using:

•

market value, for quoted bonds and for convertible, exchangeable and indexed bonds;

•

the present value of estimated future cash flows, discounted using rates available to France Telecom at the end of the period, for unlisted instruments.

The results calculated using the internal valuation model are systematically benchmarked with the values provided by the banks.

•

Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss

The market value of firm or conditional commitments to purchase minority interests is measured in accordance with the clauses of the contracts.

•

Derivative instruments

The market value of the Amena price guarantee is based on a valuation model for c

all options, using the following variables: market value and volatility of the underlying element, maturity of the option and a risk-free interest rate.

The market value of other derivative instruments is determined using the present value of estimated future cash flows, discounted using rates available to France Telecom at the end of the period. The results calculated using the internal valuation model are systematically benchmarked with the values provided by the banks.



112



Back to Contents



  

Year ended

  

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007


(in millions of euros)

Note

Book value

Estimated fair value

Quoted price

Models based on observable variables

Other

Book value

Estimated fair value

Assets available for sale

15

203

203

13

-

190

518

518

Listed investment securities

 

13

13

13

-

-

47

47

Unlisted investment securities

 

96

96

-

-

96

354

354

Other

 

94

94

-

-

94

117

117

Loans and receivables

17

8,814

8,814

-

-

8,814

9,900

9,900

Trade receivables

 

6,163

6,163

-

-

6,163

6,556

6,556

Cash

 

1,034

1,034

-

-

1,034

1,303

1,303

Deposits and sundry items

 

1,236

1,236

-

-

1,236

1,636

1,636

Other

 

381

381

-

-

381

405

405

Assets at fair value through profit or loss, excluding derivatives

18

4,377

4,377

866

-

3,511

3,212

3,212

Mutual funds (OPCVM)

 

866

866

866

-

-

69

69

Other investments

 

3,511

3,511

-

-

3,511

3,143

3,143

Financial liabilities at amortized cost

21

50,035

51,008

1,192

34,336

15,480

51,241

52,237

Financial liabilities

 

39,885

40,858

1,192

34,336

5,330

41,226

42,222

Trade payables

 

10,017

10,017

-

-

10,017

10,015

10,015

Other

 

133

133

-

-

133

-

-

Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss, excluding derivatives

21

55

55

-

-

55

78

78

Net derivatives

22

1,090

1,090

-

280

810

1,960

1,960

Amena price guarantee

 

810

810

-

-

810

516

516

Other derivatives

 

280

280

-

280

-

1,444

1,444


The market value of France Telecom's net financial debt amounts to 36,832 million euros at December 31, 2008 (38,976 million euros at December 31 2007).




113



Back to Contents



Note 29 - Off-balance sheet commitments and contractual obligations



At December 31, 2008, management considers that to the best of its knowledge, there were no existing commitments, other than those described in this note, likely to have a material effect on the current or future financial position of France Telecom.

•

Details of commitments and contractual obligations reflected on the balance sheet

The table below provides a schedule of commitments and contractual obligations reflected on the balance sheet at year-end. It covers gross financial debt after derivatives, early retirement plans, pensions and other post-employment benefits, and the TDIRA equity component.


Commitments and contractual obligations reflected on the balance sheet at December 31, 2008

 

 

Balance sheet at

December 31, 2008

Schedule of undiscounted future cash flows

(in millions of euros)

Note

Total / Ceiling

Before end December 2009

Before end December 2010

Before end December 2011

Before end December 2012

Before end December 2013

As from January 2014

Gross financial debt after derivatives

21

41,030

9,726

5,726

6,842

4,501

4,957

22,849

o/w:

Credit line drawdowns (1)

 

3,137

1,147

756

907

556

172

139

 

OCEANE and TDIRA (2)

 

3,519

830

-

-

-

-

-

 

Finance leases

 

1,233

157

120

130

141

200

711

 

Amena price guarantee (3)

 

810

810

-

-

-

-

-

Early retirement plan

24

889

489

310

120

9

-

-

Pensions and other post-employment benefits

23

591

92

124

106

82

72

362

Total

 

42,510

10,307

6,160

7,068

4,592

5,029

23,211

(1)

Before accounting for the impact of derivatives.

(2)

Maximum amounts assuming no conversion or exchange. As the TDIRAs are undated, redemptions are not included in the schedule.

(3)

Earliest date on which the guarantee may be exercised. See below.


•

Amena price guarantee

At the time of the acquisition by France Telecom, on November 8, 2005, of Auna Operadores de Telecomunicaciones SA, which owns Retevision Movil SA (Amena), those shareholders holding the residual interest in Auna undertook not to sell their shares for a period of three years except in the event of a transfer to a Spanish entity that is not a competitor of France Telecom. At the end of this period, and for an initial period of one month (which was extended by mutual consent until March 5, 2009), the minority shareholders and France Telecom may discuss the potential purchase of these interests. After March 5, 2009, and for a period of six months, certain minority shareholders may decide to sell all of their shares provided that they have received from a third party, a "Bona Fide Offer", defined as an offer at least equal to a floor valuation of the shares as established by two investment banks. After receiving the "Bona Fide Offer", the minority shareholders are required to notify France Telecom, which may decide to acquire the shares or not.

If it acquires the shares, France Telecom has undertaken to pay a price per share at least equal to 90% of the price it paid for the Auna shares in 2005 plus capitalized annual interest of 4.5% (the "Guaranteed Price"). If it does not acquire the shares, France Telecom undertakes to indemnify the minority shareholders, if they actually sell their shares, for any negative difference between the price of the "Bona Fide Offer" and the "Guaranteed Price”. This price guarantee given to minority shareholders has been accounted for as a "synthetic" derivative and measured at fair value at December 31, 2008 for an amount of 810 million euros.



114



Back to Contents


After the six-month period:

•

The minority shareholders may ask for the company's shares to be listed. The value of the shares must then be established by two investment banks. At any moment up to the date a prospectus is filed with the relevant stock exchange authorities, France Telecom can exercise its preemption right on the shares held by the minority shareholders, at a price at least equal to the Guaranteed Price per share.

•

For a period of five years after that date, France Telecom will hold a call option on the shares held by the minority shareholders, which may be exercised at a price equal to the higher of (i) the fair value of the shares or (ii) the Guaranteed Price.


29.1 Leasing commitments

Minimum future lease payments due under non-cancelable leases at December 31, 2008, by maturity


(in millions of euros)

Total  

Before end December 2009


Before end December 2010

Before end December 2011


Before end December 2012

Before end December 2013

As from January 2014

Operating leases (1)

6,184

1,116


1,024

798


651

592

2,003

Finance leases (2)

1,459

157

120

130

141

200

711

(1)

Includes lease payments in the form of overheads (land, buildings, equipment, vehicles and other assets), including those relating to contracts entered into in connection with the sale of a portion of France Telecom's real estate assets (see below).

(2)

Included in financial debt (see Note 21). Including (i) lease payments on France Telecom S.A.'s QTE leases and (ii) 286 million in interest.

As part of the divestment of a portion of its real estate assets in 2001, 2002 and 2003, the Group undertook to re-lease these buildings under commercial operating leases, except for certain assets vacated in the short term. The Group may choose whether or not to renew these leases upon expiry or to replace them by other leases with renegotiated terms and conditions. The rental expense in respect of property sold under these disposal plans amounted to 318 million euros as of December 31, 2008.


29.2 Investment and goods and services purchase commitments

Payments due by maturity at December 31, 2008

(in million of euros)

Total  

Before end December 2009

Before end December 2010

Before end December 2011

Before end December 2012

Before end December 2013

As from January 2014

Investment and  goods and services purchase  commitments

5,564

2,835

942

705

515

244

323

The most significant commitments to purchase goods and services entered into by the Group are contracts to purchase handsets and network equipment, services, content and telecommunication connections.  Such purchases may form part of multi-year contracts. The main commitments at December 31, 2008 relate to the following:

•

the purchase of transmission capacity for an overall amount of 1,132 million euros, of which 688 million euros related to the provision of satellite transmission capacity (comprising contracts with different commitment maturities up until 2015);

•

purchases of mobile telephony equipment for an aggregate amount of 324 million euros;

•

maintaining submarine cables for which France Telecom has joint ownership or user rights, for an estimated overall amount of 156 million euros; and 


115



Back to Contents


•

the acquisition of three out of the twelve lots put up for sale by the French ligue de football professionnel relating to rights to broadcast Ligue 1 matches for the next four seasons. The total amount of commitments amounted to 846 million euros, payable in installments up to 2012;

•

the acquisition of rights to broadcast content, principally from film studios, for the requirements of the Orange Cinéma Séries Service, for an estimated total amount of 337 million euros (the maturities of these commitments under the different contracts are spread out over time until   until 2014 depending on the contract).


Moreover, in respect of the Group’s largest investments, FT España had committed to investing 368 million euros from January 1, 2006 as part of the program to expand network coverage in rural areas of Spain. As of December 31, 2008, the Group considers that it has achieved the target and that this undertaking has been fulfilled. The bank guarantee relating to this undertaking will be released once the Spanish government has carried out the necessary verifications and notified FT España that it agrees that the undertaking has been fulfilled.

As part of the license award process, the Group has made certain commitments to various government authorities in terms of network coverage, number of subscribers and service quality. Meeting these commitments will require substantial investment expenditure in future years to roll out and enhance the networks. These commitments are not shown in the table above since  they are not quantifiable. Non-compliance with these obligations could result in fines and other sanctions ultimately leading to withdrawal of licenses awarded. Management believes that the Group has the ability to fulfill these commitments to  government authorities.


29.3 Guarantees

29.3.1 Guarantees given in the ordinary course of business


(in millions of euros)

Total / Ceiling

Before end December 2009

Before end December 2010

Before end December 2011

Before end December 2012

Before end December 2013

As from January 2014

Guarantees given to third parties by France Telecom in the ordinary course of business

173

31

6

3

15

21

97


The Group has not provided any material guarantees to cover the commitments of consolidated subsidiaries in which there are significant minority interests.

The Group's main commitments relating to borrowings are set out in Note 27.

Certain investments and other assets have been pledged to, or used as collateral for financial institutions to cover bank borrowings and credit lines (see Note 29.5).

29.3.2 Asset and liability guarantees granted in relation to disposals

As part of the agreements between certain Group companies and the acquirers of certain assets, subsidiaries or investments, the Group is subject to standard warranty clauses relating to assets and liabilities. All material sale agreements provide for ceilings on these warranties.

At December 31, 2008, the main warranties in effect are those granted to:

•

Tower Participations and its subsidiaries as part of the disposal of TDF, with a ceiling of 636 million euros. At December 31, 2008, the only specific warranties outstanding were given in relation to taxation and environmental law;

•

Deutsche Telekom as part of the disposal of its mobile and internet businesses in the Netherlands. The warranties are capped at 260 million euros and will expire in 2009, except for the warranties given in relation to taxation, which are capped at 400 million euros and will expire at the end of the statutory limitation period;

•

As part of the disposals of Casema and Orange Denmark. At December 31, 2008, the only warranties remaining were tax-related.


116



Back to Contents


Management believes that the risk of these warranties being called upon is remote or that the potential consequences of their being called upon are not material with regard to the Group's results and financial position.



29.3.3 Guarantees given to third parties under France Telecom S.A. QTE leases

(in millions of euros)

Total / Ceiling

Before end December 2009

Before end December 2010

Before end December 2011

Before end December 2012

Before end December 2013

As from January 2014

Guarantees given to third parties by France Telecom under France Telecom S.A. QTE leases.

332

-

9

-

10

-

313


As part of cross-leasing transactions ("QTE" leases) with various third parties, France Telecom delivered to investors, and then leased back, certain items of telecommunications equipment. Under these transactions, France Telecom guaranteed investors future payments of rents for a combined maximum of 435 million US dollars at December 31, 2008.

Under these QTE leases, France Telecom also provided counter-guarantees to the banks that granted letters of credit to investors. At December 31, 2008, the cumulative amount of letters of credit was 28 million US dollars, after taking into account  the unwinding of certain transactions unwound in December 2008.

France Telecom considers  the risk that these guarantees will be called to be negligible.


29.4 Commitments to acquire or subscribe to securities  


29.4.1 Unconditional commitments

Under the investment agreement signed with its partners in Orange Uganda in September 2008 (see Note 3), France Telecom has undertaken to participate in the company's financing via a 68 million US dollar share issue to be carried out in three tranches as from May 2009. As such, France Telecom shall be required to subscribe up to its 53% share and may in addition be required to substitute itself for any other shareholders that do not choose to subscribe. The maximum amount of this commitment is therefore 68 million US dollars.

At December 31, 2008, France Telecom had no other material commitment to unconditionally acquire or subscribe to any securities.


29.4.2 Conditional commitments

As part of agreements between France Telecom and its partners within jointly held subsidiaries, France Telecom has conditionally undertaken to purchase shares held by such partners or to subscribe for new share issues or to sell its holdings. At December 31, 2008, the main agreements concerned Mobinil (Egypt), Sonaecom (Portugal) and Orange Austria (ex-One).


(in millions of euros)

 

Total

Before end December 2009

Before end December 2010

Before end December 2011

Before end December 2012

Before end December 2013

As from January 2014

Conditional commitments to acquire or subscribe to securities (1)

 

314

-

6

18

-

-

290

(1)

When the range of maturities spans several periods, the commitment is classified at the earliest maturity date. When the maturity is not fixed, the commitment is classified at the latest maturity date. Mainly comprises Mobinil (Egypt) in the event of a change of control of one of the parties.



117



Back to Contents


•

Mobinil (Egypt)

The shareholders' agreement which governs relationships between France Telecom and Orascom provides that in the event of a change of control of one of the parties, that party shall have a put option over its shares and the other party shall have a call option over the shares. The exercise price of the put options is equal to the market value of the shares, determined on the basis of the share price of ECMS, a listed company whose total market capitalization was 1.8 billion euros on December 31, 2008 and which was 51% owned by Mobinil, which in turn is 71.25% owned by France Telecom. On this basis, France Telecom's maximum commitment at December 31, 2008 amounted to 272 million euros.

The shareholders' agreement governing the relationships between France Telecom and Orascom within Mobinil provides that in the event of serious disagreement between the parties, and in case the matter cannot be amicably resolved, the parties, having acknowledged the deadlock, may enter into a bidding process with a view to acquiring the other party's shares. The initial price offered may not be less than the market value of the shares, determined on the basis of the share price of ECMS. On August 8, 2007, Orascom initiated arbitration proceedings regarding the applicability of this provision (see Note 30).

•

Sonaecom (Portugal)

Under the agreements signed in June 2005 by which France Telecom acquired an interest in Sonaecom, Sonae had a call option and France Telecom had a put option exercisable in the event of the non-renewal of the strategic partnership agreement between the two parties initially fixed at a term of three years. As this strategic partnership was renewed in October 2008 for a further three year period and under new terms and conditions, the options held by France Telecom and Sonae have lapsed.

•

Orange Austria (ex-One)

Upon their acquisition of the entire share capital of Orange Austria (ex-One), the investment fund Mid Europa Partners and France Telecom entered into a shareholders' agreement which contains clauses governing transfer of the shares. Under the agreement, the parties undertake not to sell their holdings for a period of four years as of the acquisition date (i.e. until October 2, 2011). France Telecom has granted Mid Europa Partners a call option over its shares in the company at their market price should France Telecom make acquisitions giving rise to a conflict of interest. Upon expiration of the lock-up period, each shareholder has a right of first refusal over the shares of the other party should that party decide to sell them. France Telecom also has a call option over the shares owned by Mid Europa Partners upon expiration of the lock-up period.


29.5 Commitments relating to employees other than pensions and other post-employment benefits  

Regarding individual training rights for employees of French entities of the France Telecom Group, vested training rights not yet used totaled approximately 5 million hours at December 31, 2008.

In accordance with the accounting policies set out in Note 2, no provisions were recognized relating to statutory training rights in France Telecom's financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2008.




118



Back to Contents


29.6 Assets covered by commitments

The table below demonstrates the extent to which France Telecom has full rights of  use over  its assets at December 31, 2008.


  

Year ended

(in millions of euros)

Note

December 31, 2008

31 December 2007

Assets held under finance leases

29.6.1

602

573

Non-current pledged or mortgaged assets

29.6.2

1,261

1,553

Collateralized current assets

 

210

377

Securitized receivables

 

2,526

2,653

Total

 

4,599

5,156


29.6.1 Assets held under finance leases 

The amount of assets held under finance leases mainly included 143 million euros in respect of Orange’s  in-substance defeasance operation in the United Kingdom at December 31, 2008 (219 million euros at December 31, 2007).


29.6.2 Non-current pledged or mortgaged assets

Non-current pledged or mortgaged assets correspond to assets given as guarantees.


 

Year ended December 31, 2008

(in millions of euros)

Total on balance
sheet line (a)

Amount  of asset pledged
or mortgaged (b)

Percentage

(a) / (b)

 Intangible assets, net (excluding goodwill)

14,451

4

0%

 Property, plant and equipment, net

26,534

11

0%

 Non-current loans and receivables (1)

1,554

1,246

80%

 Other (2)

37,090

- (3)

n/a

Total non-current assets

79,629

1,261

2%

(1)

Including 1,005 million euros (nominal + interest) in the escrow account pursuant to the European Commission proceedings relating to the special French business tax (taxe professionelle) (see Notes 17.2 and 30).

(2)

This item includes net goodwill, interests accounted for by the equity method, assets available for sale and net deferred tax assets.

(3)

The value of the Orange Austria (ex-One) shares pledged is equal to zero (see Note 14).

.


119



Back to Contents



Note 30 - Litigation

In the ordinary course of business, France Telecom is involved in a number of legal and arbitration proceedings and administrative actions.

The costs that may result from these proceedings are only accrued for when it is probable that a liability will be incurred and the amount of that liability can be quantified or estimated within a reasonable range. The amount of the provisions recorded is based on a case-by-case assessment of the risk level, and events arising during the course of legal proceedings may require a reassessment of this risk.

At December 31, 2008, provisions totalling 495 million euros (compared with 472 million euros at December 31, 2007) were recorded in France Telecom’s accounts to cover all of the litigation proceedings in which it is involved. France Telecom does not provide details of the provisions, as it considers that their disclosure on a case-by-case basis could seriously harm the Group.

The litigation and claims that could have a significant effect on France Telecom’s financial position are described below.


Litigation related to competition law

A number of claims have been issued against France Telecom by competitors for alleged anti-competitive behavior, for which they are generally seeking a cease order. If the claims are upheld, France Telecom may also be ordered to pay fines. Competitors may also claim damages in civil or commercial proceedings for harm caused by these practices.

European Commission procedures and requests for information

In January 2003, the European Commission opened an inquiry into possible State aid in favor of France Telecom. The formal investigation procedure focused in particular on the special French business tax (taxe professionelle) regime resulting from France Telecom’s historical legal status established by the French law of July 2, 1990, to which it was subject from 1991 to 2002.

In its August 2, 2004 decision, the European Commission stated that this regime was incompatible with the European Union Treaty and ordered the French State to recover from France Telecom an amount of aid that it estimated to be between 798 million euros and 1.140 billion euros plus interest.

In January 2005, France Telecom lodged an appeal against this decision with the European Court of First Instance (ECFI). For its part, the French State had filed an equivalent appeal in October, 2004. In October, 2006, the European Commission asked the European Court of Justice (ECJ) to rule that the French authorities had failed to execute its decision.

On October 18, 2007, the ECJ concluded that the French authorities had failed to respect their obligation to execute this decision within the prescribed time limits. Following the October 18 ruling, France Telecom placed in an escrow account, pending the final decision on the substance of the matter, the amount of 757 million euros, increased to 813 million euros on February 6 2008 and to 964 million euros on July 30 2008, following discussions between the French authorities and the Commission staff with the participation of France Telecom.  This amount corresponds to the Commission’s estimate of the supposed state aid but does not imply approval by the French authorities or France Telecom as to whether any state aid occurred, whether it is possible to establish an amount or the estimate made by the Commission staff. The amount in escrow will be transferred to the French State if the appeal of the August 2, 2004 Commission decision should be dismissed by the ECFI. In the contrary event, it will be returned to the full possession of France Telecom.

The oral hearing before the ECFI took place on November 18, 2008.  The tribunal decision is expected in 2009.

Following the oral hearing, the risk assessment in this litigation is unchanged and the risk continues to be classified as a contingent liability as defined by IAS 37 “Provisions, Contingent Assets and Contingent Liabilities”.


•

In December 2001, following a sector inquiry on the conditions for unbundling the local loop and providing access to broadband services in the European Union member states, the European Commission notified Wanadoo of claims arising from the company’s tariffs for the broadband Internet services Wanadoo ADSL and Pack eXtense. In July 2003, the European Commission ordered Wanadoo to pay a fine of 10.35 million euros for abuse of dominant position between March 2001 and October 2002. On January 30, 2007, the ECFI upheld this decision. France Telecom has filed an appeal with the European Court of Justice. A decision is expected in April 2009.


120



Back to Contents


•

On May 20, 2008, the European Commission announced that it had launched formal inquiry proceedings concerning the pension plan for French civil servants employed by France Telecom. This step follows a complaint from Bouygues Telecom initiated in 2002.

The objective and effect of the pension plan implemented by the French law of July 26, 1996 was to bring the financing of the pension plan for French civil servants employed by France Telecom into line with pension plans applicable to employees of France Telecom competitors. As part of the new regime established by the 1996 law, France Telecom made an exceptional payment of 5.7 billion euros to the French State in 1997 and, since then, has made annual contributions in full discharge of its liabilities.

France Telecom considers that the sole effect of the pension plan system established in 1996 is to release the company from a structural disadvantage and that this reform contains no element of state aid.  The company made observations as an intervenor in the proceedings.The European Commission is not bound by any time limit for rendering its decision, but Regulation CE 659/1999 provides a guideline of 18 months following the launch of the procedure.  

•

In September 2008, the European Commission carried out an inspection in the offices of TPSA and of its subsidiary PTK Centertel aimed at gathering evidence of a possible breach of competition law in the broadband market.  At this stage of the proceedings, it is not possible to predict what action the Commission will take as a result of this inspection, given that the European Commission is not bound by any deadline for completing its investigations.  TP S.A. has appealed to the ECFI from the Commission decision ordering this inspection.


Proceedings with national competition authorities

•

Bouygues Telecom Caraïbes and Outremer Telecom brought claims before the Competition Council (Conseil de la concurrence) respectively in July 2004 and July 2005 regarding practices of Orange Caraïbes and of France Telecom in the mobile and fixed to mobile markets in the Caribbean and in French Guyana.  The initial complaint by Bougues Telecom Caraibes resulted in the adoption by the Competition Council of interim injunctions against Orange Caraibes in December 2004.  Further to an appeal against this decision lodged by Orange Caraïbes, on January 28, 2005, the Paris Court of Appeal confirmed the principles behind these injunctions, while extending the timeframe for implementing two of them. An investigation into the substance of the case was opened in December 2005. In May 2007, the Competition Council joined the two proceedings. On August 5, 2008, it issued a number of complaints concerning in particular tariff practices and exclusivity practices with distributors.  A response was filed in November 2008.  The proceedings could resume in 2009.

•

On December 1, 2005, the Competition Council ordered Orange France to pay a fine of 256 million euros for engaging in anti-competitive agreements with SFR and Bouygues Télécom which were said to restrict competition on the mobile telephony market. The criticized practices involved the exchange of strategic information and a market share stabilization agreement between 2000 and 2002. France Telecom paid this fine in 2005. On December 12, 2006, the Paris Court of Appeal rejected Orange France’s appeal, and on June 29, 2007, the French Supreme Court partially overturned the Court of Appeal Decision. Orange France has brought proceedings for a new hearing before the Court of Appeal. The oral hearing before the Court took place on January 20, 2009 and the Court decision is expected to be available on March 11, 2009.

•

On October 10, 2006, Bouygues Telecom filed a claim with the Competition Council relating to practices engaged in by Orange France and SFR in the French mobile telephony market. This complaint resulted in a March 19, 2008 notification of  complaints, followed by a final report on August 7 pointing to the existence, between June 2005 and July 2007, of a price squeeze between the mobile call termination tariff and the retail price of certain offerings for consumers which included unlimited on-net service on Orange and SFR networks.  The hearing before the Competition Council (now the Competition Authority – Autorité de la concurrence) is expected to be held by the end of the first quarter of 2009.  In April 2008, Bouygues Telecom filed a new claim with the Competition Council, concerning the non-residential mobile market.  This claim is currently under investigation.

•

On August 14, 2007, France Telecom was informed that Free had filed a complaint with the Competition Council against France Telecom concerning the rollout of fiber optic networks. This complaint includes a claim for injunctive relief to require France Telecom to provide access to its civil engineering facilities for purposes of implementing very high bandwidth services, and to do so at cost-oriented tariffs, while prohibiting France Telecom from marketing its own retail service offering or rolling out its own facilities outside Paris until such time as these measures are taken.  On February 12, 2008, the Competition Council rejected Free’s request for injunctive relief concerning the conditions of access to existing civil engineering infrastructure established on the public domain for deploying new optical local loops on the residential market (FTTH).  The Competition Council acknowledged that France Telecom had been engaged since October 2007 before the Telecom and Postal Regulatory Authority (ARCEP) in a constructive process to develop an offer to access its cable ducts. It considered that there was no serious and immediate threat to competition justifying the pronouncement of the measures requested. At the same time, it decided to pursue its investigation into the substance of the case.  Parallel to this investigation, France Telecom developed its civil engineering offering while also undertaking working discussions with other operators under ARCEP supervision, concerning the mutualisation of equipment inside buildings.  These discussions resulted in an agreement in December 2008.


121



Back to Contents


•

On September 18, 2008, the Competition Council notified France Telecom of a substantive claim by Bouygues Telecom along with claims for interim measures, for anti-competitive agreements with Apple regarding conditions for distibution of the i-Phone in the French market.  On December 17, 2008, the Council upheld the request for interim measures and in particular ordered the suspension of the exclusivity arrangements between Apple and Orange and its distributors.  The Paris Court of Appeal confirmed his decision on February 4, 2009.  France Telecom has filed an appeal with the Supreme Court.

•

In Switzerland, the Competition Council’s inquiry into mobile call termination charges, which began at the end of 2002, is still pending. On February 16, 2007, the Swiss Competition Council imposed a fine on Swisscom Mobile of 333 million Swiss francs for abuse of dominant position in the call termination market during the period prior to June 2005, at which date Swisscom Mobile significantly reduced its call termination charges. The Council did not sanction Orange or TDC (Sunrise) for their call termination charge practices during that same period. However, the Council opened an inquiry into the period after June 1, 2005. A decision could be handed down in 2009.

•

On February 22, 2007, the Office for Electronic Communications (OEC) imposed a fine of 339 million zlotys (82 million euros) on TP for having established its Internet (neostrada) price list without observing the provision of the Polish law on telecommunication which requires prices to be based on the cost of provision. The European Commission has indicated that the market analysis on which the OEC founded its decision is incorrect. TP considers the regulatory authority erred in challenging its Internet tariffs since they are not defined as regulated services. In March 2007, TP filed an appeal with the Competition and Consumer Protection Court. A hearing planned for November 18, 2008 was postponed and no new hearing date has yet been fixed.

•

In October 2007, the national competition authority in Spain, the CNC, opened an investigation relating to a possible anti-competitive agreement among the country’s three main mobile telephone operators, Movistar, Vodafone and Orange. This investigation follows complaints by consumer associations which allege that the operators agreed among themselves to increase their tariffs as of March 1, 2007. In December 2008, the CNC investigation division recommended to the CNC that it make a finding that an anti-competitive agreement existed, but that it impose no fine on Orange or Vodafone, but only on Movistar.  The CNC decision is expected by June 2009 at the latest.


Civil and commercial proceedings

•

In December 2006, Free brought action against France Telecom before the Paris Commercial Court, claiming compensation for the loss it believes it has suffered due to France Telecom’s anti-competitive practices in the broadband access market between 1999 and 2005. Free accuses France Telecom of having implemented a strategy that, between 2000 and 2002, prevented it from deploying ADSL and recruiting potential new customers to its dial-up customer base, and which, from 2003 to 2005, hampered its development in this market. Free has asked the court to order France Telecom to pay a provisional sum of 500 million euros. In May 2008, in support of its claims, Free filed an economic study which speaks of theoretical damages of 1.9 billion euros.  In December 2008, France Telecom produced an expert economic and financial assessment which concludes that Free has incurred no loss.  France Telecom considers that the claims of Free are unfounded, since Free has been able to take full advantage of the development and dynamism of the French broadband market.

•

In 1991, Lectiel (formerly Filetech) brought proceedings before the Paris Commercial Court claiming anti-competitive practices by France Telecom and demanding that the subscriber directory database be delivered to it without charge.  Following the refusal of its claim in January 1994, Lectiel brought an appeal before the Paris Court of Appeal. Numerous other proceedings were brought which interfered with this main claim, including Lectiel’s claim before the Competition Council which, on September 29, 1998, imposed a fine on France Telecom of 1.52 million euros and ordered it to give access to its directory database at “cost-oriented prices”.  In December 2006, Lectiel increased its monetary claim to 376 million euros and claimed for the delivery without charge of the directory database, together with daily updates, subject to penalties for non-compliance of 1.5 million euros per day.  On September 30, 2008, the Court of appeal rejected all of Lectiel’s claims and ordered it to pay damages of 3.9 million euros to France Telecom for unauthorised use of its database.  On December 23, 2008, the court-appointed liquidator of the company Groupadress, who had intervened in the proceedings, appealed the decision to the Supreme Court.


122



Back to Contents


•

At the end of January 2004, Nerim issued proceedings against Wanadoo France and Transpac (since absorbed into France Telecom S.A.) before the Paris Commercial Court, following a claim against Nerim for unpaid invoices. Nerim claimed not to owe any amounts to Transpac and  further claimed that on the contrary Transpac and Wanadoo engaged in anti-competitive behavior, warranting damages of 57 million euros. In March 2008, Nerim withdrew its claim. This development brought the proceedings to an end.

•

On June 25, 2008, Free brought interim proceedings before the Paris Commercial Court seeking an injunction ordering the suspension of the sale of the «Orange Foot» service which is linked to the subscription for an Orange multi service ADSL access offer. The court rejected the injunction request on July 1, 2008. Free withdrew the appeal it had filed, but brought substantive proceedings seeking to enjoin France Telecom from conditioning the subscription to the Orange Foot service on the purchase of an Orange Internet subscription, together with an order that France Telecom pay damages of 5 million euros, subject to revision. Free considers the amount of its loss to be 54 million euros. Neuf Cegetel joined the proceedings, also claiming damages but calling for an expert report to value its loss. On February 23, 2009, the Paris Commercial Court ordered France Telecom to cease conditioning the linear TV broadcast of Orange Foot on the purchase of an Orange broadband internet subscription. It also appointed a panel of experts to enable it to evaluate the quantum of loss incurred by Free and Neuf Cegetel.  France Telecom considers that separating out the linear TV stream deprives the Orange Foot service of its substance, an integral part of which consists of interactive and non linear functions inseparable from the access element. Based on solid legal and factual arguments, France Telecom has appealed from the decision. Lastly, France Telecom considers that should his decision be upheld, the costs that might arise from remedying the alleged losses would not have a material impact on its financial situation and results; and further considers that it is not possible at this stage to quantify the potential financial statements impact, if the decision were upheld, of off-balance sheet commitments involving the Ligue de Football Professionnel (referred to in Note 29.2).


Other proceedings

Civil and commercial proceedings

•

Three proceedings were brought before German courts relating to the UMTS investment undertaken in Germany in 2000 in partnership with MobilCom. This investment was agreed to on March 23, 2000 under the aegis of the contract known as the “Cooperation Framework Agreement” (CFA), and subsequently was brought to an end on November 20, 2002 by a negotiated settlement, known as the “MobilCom Settlement Agreement” (MCSA). Under the terms of this settlement, France Telecom purchased the Mobilcom receivables held by the bank syndicate members and suppliers at their face value and wrote-off the receivables as well as the repayment of shareholders’ advances made to MobilCom during the previous two years for a total settlement payment of approximately 7 billion euros. These judicial proceedings have been initiated either by the court-appointed liquidator in the personal bankruptcy of the former MobilCom CEO Gerhardt Schmid, or by minority shareholders of MobilCom related to Mr Schmid. The parties are claiming very significant amounts on the basis of the alleged improper enforcement of the CFA and/or violation of German law on the protection of minority interests. The plaintiffs accuse France Telecom in substance of having undertaken the UMTS project and then terminated it, and of having imposed these decisions on MobilCom and its then CEO by means of a supposed “hidden” or “de facto” domination.

The first action was brought in December 2003 before the Kiel Court by Millenium, a minority shareholder of MobilCom owned by Mrs. Schmid-Sindram. In December 2005, Millenium raised its claim to 5.41 billion euros excluding interest in respect of the losses suffered by it and by MobilCom as a result of the so-called de facto domination (see below). On January 30, 2008, the Court held that it was competent and on February 4, 2009, it held an oral hearing on the substance of the case.  Its decision is expected to be rendered during the first half of 2009.

The second action was launched in December 2003 by Mrs. Schmid-Sindram and Mr Marek, another MobilCom minority shareholder, in which they too claimed compensation for loss suffered due to the alleged dominant relationship, which they evaluated at a theoretical supplement to the share price multiplied by the number of shares held by the plaintiffs or possibly by all the shareholders. On August 12, 2005, the Court of Flensburg rejected the claim as unfounded and on August 27, 2008, the Schleswig Court of Appeal confirmed that decision.  Since no appeal to the Supreme Court is possible in this type of procedure, the decision of the Schleswig court is final and the proceedings have come to an end.


123



Back to Contents


The third action was brought before the Frankfurt Court in December 2004 by the court-appointed liquidator in Gerhardt Schmid’s personal bankruptcy. The claim disregards all waivers of rights to legal recourse stipulated in the MCSA, which he claims are null and void, alleging improper enforcement of the CFA as well as de facto domination. In December 2005, the claim was increased to 7.22 billion euros excluding interest, on the basis of a hypothetical reconstruction of MobilCom’s value had the UMTS project been successful. On January 16, 2008, the Court dismissed the claim, considering in particular that the abandonment of court proceedings was valid and that it barred Gerhardt Schmid from all claims.  An appeal is pending before the Frankfurt Court of Appeal.  No hearing date has yet been fixed.

France Telecom considers that all these actions are unfounded and in bad faith.


•

In December 2004, Suberdine and some of its shareholders issued proceedings against Orange France before the Paris Commercial Court. Suberdine, which had participated along with its subsidiaries in the marketing and sale of Orange’s products and services between 1995 and 2003 went into liquidation on December 18, 2003. Suberdine claimed that Orange had unlawfully terminated their business relationship, and attributed to Orange the responsibility for its liquidation. Suberdine’s monetary claims together with those of the shareholders amounted to 778 million euros. In March 2006, the Paris Commercial Court dismissed the shareholders’ claim but ordered Orange to pay Suberdine 12 million euros. Both Suberdine through its voluntary liquidator and Suberdine’s shareholders appealed, while the court-appointed liquidator formally gave notification of the Court’s decision. On November 26, 2008, the Paris Court of Appeal upheld the positions of Orange, holding Suberdine’s appeal to be invalid and that of the shareholders inadmissible and unfounded.  As a result, the court’s March 2006 judgement, having become final, has been executed. On February 24, 2009, Suberdine filed an appeal with the Supreme Court.


Administrative litigation

In November 2000, the SNCF brought proceedings with the Paris Administrative Court in which it claimed payment from France Telecom of compensation set at 135 million euros (excluding interest) for its use of SNCF railway infrastructure between 1992 and the end of 1996.  In addition, the SNCF sought the appointment of an expert to calculate the amount of variable compensation it considered owning to it in addition to the fixed compensation.  According to SNCF calculations, this variable compensation amounted to 352 million euros.  France Telecom does not contest the fact that payment is due for the period since July 29, 1996, but considers that the action is unfounded for the period prior to that date.  On March 11, 2004, the Paris Administrative Court  held the SNCF claims to be inadmissible,  a decision upheld by the Paris Court of Administrative Appeal on May 24, 2007.  The SNCF has lodged an appeal with the Administrative Supreme Court (Conseil d’Etat).  No new developments took place in the proceedings in 2008.


International arbitration

•

In 2001, a dispute arose over the interpretation of a contract for (in the view of TP SA) the sale and installation by the Danish company DPTG of a fiber optical transmission system, known as NSL, for the State-owned Polish Post, Telegraph and Telephone, the predecessor of TP SA. The contract, signed in 1991 and for which work was completed in 1994, provided for payment of part of the contract price by allocating to DPTG 14.8% of certain revenues produced by the NSL for fifteen years from the system’s installation, that is, from January 1994 to January 2009.

In 1999 the parties came into disagreement regarding the calculation of this revenue. Based on the view that a joint venture existed under the terms of the contract, DPTG initiated arbitration proceedings. DPTG’s claims, calculated up to January 2006, amount to 670 million euros excluding interest. In October 2008, DPTG increased the amount of its claim to 840 million euros excluding interest. TP S.A. challenges both the basis of the claim and the amounts claimed by DPTG.

Between 2004 and 2007, the tribunal directed its attention to assessing the revenues that were supposed to have been shared.  In 2008, the tribunal chairman was removed from his functions for lack of impartiality.  Following the appointment of a new chairman and the scheduling of new procedural dates, a hearing on the substantive issues took place in January 2009.  A second hearing is planned for April 2009.  A decision is expected in the course of this year.


124



Back to Contents


•

On March 13, 2007, the minority shareholders of FTML, who hold 33% of the share capital, filed suit against France Telecom in the Paris Commercial Court seeking payment of compensation provisionally estimated at 97 million US dollars. They claim that France Telecom imposed upon its Lebanese subsidiary and against the latter’s interests the settlement agreement of January 12, 2006 under which FTML and its majority shareholder FTMI resolved their disputes with the Lebanese government in connection with the BOT contract for a mobile telephone network in Lebanon, thereby depriving the minority shareholders of their share of the sum of 266 million US dollars awarded to FTML and FTMI by the arbitration rulings of January and April 2005. France Telecom considers that it has at no time taken any action contrary to the best interests of its subsidiary and it regards the claim as entirely unfounded.

•

The shareholders’ agreement governing the relationships between France Telecom and Orascom within Mobinil provides that in the event of serious disagreement between the parties, and in case the matter cannot be amicably resolved, the parties, having acknowledged the deadlock, may enter into a bidding process with a view to acquiring the other party’s shares (see Note 29.4 “Commitments to acquire or subscribe to securities”).

On August 8, 2007, Orascom initiated arbitration proceedings regarding the applicability of this provision to a disagreement for which it had previously launched the bidding process provided for in the shareholders’ agreement. France Telecom considers that the launch of the bidding process is entirely groundless. Orascom claims the transfer in its favor of Mobinil shares and the payment of 160 million dollars in damages. Following the exchange of written briefs by the parties, hearings took place before the arbitral tribunal on September 30 and October 4, 2008.  The arbitral decision is expected in March, 2009.


There are no other governmental, legal or arbitration proceedings, including any proceedings that are pending or threatened of which France Telecom is aware, which may have or have had in the last twelve months a material impact on the company and/or Group’s financial position or profitability.



125



Back to Contents



Note 31 - Related-party transactions

31.1 Members of the Board of Directors and Group Management Committee of France Telecom

The following table shows the compensation disbursed by France Telecom S.A. and the companies it controls to persons who served on France Telecom's Board of Directors or Group Management Committee during 2008 or any part of the year.


 

Year ended

(in euros)

December 31, 2008

December 31, 2007

Short-term benefits excluding employer social security contributions (1)

7,538,617

7,962,258

Employer social security payments on short-term benefits

1,886,695

1,893,757

Post-employment benefits (2)

1,480,357

1,642,186

Other long-term benefits

-

-

Termination benefits

-

4,691,381

Share-based compensation (3)

1,081,364

1,213,091

(1)

In 2008, includes all compensation recognized (gross salaries, bonuses, attendance fees, bonuses, directors' fees and benefits in kind, incentive schemes and profit-sharing) over the period; the 2007 amount included all compensation paid in 2007.

(2)

Service cost.

(3)

Expense recorded in the income statement in respect of stock option plans and employee shareholding plans.


Didier Lombard has waived his right to receive attendance fees.

The total amount of retirement benefits (contractual retirement bonuses and defined benefit supplementary pension plan) provided for in the financial statements at December 31, 2008 in respect of persons who were members of the Group Management Committee at the end of the year, including Didier Lombard, was 7,167,251 euros (6,597,945 euros in 2007).

Following a decision of the Board of Directors approved by the May 27, 2008 Shareholders’ Meeting, in the event the duties of Didier Lombard with the company were terminated, the Board of Directors may decide to grant him a termination settlement of up to 21 months of his compensation calculated on the average of his  gross monthly compensation during the 24 months preceding the date of the Board's decision. This amount would include any settlement granted with respect to the termination of his employment contract currently suspended.

Contracts of other members of the Group Management Committee include a clause providing a contractual termination settlement not exceeding 15 months of their last total gross annual compensation (including the contractual termination benefit).


31.2 Related party transactions

The related party transactions summarized below cover the main transactions carried out in the ordinary course of business with associates, proportionally consolidated companies and companies in which the Chairman of France Telecom's Board of Directors is a member of the Board of Directors, Supervisory Board or Executive Committee.

Telecommunications services provided to French governmental authorities, which are one of France Telecom's largest customers, as well as those to its various local and regional authorities, are provided on an arm's length basis.




126



Back to Contents


31.2.1

Transactions with associates

•

CET

Transactions with Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie relate mainly to promotion and sales of Orange products, services and brands in sales outlets operating under the Photo Service and Photo Station names. Amounts due by CET or by France Telecom S.A. and its subsidiaries are shown down below:


(in millions of euros)

December 31, 2008

Assets

 

- Trade receivables

51

- Loans

32

Liabilities

 

- Trade payables

6

Operating income

 

- Revenues

109

- Operating expenses

81


•

Other associates

Other transactions carried out with associates during the financial year represented less than 5 million euros and are therefore not described below.


•

Transactions with proportionally consolidated companies

Material transactions are shown below:


 

December 31, 2008


(in millions of euros)

Trade receivables

Trade payables

Sales of goods

and

services

Purchases of goods

 and

services

Darty France Telecom

20

27

14

(20)


 

December 31, 2007



(in millions of euros)

Trade receivables

Trade payables

Sales of goods

and

services

Purchases of goods

 and

services

Darty France Telecom

24

32

15

(22)

The data presented above represents the portion which has not been eliminated on consolidation.



127



Back to Contents


31.2.3

 Transactions with companies in which the Chairman of France Telecom's Board of Directors is a member of the Board of Directors, Supervisory Board or Executive Committee


 

December 31, 2008

(in millions of euros)

Trade receivables

Trade payables

Sales of goods

and

services

Purchases of goods

 and

services

Thomson

3

1

10

(1)


 

December 31, 2007

(in millions of euros)

Trade receivables

Trade payables

Sales of goods

and

services

Purchases of goods

and

services

Thomson

4

1

12

(2)


128



Back to Contents



Note 32 - Subsequent events  


None


129



Back to Contents



Note 33 - Fees paid to statutory auditors


As required by Decree No. 2008-1487 of December 30, 2008 supplementing article R.233-14 §17 of the Code de Commerce, the following table shows the amount of auditors' fees included in the Group's consolidated income statement for the year, broken down into audit and certification fees for the consolidated financial statements and fees for advisory and other services rendered for procedures that are directly linked to the statutory audit of the consolidated financial statements. The fees shown for the subsidiaries apply to fully and proportionally consolidated subsidiaries.


 

Deloitte

Ernst & Young

 

Amount

%

Amount

%

(in millions of euros)

2008

2007

2008

2007

2008

2007

2008

2007

Audit

        

- Statutory audit fees, certification, auditing of the accounts

16.9

17.7

95%

98%

18.2

19.9

94%

94%

Issuer

8.9

8.5

50%

47%

8.7

8.4

45%

40%

Fully-consolidated subsidiaries

8.0

9.2

45%

51%

9.5

11.5

49%

54%

- Ancillary assignments and services directly linked to the statutory auditors’ mission

0.9

0.3

5%

2%

1.0

1.1

5%

5%

Issuer

0.3

0.3

2%

2%

0.3

0.4

1%

2%

Fully-consolidated subsidiaries

0.6

 

3%

0%

0.7

0.7

4%

3%

Sub-total

17.8

18.0

100%

99%

19.2

21.0

99%

99%

Other services rendered by auditors’ networks to fully-consolidated subsidiaries

        

- Legal, tax, personnel-related

0.0

0.0

0%

0%

0.2

0.2

1%

1%

- Other

0.0

0.1

0%

1%

0.0

0.0

0%

0%

Sub-total

0.0

0.1

0%

1%

0.2

0.2

1%

1%

Total

17.8

18.1

100%

100%

19.4

21.2

100%

100%


Rules for approving auditors' fees

France Telecom's Audit Committee defines and oversees the auditor selection procedure and submits recommendations on the choice and compensation of the auditors to the Board of Directors. The Audit Committee also reviews policies and rules designed to safeguard the independence of the statutory auditors. It examines their engagement plan and the scope of their audit assignment.

In accordance with the applicable European and US regulations, France Telecom has instituted a policy for pre-approving audit services and other services rendered by the auditors, to safeguard the independence and objectiveness of the auditors. In December 2003, the Audit Committee adopted internal rules to be applied within the Group in this area. These rules stipulate that any audit services and other authorized services are subject to prior approval by the Audit Committee. Approval is granted either on a blanket basis covering a list of specific services, or on a case-by-case basis for all other services. Ancillary services (including those directly related to the audit assignment) that may be subject to securing blanket prior approval are limited as a percentage of audit fees. Services provided above and beyond these limits are subject to specific prior approval. Lastly, the internal rules set out a list of services that are not related to auditing and are prohibited because they would be liable to jeopardize the auditors’ independence.

All services provided by the auditors in 2007 and 2008 were approved, in accordance with these rules, and the Audit Committee was kept informed of the services provided and fees due on a regular basis.




130



Back to Contents



Note 34 - Scope of consolidation

The main changes in consolidation scope in the year ended December 31, 2008 are set out in Note 3. Special-purpose entities included within the scope of consolidation are mainly companies linked to securitization operations. The table below covers the principal legal holdings.


COMPANY

  

COUNTRY

France Telecom S.A.

Country Parent company

 

France

Personal Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Orange S.A.

100.00%

 

France

FTA Telecom CJSC

100.00%

 

Armenia

Mobistar

52.91%

%

 

Belgium

Orange Botswana

53.68%

 

Botswana

Orange Cameroun

99.50%

 

Cameroon

Orange Côte d'Ivoire

85.00%

 

Ivoiry Coast

Orange Holding A/S

100.00%

 

Denmark

Orange Dominica

100.00%

 

Dominica

Telecom España Distribucion S.A. (ex-Amena Movil)

81.62%

 

Spain

FT España (mobile operations)

81.62%

 

Spain

Inversiones en Telecomunicaciones

54.41%

 

Spain

FCC Orange S.A.

100.00%

 

France

Orange Caraïbes

100.00%

 

France

Orange France

100.00%

 

France

Orange Mayotte

100.00%

 

France

Orange Réunion

100.00%

 

France

SPM Télécom

70.00%

 

France

CGBC (TEN)

75.70%

 

France

Orange Bissau (1)

42.33%

 

Guinea Bissau

Orange Guinée (1)

38.10%

 

Guinea

Orange Services India Private Limited

100.00%

 

India

Mobilecom

51.00%

 

Jordan

FTM Liban

67.00%

 

Lebanon

Orange Liechtenstein

100.00%

 

Liechtenstein

VOXmobile

52.91%

 

Luxembourg



131



Back to Contents



Personal Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Orange Madagascar

71.79%

 

Madagascar

Orange Mali (ex-Ikatel) (1)

29.71%

 

Mali

Orange Moldova (ex-Voxtel)

94.31%

 

Moldavia

Orange Niger

80.00%

 

Niger

Orange Uganda Ltd

53.00%

 

Uganda

PTK Centertel (2)

49.79%

 

Poland

Orange Centre Afrique

100.00%

 

Central African Rep.

Orange Dominicana

100.00%

 

Dominican Rep.

Orange Romania

96.82%

 

Romania

Orange Retail Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange 3G Limited

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Holdings Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Personal Communications Services Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Cellular Services Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Global Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Mobiles Services

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Paging

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Payment Handling Services (ex-The Point Telecommunications)  

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Trust of Receivables Orange

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Sonatel Mobiles (1)

42.33%

 

Senegal

Orange Corpsec

100.00%

 

Slovakia

Orange Slovensko

100.00%

 

Slovakia

Orange Sverige

100.00%

 

Sweden

Orange Communications S.A. (“OCH“)

100.00%

 

Switzerland

Orange Network S.A.

100.00%

 

Switzerland

(1)

Sonatel and its subsidiaries are fully consolidated as France Telecom controls the Strategic Committee which makes recommendations to the Board of Directors.

(2)

TP S.A. and subsidiaries (TP Group): France Telecom has the power to appoint the majority of the Supervisory Board members of TP S.A.; TP S.A. and its subsidiaries are therefore fully consolidated.






132



Back to Contents



Personal Communication Services

   

Proportionally consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Irisnet

26.45%

 

Belgium

Mobinil for Telecommunications (1)

71.25%

 

Egypt

Egyptian Company for Mobile Services (ECMS) (2)

36.36%

 

Egypt

Mobinil Invest (2)

37.06%

 

Egypt

Mobinil Services Company (2)

36.33%

 

Egypt

DARTY France Telecom

50.00%

 

France

GETESA

40.00%

 

Equatorial Guinea

Cellplus Mobile Communications Ltd

40.00%

 

Mauritius

(1)

France Telecom Group holds a 71.25% stake in Mobinil for Telecommunications, with the remaining 28.75% owned by Orascom Telecom. Since all executive decisions must be jointly approved by both partners at board level, Mobinil is consolidated by the proportional method.

(2)

ECMS and its subsidiaries are controlled by Mobinil and therefore proportionally consolidated by France Telecom Group SA.



Personal Communication Services

   

Associates consolidated by the equity method

Interest

 

Country

One (PASR 24)

35.00%

 

Austria

Safelayer

13.23%

 

Spain

GIE Preventel

27.90%

 

France

Sonaecom

20.00%

 

Portugal



133



Back to Contents



Home Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Sofrecom Algérie

100.00%

 

Algeria

Sofrecom Argentina

100.00%

 

Argentina

Lightspeed Communications

51.00%

 

Bahrain

Atlas Services Belgium

100.00%

 

Belgium

Orange Belgium

100.00%

 

Belgium

Wirefree Services Belgium

100.00%

 

Belgium

Fimocam

100.00%

 

Cameroon

Orange Cameroon Multimedia Services

99.50%

 

Cameroon

FT R&D Beijing

100.00%

 

China

CI Telcom

45.90%

 

Ivoiry Coast

Côte d’Ivoire Multimedia

45.90%

 

Ivoiry Coast

Wirefree Services Denmark

100.00%

 

Denmark

Autocity Networks

81.62%

 

Spain

Catalana

81.62%

 

Spain

FT España (fixed-line operations)

81.62%

 

Spain

EresMas Interactiva

81.62%

 

USA

FT Participations US

100.00%

 

USA

FTLD USA

100.00%

 

USA

FTP Holding

100.00%

 

USA

FT R&D LLc San Francisco

100.00%

 

USA

FT R&D LLc Boston

100.00%

 

USA

FT North America

100.00%

 

USA

FTP Holdco 1 LLC

100.00%

 

USA

Orange World

100.00%

 

USA

Cityvox

100.00%

 

France

Corsica Haut Débit

100.00%

 

France

EGT

100.00%

 

France

FCC FT S.A. Titricom 1.2

100.00%

 

France

FCC FT S.A. Titricom 1.3

100.00%

 

France


134



Back to Contents



Home Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

FCR

100.00%

 

France

FCR Côte d’Ivoire

90.00%

 

France

FT Capital Development

100.00%

 

France

FT Encaissements

99.99%

 

France

FT IMMO Gestion

100.00%

 

France

FT IMMO GL

100.00%

 

France

FT IMMO Holding

100.00%

 

France

FT Marine

100.00%

 

France

FT Mobiles International

100.00%

 

France

FT Technologies Investissement

100.00%

 

France

France Telecom e-Commerce

100.00%

 

France

France Telecom Lease

100.00%

 

France

Francetel

100.00%

 

France

Immobilière FT

100.00%

 

France

Innovacom Gestion

50.00%

 

France

Nordnet

100.00%

 

France

Orange Assistance (ex-RAPP 31)

100.00%

 

France

Orange Cinema Series (ex-RAPP 35)

100.00%

 

France

Orange Distribution

100.00%

 

France

Orange East-Africa (ex-RAPP 32)

78.50%

 

France

Orange Participations (ex-RAPP 18)

100.00%

 

France

Orange Prestations TV (ex-RAPP 41)

100.00%

 

France

Orange Promotions

100.00%

 

France

Orange Sports (ex-RAPP 24)

100.00%

 

France

Orange Vallée (ex-NEDDI)

100.00%

 

France

RAPP 9

100.00%

 

France

RAPPtel

100.00%

 

France

RAPP 26

100.00%

 

France

Sofrecom

100.00%

 

France

Sofinergie 4

99.78%

 

France

Sofinergie 5

97.94%

 

France

Soft At Home

60.00%

 

France

Studio 37 (ex-RAPP 27)

100.00%

 

France


135



Back to Contents



Home Communication Services (HCS)

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

TP S.A. Eurofinance France S.A. (1)

49.77%

 

France

Telincom Courtage

100.00%

 

France

Viaccess

100.00%

 

France

Wormy (ex-RAPP 34)

100.00%

 

France

W-HA

100.00%

 

France

GOA Games Services Ltd

100.00%

 

Ireland

Orca Interactive

100.00%

 

Israel

FT Japan

100.00%

 

Japan

E-dimension

51.00%

 

Jordan

JIT CO

100.00%

 

Jordan

Jordan Telecom Cie (JTC)

51.00%

 

Jordan

Wanadoo Jordan

51.00%

 

Jordan

Telkom Kenya

40.03%

 

Kenya

Miaraka

100.00%

 

Madagascar

Sofrecom Maroc

100.00%

 

Morocco

Sofrecom Services Maroc

100.00%

 

Morocco

Chamarel Marine Services

100.00%

 

Mauritius

Rimcom

100.00%

 

Mauritius

Telsea

60.80%

 

Mauritius

StarMedia Mexico

80.80%

 

Mexico

MMT Bis

100.00%

 

Moldavia

Atlas Services Nederland

100.00%

 

Netherlands

MMT Telecom Holding BV

100.00%

 

Netherlands

TP Edukacja i Wypoczynek (Exploris) (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Fundacja Grupy TP (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

OPCO Sp zo o (ex-OTO Lublin) (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

ORE (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

PTE TP (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Paytel (ex-Contact Center) (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Sofrecom Polska (1)

100.00%

 

Poland


136



Back to Contents



Home Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

TP EmiTel (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP Internet (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP Invest (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP Med (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP S.A. (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP S.A. Eurofinance (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP S.A. Finance (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

TP Teltech (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Telefon 2000 (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Telefony Podalskie (1)

27.44%

 

Poland

Virgo (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Wirtualna Poska (1)

49.79%

 

Poland

Terravista

81.62%

 

Portugal

OHCS II - Serviços de Internet (ex-Wanadoo Broadband Serviços de Internet)

100.00%

 

Portugal

Ananova Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

FT Participations UK

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

FT R&D Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Freeserve Investments

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Wanadoo Plc

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Austria Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Brand Services Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Direct Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange FURBS Trustees Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Holdings Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Home UK

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange International Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Overseas Holdings No.2

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Orange Pension Trustees Ltd

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Sonatel Business Solutions (2)

42.33%

 

Senegal

Sonatel (2)

42.33%

 

Senegal

Sonatel Multimedia (2)

42.33%

 

Senegal



137



Back to Contents



Home Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Sofrecom Thailand

100.00%

 

Thailand

FCR Vietnam PTE Ltd

74.00%

 

Vietnam

(1)

TP S.A. and its subsidiaries (TP Group): France Telecom has the power to appoint the majority of the Supervisory Board members of TP S.A.; TP S.A. and its subsidiaries are therefore fully consolidated.

(2)

Sonatel and its subsidiaries are fully consolidated as France Telecom controls the Strategic Committee which makes recommendations to the Board of Directors.



Home Communication Services

   

Proportionally consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

DT-FT Italian Holding GmbH

50.00%

 

Germany

Innovacom 3

34.24%

 

France

Call Services Ltd

40.00%

 

Mauritius

Mauritius Telecom

40.00%

 

Mauritius

Telecom Plus Ltd

40.00%

 

Mauritius

Teleservices Ltd

40.00%

 

Mauritius

Vanuatu Telecom Ltd

50.01%

 

Vanuatu




Home Communication Services

   

Associates consolidated by the equity method

Interest

 

Country

Absline Multimedia

38.77%

 

Spain

Store Alcala

40.81%

 

Spain

Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie (CET Group) (1)

48.50%

 

France

Orange BNP Paribas Services (2)

50.00%

 

France

Augere Holdings (Netherlands) BV

22.22%

 

Netherlands

Mainline Communication Group Plc

26.00%

 

United Kingdom

Midland Communication Distribution Ltd

35.00%

 

United Kingdom

(1)

As France Telecom exercises significant influence over Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie, Compagnie Européenne de Téléphonie is accounted for using the equity method.

(2)

As France Telecom exercises significant influence over Orange BNP Paribas Services, Orange BNP Paribas Services is accounted for using the equity method.



138



Back to Contents



Enterprise Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Globecast Africa

100.00%

 

South Africa

Globecast South Africa (Proprietary) Limited

70.00%

 

South Africa

Etrali Allemagne

100.00%

 

Germany

FT Corporate Solutions Australia

100.00%

 

Australia

Silicomp Belgium

96.31%

 

Belgium

Silicomp Benelux

96.31%

 

Belgium

Silicomp Canada Inc

96.31%

 

Canada

Etrali Beijing

100.00%

 

China

Etrali S.A. Spain

100.00%

 

Spain

Etrali North America

100.00%

 

USA

FT Corporate Solutions

100.00%

 

USA

GlobeCast America Incorporated

100.00%

 

USA

Equant Holding US and subsidiaries

100.00%

 

USA

Equant S.A. and subsidiaries

100.00%

 

France

Almerys

64.00%

 

France

CVF

100.00%

 

France

Etrali France

100.00%

 

France

Etrali S.A.

100.00%

 

France

Expertel Consulting

100.00%

 

France

GlobeCast France

100.00%

 

France

GlobeCast Holding

100.00%

 

France

GlobeCast Reportages

100.00%

 

France

Groupe Diwan

99.88%

 

France

Groupe Silicomp

96.31%

 

France

Netia

100.00%

 

France

Newpoint

95.96%

 

France

OB Participations (ex-RAPP 45)

100.00%

 

France

Obiane (ex-Silicomp Réseaux)

95.96%

 

France

SCI Groupe Silicomp

95.51%

 

France

Silicomp Management

96.30%

 

France

Silicomp-AQL

95.93%

 

France

Sétib

100.00%

 

France

Telefact

69.53%

 

France

Etrali HK

100.00%

 

Hong Kong

Silicomp China Limited

96.31%

 

Hong Kong



139



Back to Contents



Enterprise Communication Services

 

 

 

Fully consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

Silicomp India

96.31%

 

India

Etrali Spa

100.00%

 

Italy

GlobeCast Italie

100.00%

 

Italy

Etrali KK

100.00%

 

Japan

Silicomp (Malaysia) SDN BHD

96.31%

 

Malaysia

France Telecom Servicios

100.00%

 

Mexico

Newsforce BV

100.00%

 

Netherlands

EGN BV and subsidiaries

100.00%

 

Netherlands

Equant BV

100.00%

 

Netherlands

Etrali UK

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

GlobeCast UK

100.00%

 

United Kingdom

Etrali Singapore Pte

100.00%

 

Singapore

GlobeCast Asie

100.00%

 

Singapore

Silicomp Asia Pte Ltd

96.31%

 

Singapore

Equant Integration Services S.A. and subsidiaries

100.00%

 

Switzerland

Etrali Suisse

99.17%

 

Switzerland

Telecom Systems

96.31%

 

Switzerland

Feima Limited

96.31%

 

Taiwan

Silicomp Taiwan

96.31%

 

Taiwan



Enterprise Communication Services

   

Proportionally consolidated companies

Interest

 

Country

GlobeCast Australia

50.00%

 

Australia

Neocles Corporate (1)

51.00%

 

France

Silicomp Software Validation

48.16%

 

France

(1)

Neocles Corporate is proportionally consolidated as it is jointly controlled by France Telecom and the minority shareholders.



140



SIGNATURE



Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned, thereunto duly authorized.



   

FRANCE TELECOM

     

Date: March 5, 2009

By:

/S/ Stéphane Pallez

 

Name:

Stéphane Pallez

 

Title:

Group Deputy Chief Financial Officer